An amateur birder recently made it into a science journal for discovering a new bird near a small town south of Altoona. The unusual cross-breed has the plumage of two warbler species, sings like another and has been named after its discoverer.

Lowell Burket, a Pittsburgh attorney, is credited with finding the previously unknown three-species hybrid believed to be the result of a complicated genetic mix that ornithologists had never seen and didn’t think was possible.

A hunter who says he’s fascinated with warblers, Mr. Burket has photographed 34 of the 36 warbler species that frequent Pennsylvania, all on his family’s property near Roaring Spring, which straddles Blair and Bedford counties about 100 miles east of Pittsburgh. In May he took photos and videos of a warbler he thought seemed unusual and recorded its call. He sent his evidence to the Fuller Evolutionary Biology Lab at Cornell University, along with a hypothesis that the bird was the result of a rare cross breeding.

“Five years ago I knew nothing about warblers,” said Mr. Burket. “When I spotted this warbler, I immediately recognized that it was a little different from the Brewster’s warblers that I typically see in fall migration. My attention was also drawn to it because it was the first time that I have seen a Brewster’s in the early spring.”

Advertise with us

He knew the familiar song of the chestnut-sided warblers that had been breeding on the property for four years. When he heard the atypical Brewster’s singing the chestnut-sided song, he knew the bird was different from the rest.

“That was the final clue,” he said.

Cornell sent an ornithological researcher to Roaring Spring. He and Mr. Burket netted the bird, took a blood sample, tagged it and set it free. Two days later Mr. Burket’s theory was confirmed. The new bird was named Burket’s warbler.

In a news release, the Cornell Lab of Ornithology reported the striking yellow, black and white male bird has the physical markings of two distinct types of warblers but sings like an entirely different warbler. According to an analysis published this month in the science journal Biology Letters, the bird’s DNA showed that its mother was a fairly common cross between a golden-winged warbler Vermivora chrysoptera and a blue-winged warbler, sometimes called a Brewster’s warbler Vermivora cyanoptera. Its father, however, was a chestnut-sided warbler Setophaga pensylvanica, a bird taxonomically placed in an entirely different genus.

Among taxonomic categories, “genus” is ranked below “family” and above “species.” For instance, within the cat family Felidae, the African lion is classified Panthera (genus) leo (species), while a South American jaguar is classified Panthera onca.

Advertise with us

The distinction is important among birds but in this case a little “tough to explain,” said Jim Bonner, executive director of the Audubon Society of Western Pennsylvania.

“Hybridization happens frequently in the bird world. As many as 18 percent of bird species can and have hybridized in the wild,” said Mr. Bonner, who was not involved in the bird’s discovery or analysis. “Why this is unusual is that the chestnut warbler is not as closely related [to the other two] as they are to each other. From what we all learned decades ago in school, this shouldn’t happen.”

Mr. Bonner likened the new bird’s genetic history to pairings among more familiar animals.

“If you own a dog you know that all domestic dogs big and small, no matter what they look like, can mate with each other because they are the same species, Canis lupus familiaris,” he said. All canines are of the family Canidae. “So, you have a dog that mates with a wolf, Canis lupis — the same genus, you get a wolf-dog hybrid. Now throw in a red fox, Vulpes vulpes. They’re somewhat related in the family Canidae, but not in the same genus. A wolf-dog-red fox hybrid shouldn’t happen, but that’s what happened among these warblers.”

The populations of blue-winged and chestnut-sided warblers are healthy, and there are plenty of Brewster’s hybrids. But according to Cornell the density of golden-winged warblers is down 66 percent since the 1960s. In the Appalachian region the population has dropped by 98 percent. The Biology Letters study suggested that a female Brewster’s that was not able to find find a suitable golden-winged mating partner may have settled for a chestnut-sided male.

Advertise with us

It is not known whether there are more Burket’s warblers. Typically hybrids are infertile. Mr. Bonner said that even if this male is capable of reproducing, it is uncertain that the oddly marked warbler that sings the wrong song could attract a mate. Female warblers can be extremely discriminating in selecting a male partner, and the decision is made primarily by what they hear in his song.

“But with this new bird,” said Mr. Bonner, “who knows?”

More research is needed. The banded bird was last seen in Roaring Spring in August and is believed to have migrated south for winter.

Mr. Burket says his discovery has been reported in 23 countries including the United States.

“I am actually baffled by that but thrilled at the same time,” he said. “I truly hope my experience inspires other birders. I have no doubt that there are other rare warblers out there, flitting around, just waiting to be spotted.”

Advertise with us

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.