Even in these inflationary times, $2.50 doesn’t seem like a lot of money.
But having it added Thursday to the $22.97 price of a Pennsylvania fishing license — the first fee increase since 2005 — took years of legislative wrangling, tourniquet-level belt tightening at the state Fish and Boat Commission, an audit of the state Game Commission and the forced retirement of Fish and Boat’s executive director.
Last week, Fish and Boat commissioners for the first time set their own license fees, effective when 2023 fishing licenses go on sale Dec. 1. Since 1866, when the commission was founded, license fees had been the responsibility of the state Legislature.
With the exception of funding for occasional infrastructure upgrades, Pennsylvania taxpayers provide no financial support for Fish and Boat.
License and permit fees account for 70% of the user-pay agency’s current $55 million annual budget. A small amount is raised through leases on Fish and Boat properties. Another 25% is funded through the federal Sport Fish Restoration Act of 1950, in which excise taxes on nationwide sales of fishing gear, boat motors and fuel are reapportioned back to the states at proportions determined by the number of fishing licenses sold.
“So, license and permit fees are vital to our funding,” said Fish and Boat spokesman Mike Parker. “The price of everything goes up — what we pay for gas, vehicles, employees, everything. Without occasional license fee increases, there’s no way we can keep up with costs.”
Read More
Over the years, commissioners occasionally would request a fee increase that lawmakers usually accommodated. But by the late 1990s, commissioners found that fishing license fee increases were becoming harder to get.
The Pennsylvania Game Commission, Fish and Boat’s wildlife management counterpart, was struggling within the same impediments to license fee increases. To ensure that financial needs could be met on a timely basis, the agencies independently set up financial reserves to be tapped when the General Assembly was slow to respond to fee increase requests.
Lawmakers soon said they were uncomfortable raising fishing license fees when the agency was sitting on a funding reserve equal to one year’s operating costs.
In 2010, Fish and Boat biologist John Arway became executive director of the agency, convinced that lawmakers were afraid that voting to make fishing more expensive would hurt them at the ballot box. As a result, Mr. Arway said at the time, license fee legislation took years to make it through the General Assembly. And when a new price was finally set, the increase was so high that many anglers were reluctant to buy a license.
“My position was based upon past license sales market performance after historical license increases which showed a 10% to 20% decrease in sales volume, although income generated from license fees increased,” Mr. Arway explained Friday.
Determined to find a reliable long-term funding mechanism, Mr. Arway commissioned Penn State University to develop a new financial plan. He also proposed taxing companies that export bottled water from Pennsylvania and called for state funding of the agency. Neither happened.
Mr. Arway persuaded commissioners to add a $1 charge for a voluntary mentored-youth fishing license — for every one sold the U.S. government reallocated $5 back to Fish and Boat. He gave license holders the option to pay more for an old-school license pin button and added voluntary permits that would enable anglers to support the types of fishing they enjoy. One year, he even reduced the license fee, hoping for an uptick in sales. More licenses were sold, but not enough to solve the agency’s problems
In 2017, Mr. Arway cast his line in the political puddle. He threatened to close two trout hatcheries and stop stocking streams in the districts of lawmakers who opposed a funding plan he supported. A map was posted linking the targeted streams with legislative districts and lawmakers opposed to a license fee increase. It was quickly removed from the Fish and Boat website.
Within days, Fish and Boat commissioners were told there would be no legislative discussion of funding until Mr. Arway was gone. A bill — dubbed the Arway Bill — was introduced in the Senate that set a term limit of eight years for the Fish and Boat executive director. Mr. Arway had marked his eighth year on the job a few weeks earlier.
“When I took that job, I said I’d stick to the science and never play politics. I should have taken my own advice,” said Mr. Arway, who retired in 2018. “The Arway Bill never passed, but it put pressure on the commission and me to retire. I was at the place in my career where I was ready to retire, which is why I took the risks I did. I always say I got the ball to the goal line but couldn’t get it across the goal.”
The Fish and Boat Commission had supported Mr. Arway’s gambit but caved under legislators’ substantial pressure. Commissioner John Mahn, appointed this year to the district that includes Allegheny County, said that while commissioners at the time were put in an impossible position, Pennsylvania anglers had the most to lose.
“I see [Mr. Arway’s forced retirement] was just another way to get it done,” he said. “Look, John is a biologist, a scientist, His background was not politics. He did things that way because from his perspective it was the only way he thought he could get it done.”
With Mr. Arway gone, another problem arose when the self-licensing of Fish and Boat became linked with a similar self-licensing plan for the Game Commission, which was also sitting on a rainy day fund of $150 million. Legislators said its reserves would have to be reduced and that an audit of the agency's finances was necessary before they would address the Fish and Boat problem.
In 2020, lawmakers finally agreed to allow the Fish and Boat Commission to set its own license fees, with conditions. Fish and Boat would have to reduce the size of its reserves, a legislative committee would oversee and approve license fee changes, and a five-year sunset clause would automatically end the self-licensing practice unless overruled by the Legislature.
“When the pandemic hit, fishing license sales went up by 10%,” said Mr. Parker, the Fish and Boat spokesman. “We finally had authority to control our own license fees, and commissioners decided we didn’t need to raise them. This is actually the third license year that we’ve had control of fees, and we’re raising them, by $2.50.”
Pending legislative approval, anglers will pay $25.47 for a resident adult fishing license. The same increase will be applied to most other license categories, as well as trout permits and combination trout/Lake Erie permits. Revenue from those fee increases are expected to generate an estimated $2.5 million annually for the agency’s Fish Fund, which supports fishing-related programs.
Approval was also given for increases in fees for boat titles, licenses and permits. Revenue from those increases are expected to generate an estimated $30,000 annually for the Fish Fund and $1.2 million for the Boat Fund, which pays for boating-related programs.
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.