An angler’s successful ice fishing trip on a regional lake turned into a real fish story when an inaccurate Facebook posting went viral and was repeated by conventional media.

In late February, Daniel Salter of St. Marys in Elk County pulled a big tiger muskie through a little hole at Keystone Power Dam, a 950-acre impoundment in Armstrong County that fills a hydroelectric dam that powers the nearby Keystone Generating Station.

When the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission posted a photo of Salter’s 45½-inch, 25-pound catch on its website and Facebook page, the caption erroneously said it was caught and released at Keystone Lake in Westmoreland County. The centerpiece of Keystone State Park, the lake covers 78 acres near New Alexandria. It was created in 1909 by Keystone Coal and Coke Co. and operated until 1936. The lake and surrounding land were purchased by the state, and in 1945 it reopened as a 1,200-acre camping and fishing destination 35 miles east of Pittsburgh.

Both lakes are stocked with 6-inch tiger muskellunge fingerlings by the state Fish and Boat Commission. The hybrid, typically sterile offspring of a male Northern pike and female muskie, tigers are artificially bred at Fish and Boat hatcheries in Union City, Tionesta and Pleasant Mount. They grow faster than muskies although generally not as big.

Advertise with us

Identified by their distinctive stripes, tiger muskies are less cautious than their purebred parents and more likely to be caught by anglers. The minimum harvest size for muskellunge and tiger muskies is 40 inches. It takes eight years for a tiger to grow to that size, however, and most anglers who target the big predators prefer to catch, photograph and release.

Salter and friends ice fish for big prey throughout the state at waterways known to produce trophies. On Salter’s first visit to Keystone Power Dam, after hours of nothing, the flag on his tip-up tripped.

“I could tell it was a big fish,” he said. “The line was really going out. I waited until it stopped and I set the hook.”

Reeling the line onto the tip-up spool took 15-20 minutes, he said.

“When it got nearer [to the hole] and swam past, I could see how big it was,” Salter said. “I wondered if we could get it through.”

Advertise with us

His biggest catch after a lifetime of trying was photographed and carefully slid back into the lake.

But that’s not the end of the story.

“I never heard of Keystone State Park,” said Salter, who allowed the photo to be released.

A regional TV station spotlighted the catch with the bad information. The Fish and Boat staffer who maintains the agency’s website and Facebook page later said he had no idea southwestern Pennsylvania had two Keystone Lakes just 26 miles apart. While regional newspapers repeated what had been written, the Associated Press newswire service and social media took the story nationwide. On Tuesday, a page-wide photo of Salter and his mislocated tiger muskie made it into Outdoor Life magazine.

News that a 47½-inch tiger muskellunge was caught in a small state park lake shocked many anglers, who probed GPS maps to find the park. Those who called were told by staff the fish wasn’t caught there, compounding the confusion.

Advertise with us

For the record, Salter caught a 25-pound tiger muskellunge in February while ice fishing at Keystone Power Dam in Armstrong County.

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com