The Great Lakes have absorbed profound change for decades. Overfishing and pollution reduced native game fish, and a soup of invasive species upended ecology.

But a cooperative effort among Great Lakes states and provinces has built a world-acclaimed recreational fishery for salmon and steelhead trout whose ancestors roamed the Pacific Ocean and might have considered the Great Lakes puddles.

Few locations along the 9,000 miles (including Canada) of Great Lakes coastline enjoy such ready access to diverse fishing as Niagara County, N.Y. Better known for Niagara Falls, Niagara County makes up New York’s northwest “shoulder,” abutting Lake Ontario to the north and with Lake Erie in its southern backyard. The Niagara River, flowing out of Lake Erie over the famed falls and into Lake Ontario, separates the county from Canada.

“The nice thing about Niagara County’s central position between the two lakes, with access through the Niagara River, is that you have choices under all conditions,” said Frank Campbell, outdoor promotions director for Destination Niagara.

Advertise with us

“If we have a heavy southwest wind and you can’t fish Lake Erie, you can fish Lake Ontario. With a northeast wind, which roils Lake Ontario, you can opt for Erie. And with the more sheltered river running between, weather has to be really extreme for us to be out of options here.”

In the late 1960s, the New York Department of Environmental Conservation responded to change in the lakes with a change of strategy.

They introduced chinook (king) and coho (silver) salmon to Lake Ontario as a predatory check on the invasive alewife, a small herring that was so explosively abundant that its annual die-offs washed ashore and offended tourists with their stench.

The salmon did gobble the alewives into a wobbly balance, but sport fishermen and women also started catching the big silvery predators and loved it, demanding more. Today, New York stocks about 850,000 young salmon in Ontario tributaries annually.

Those fish coupled with some natural reproduction anchor a recreational fishing industry worth $75 million just in New York’s half of Lake Ontario.

Advertise with us

New York, Pennsylvania and Ohio also tried stocking salmon in Lake Erie, but have not fared as well. Lake Erie’s successful transplant is the steelhead, which is the same fish as a rainbow trout. The difference is that rainbow trout are landlocked while steelhead spend their lives in the ocean — or in this case, the Great Lakes — and return inland via tributary streams at spawning time.

Niagara County anglers, charter captains and guides fish for both, plus brown trout and a native lake trout fishery that’s rebounding in both lakes.

“No place else in the country has what we’ve built here in the number, size and diversity of salmonids,” Campbell said. “It’s bloomed into a $30 million economic impact in Niagara County alone. We have 12-month trout and salmon fishing.”

Zane Smith of New Brighton, Beaver County, knows about the size of Lake Ontario salmon.

His 32-pound, 4-ounce king salmon won the grand prize in the 2021 Fall Lake Ontario Counties Trout and Salmon Derby. He fished out of Olcott, Niagara County, in September.

Advertise with us

Another Western Pennsylvania angler, Wade Robertson of Bradford, McKean County, fished the Niagara River with a local guide out of Lewiston, N.Y., in late November.

“The Niagara is big, fast and deep, but our guide knew exactly where the fish would lay,” Robertson said. “I caught two steelhead in the river, then we ran out to ‘the bar’ at the mouth in Lake Ontario and I caught six big lake trout. But I lost the biggest one. It was like being hooked to a truck.”

Campbell said Destination Niagara can also hook anglers up with steelhead guides for New York’s Erie tributaries, but many visitors fish those on their own.

“Anyone coming here to fish should watch our weather for a few days,” said steelhead guide Blake Kowalski. “Watch for a good rain, enough to raise and stain the creeks, then come a couple days later.

“The fresh flow tends to push a surge of fish up out of the lake, and when the water starts to clear and drop, that’s the best time to catch steelhead.”

Advertise with us

Learning to read the water on a steelhead stream is as important as being there at the right time, Kowalski explained.

“Steelhead like to hold and rest in the slower to medium-speed holes. Any hole where you can’t see the bottom, but has current, they’ll be in there,” he said. “Also look for where a boulder forms a downstream eddy, or where the rock splits the current. That will hold fish.”

The Lake Ontario salmon runs are pretty much over by December, Kowalski said, but steelhead can be found in the tributaries of Lake Erie all winter into spring.

Unlike Pennsylvania, New York does not require a special permit to fish for trout or salmon. For out-of-state visitors, only a non-resident fishing license is required, available through the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (www.dec.ny.gov) in intervals of one year, seven days and one day.

“Our Destination Niagara website (www.niagarafallsusa.com) is set up to make it easy for visiting fishermen,” Campbell said. “The contacts for guides, launch ramps, hotels and licensing are all right there. It’s a one-stop site. You don’t have to research multiple sites to find your captain, lodging or a nice restaurant to relax after a day of fishing.”

Advertise with us

Ben Moyer is a freelance writer from Farmington, Pa.