Like most Erie-based fishing charters, Small Program Charters has been booked through summer since spring. Captain Steve Small of Aliquippa, Beaver County, was piloting his 31-foot Tiara yacht with a full complement of anglers when we spoke recently by phone.
“The walleye are everywhere. That’s my fishing report,” said Small, president of the Erie Pennsylvania Charter Boat Association. “Residents [walleye that spend their lives off Erie County] are in close. The migration [of walleye from western Lake Erie] are swimming all the way to North East and beyond.
“Right now,” he said, pausing to check his electronics, “they’re stacked at 40-60 feet down in 50-70 feet of water.”
I told him I was getting contradictory reports about a spotty bite from anglers.
“Not from professional guides, you're not. All the charter boats are killing ’em,” he said. “You’re getting that from novice anglers who don’t know what they’re doing.”
I asked him what most walleye anglers are doing wrong.
Read More
“They don’t know how deep they’re trolling,” said Small. “These fish are currently under us at 40-60 feet. You won’t catch them above that. [Anglers] see the fish marked [on depth finders] and deploy a spread and think that’s where they’re fishing. But they’re not and they don’t know it. Sometimes they luck out and hit the right depth and say the fishing is spotty.”
I expected Small to lose me in a treatise on the complex calculus used by professional fishing guides to accurately calculate trolling depth. In the 21st century, I shouldn’t have been surprised by his response.
“Precision Trolling Data,” he said. “Download the app, put in the details and it does the rest. Most guides use it. That, or something similar. Years of experience trumps any app, of course. You have to factor speed and currents. It's not that simple. The apps are a good starting point.”
He said Great Lakes Walleye University, hosted in Erie each spring by the Erie Pennsylvania Charter Boat Association, is an excellent way to learn how to increase your catch rate for what he called “these toothy critters."
Like all predators, walleye follow the food. Prey fish go where they’re most comfortable, protected by structure or at a depth where the temperature and oxygen content are just right. Sometimes it’s hard to catch a walleye’s attention when a spinner, spoon or harness trolls by 2 feet too deep or in a higher, visually obscured thermal layer. Anglers who boat a few keepers while the guides say they’re “killing ’em” may want to reconsider their calculation of trolling depth.
Traditionally, anglers used the hit-or-miss method. They let out line and approached a submerged slope of a confirmed depth. When the lure hit the slope, they had a usable depth estimate.
Many Lake Erie walleye veterans believe the downrigger counter indicates depth. It does, when the boat is idling still. As the boat moves faster, however, the angle from the rod tip to the water surface changes. The rigger counter shows the cable length, not necessarily lure depth. At various speeds the rigger cable arcs back and runs higher, pulling line that bows at rates determined by its type and weight. The line is attached to a leader that sinks or rises depending upon lure weight, shape and speed. Use of a Dipsy or planer boards also changes the calculation. The lure rushes past a walleye, but at what depth?
Some anglers still use printed depth charts with lines or grids that combine water depth, line length, sinker weight and lure weight to determine depth. The charts can be generally accurate within about 10 feet. But when the ’eyes are picky, 10 feet off target might as well be 100 feet.
If you’ve got the cash, integrated wireless throttle and steering control systems for gas-powered auxiliary outboards calculate dozens of criteria and drive the boat to maximize the potential of any trolling lure.
Somewhere between those extremes are products with advanced angling sophistication that won’t break the bank. Electronic trolling depth calculators can be as simple as a cell phone screen showing a printed depth chart. Software applications designed to work on the angler’s existing smartphone use proprietary algorithms that combine physics and practical testing experience to more accurately calculate lure depth. The most popular are Small’s choice, Precision Trolling Data and Troll Master Depth Calculator app. They’re accessible on Android and Apple phones and programmed for various types of fishing including trolling for Great Lakes walleye.

The Precision Trolling phone app is preloaded with hundreds of popular lures, variations and their weights, as well as the effects on lures of diving planers, sinking lines like lead core and other common trolling devices. Precision Trolling staff send scuba divers to document, confirm and replicate actual diving depths as the lures are functioning underwater.
Open the app and input data including line type, weight and length; GPS boat speed, trolling weight and leader length; and lure weight and profile. Press a button to calculate lure depth. Change any of the criteria and recalculate. When lure depth matches the markers on your fish finder, get ready to reel.
Other brands including Trolling Controller, Live Precise and Lead Core Line Precision Trolling Depth Calculator for Android incorporate much of the same data but use different algorithms. App demos are generally free through Play Store and Galaxy Store. Subscriptions with unlimited upgrades can run $50-$100.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.