By the time bass season opens in mid-June, freestone streams have grown warm, stocked trout have moved to cooler or deeper water, and most Pennsylvania anglers have shifted their focus to largemouths, smallmouths and other warm-water species.

So my curiosity was piqued when a Westmoreland County angler continued filing fishing reports about trophy-size trout caught on Loyalhanna Creek after the bass opener, even after the Fourth of July. In photos accompanying the reports, he posed with fat trout exceeding 20 inches. Most were brightly colored, easy-to-spot golden rainbows.

I suspected the Fishing Report frequent filer was probably sight fishing on the stream’s Keystone Select Trout Waters. In the Fish and Boat Commission program, 10,000 2- to 3-year-old former hatchery breeders are stocked in large numbers in some of the state’s Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only sections.

“I first noticed these fish were in the area by checking the local stocking lists. I noticed that the trout in this part of the Loyalhanna were a lot bigger and harder to catch, and I was up for the challenge,” said Jordan Stranko, 20, of Latrobe, a biology student at Saint Vincent College. “One summer [three years ago], I threw on the water shoes and went on a hike traveling very light. I was not disappointed by the size of the fish, and there was no one around to put pressure on them.”

Advertise with us

Loyalhanna’s special regulation section stretches 1.67 miles from the Route 711 bridge at Ligonier downstream to the bridge on Two Mile Run Road. Stranko walks the stream banks looking for lunkers. He carries a spinning rod, jig heads, soft plastic trout worms and a cell phone camera.

“I tend to walk right to the deeper holes or the holes that have a runoff water source, such as the road or natural flowing water, as this cools and puts more oxygen in the water,” he said. “The golden rainbows are always an indicator that more trout are there. It lets me know that fishermen are not fishing these holes. Almost every time I see a golden rainbow in a hole, big normal-colored trout are either right up against them or real close by.”

Sight fishing works best on the Loyalhanna when it is low, before a storm or just after a light rain.

“If the water is not muddy, the rain provides just the right temperature drop to make these trout want to feed, and the rain also drives out the bugs that the trout feed on,” he said.

A white plastic grub and natural color Trout Magnet with a small jig head are his go-to baits; he throws them with an ultra-light spinning rod strung with 4-pound test fluorocarbon line.

Advertise with us

“With the water normally being clear for sight fishing, it is important to not drive more attention to the lure then I have to,” he said. “I like to fish these baits by throwing upstream away from the trout to cause as little disturbance as I can. Once the lure is down by the trout, I slowly reel in and give the jig light twitches on the bottom. I watch very closely how the fish interact with the bait and how I present it to them. It's all trial and error, figuring out what they want and how they want it to be presented to them.”

There is no opening day on year-round Delayed Harvest waters. Stranko fishes there during the catch-and-release-only period when the trout are stocked. He avoids the high-pressure spring trout rush when the fish are harder to catch and returns after the harvest opens June 15.

On that day this year, he landed a 22-inch golden rainbow, a 23-inch rainbow and a 22½-inch tiger trout. The sterile brown and brook trout hybrid rarely occurs in the wild, and the Fish and Boat Commission neither produces nor stocks tiger trout. Stranko’s fish likely escaped from private club waters upstream and wandered into the Keystone Select waters. On June 21, he brought in a 23¼-inch, 4-pound golden rainbow.

Recently, school has cut into his time on the Loyalhanna, but Stranko said the big breeders continue gathering in the deepest, coolest pools in the special regulations area.

“It's a good place to target in the summer as pressure is low and the fish are still heavily populated in the Delayed Harvest section,” he said. “I normally will harvest these trout late in the summer months because as low as the streams are, and with the temperatures the stream produces this late into the season, it’s very hard for these trout to survive. I take these fish so they do not go to waste, simply dying off in the streams.”

Advertise with us

In three years of summer fishing, Stranko said he has harvested dozens of trout, mostly golden rainbows, ranging from 16 to 25 inches.