With the approval of three days of Sunday hunting in 2020, Pennsylvania took a step into the current millennium. A state Senate bill introduced last week would give the Game Commission authority to set the dates when Sunday hunting would occur.
The original Blue Law dated to the 1700s when colonial Penn’s Woods banned hunting and working on Sundays to encourage church attendance. In recent decades, Sunday hunting for most species was forbidden in deference to the powerful Pennsylvania Farm Bureau, which said its members demanded one day per week when strangers in orange coats were not permitted on their properties.
In 2019, legislators recognized that 47 states permitted general hunting on Sundays. Following decades of debate, the Farm Bureau adopted a neutral position on Sunday hunting — not overall support — in exchange for the creation of several new laws.
The legislature designated two Sunday hunting dates for 2020: the day after the opening of archery deer season and the day following the Saturday start of the firearm deer season. The Game Commission, permitted to choose one Sunday hunting date, picked the day after the opening of firearm bear season.
Hunters on private property are required to carry written permission from the landowner. A new class of trespass law, “hunting trespass,” sets higher penalties for trespassing while in the act of hunting, and state and local police may enforce the law. To protect hunters from accidentally straying over property boundaries, the so-called “purple paint law” permits landowners to mark property lines with a slash of paint instead of the costly and time-consuming posting of No Hunting signs.
It appears that Pennsylvania hunters obeyed the law during those Sunday hunts, and legislators are looking to make changes.
Read More
The new initiative was introduced by Sens. Dan Laughlin, R-Erie, the Game and Fisheries Committee chair; Devlin J. Robinson, R-Bridgeville; and James R. Brewster, D-McKeesport, the Game and Fisheries minority chair. Senate Bill 607 would expand Sunday hunting by permitting the Game Commission to set the dates. If passed into law, it likely would not take effect in the 2021-22 license year, which begins July 1.
As lawmakers discuss its implications, they are sure to ask whether anyone has been injured by hunters on Sundays, and whether hunters have obeyed the hunting-trespass law. On both counts, Pennsylvania hunters get a good grade.
Following a request for information, the Game Commission said it has no record of a hunting-related shooting incident occurring on any of the three days of Sunday hunting in 2020. Those include when a hunter or nonhunter is injured as the result of the discharge of a sporting arm while in the act of hunting or trapping.
Also, no charges were filed for hunting-related trespass on a Sunday. It was not possible to determine if calls or complaints had been made that did not result in legal charges.
Hunting license sales
A big part of the Sunday hunting debate is whether the added days of hunting opportunity increased the sale of hunting licenses. Following years of declining sales, sales increased 3% by the end of April. Some 884,100 general 2020-21 licenses were sold, showing an increase of more than 26,000 hunters compared to 2019-20.
But was that due to Sunday hunting or the pandemic, which forced hunters to spend more time away from work and school? To find out, the Game Commission sent out two hunter surveys in the winter of 2020-21.
“There were about 1,400 responses from the reactivated archery hunter survey. Those were hunters who had lapsed for two years from all license buying and reactivated [or purchased a license again] in 2020-21 and also bought an archery license,” said Game Commission spokesman Travis Lau. “The second survey is a survey of reactivated general license buyers. For this sample, we used the population of hunters who were lapsed for at least one year but reactivated in 2020-21.”
The second survey is still out and results from the first survey have not been analyzed.
From the state’s perspective, hunting is more than simply the support of tradition and recreation. With no apex predators or original foliage in millions of acres of wild spaces, there is no longer a self-sufficient “nature” that can take care of itself. Wildlife and its habitat need to be managed by the humans who created this hybrid environment.
In every American state and Canadian province, wildlife management is funded through a user-pay system in which the people who make use of wildlife pay for its management through the sale of licenses and excise taxes on the equipment they use. Without the support of general tax revenue, declining hunter participation in Pennsylvania makes wildlife management increasingly difficult to afford. The state’s effort to grow hunter numbers is an attempt to build a long-term funding source for Pennsylvania wildlife management.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.