For the first time since 2018, anglers are ice fishing on Pittsburgh area lakes.
With temperatures mostly below 30 degrees and dipping into single digits at night, rainbow trout are being pulled through the hardtop at shallow impoundments throughout the region. Where safe ice is more common, to the north from Lake Arthur to Presque Isle Bay and on high mountain lakes south and east of Allegheny County, they’re catching bluegills, crappies, perch, bass, pickerel, Northern pike and muskellunge.
Few Pennsylvania anglers target the most challenging ice fishing prize. Walleye are chased by anglers on Lake Erie and many inland lakes after the second harvest season opens, this year May 1. But during the early walleye season — Jan. 1-March 14 — most walleye fishing is done on moving water. Finding the fish under lake ice requires special skills that are hard to come by in a region that might get only a few weeks of good ice every several years.
Many freshwater predators inhabit a designated range. Walleye travel like schools of vacuum cleaners, sucking up prey species. Migrating Lake Erie ’eyes can follow shad from Maumee Bay spawning waters off Toledo to the Niagara River off Buffalo before returning to Ohio waters to spawn again, a 500-mile round trip. When lakes grow a sheet of ice, walleye schools keep moving through the dark waters below.
“In the summer you troll or drift for walleye, trying to find the schools. Ice fishing, you’re limited to where you drill your holes,” said Jim Archer, a Butler-area ice fisherman who has pulled walleye through the ice at Lake Arthur, Pymatuning Reservoir and Lake Erie.
“More than with any other fish you catch ice fishing, you have to know where they’re going to be. You can tell by using a depth finder to see the contours of the bottom and setting up over that.”
Read More
The biggest, toothiest member of the perch family, the ancient Sander vitreus is native to the Great Lakes and Ohio River system, dating to when the Allegheny River was a northward flowing tributary of a giant glacial lake. The walleye is named for its large, glassy eyes containing a layer of reflective pigment that enable the fish to see well at night and in the low-light conditions it encounters under ice.
A popular sport fish, it has been extensively stocked. This voracious predator has been introduced in lakes by the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission to control shad and invasive gobies.
To find walleye in winter, it helps to understand walleye in spring. Among the first fish to spawn, sometimes even before ice-out, females return to ancestral spawning sites on rocky or gravelly shallows, dam tailraces or up tributaries when the water temperature reaches 45-50 degrees.
Walleye are a cool-water species, but when it’s icy cold they follow shad, gobies and other prey to warmer, deep water. They prefer to attack from below, which offers a clue about using bottom contour to locate them under the ice.
Lake Arthur in Butler County isn’t particularly known for its walleye, which are stocked as fingerlings. Experienced ice anglers have brought some good-size ’eyes to the surface.
“They usually go deep to follow the aelwives when the water cools down,” said Jerry O’Donnell, co-owner of O’Donnell’s Sports Supplies near Portersville. “That’s why they’re hard to catch ice fishing — they’re deep. I know guys who get them off Neally’s Point.”
A moraine peninsula made from debris dropped by a receding glacier, Neally’s Point juts into Lake Arthur from the north shore. Under water, its sides gradually drop to the bottom. Wiley walleye suspend below, waiting for aelwives holding at a comfortable depth to stray over the edge, where the prey fish are ambushed from below.
Some ice anglers set up a row of holes 15-25 feet above the sloping sides of the peninsula, searching for the sweet spot for walleye.
“They catch them there and over the sides of submerged railroad beds,” said Mr. O’Donnell. “They jig blade baits, or the best is tip-ups with shiners, the big ones about 3 inches.”
Few rig for walleye at Cross Creek Lake in Washington County, but Mike Milvet watched as one in the 23-inch range was brought to the edge of the ice.
“We were walking by and this guy was targeting walleye,” said the owner of Cross Creek Bait Shop. “He had a fathead minnow on a ⅜-ounce jig and was jigging it over about 20 feet of water. He was on it for a while and got it right to the edge and it got off.”
On Pymatuning in Crawford County, where there’s no closed walleye season under joint Pennsylvania and Ohio management, Mr. Archer fishes over rock piles and wooden porcupine fish structures placed by Fish and Boat and Ohio Department of Natural Resources.
“Anywhere that schools of minnows are hugging the bottom for safety but walleye can get underneath them to ambush them from below, that’s where I set up my tip-ups,” he said. “I know the lake pretty well and have GPS marking the fish structures. But you have to be right over the walleye, so I use the depth finder to find the drop offs and then to mark big walleye.”
Fish and Boat biologist explains more about winter walleye in the free newsletter, The Wildlife. Subscribe at the top of the PG homepage.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.