Joe Fazio doesn’t mark his calendar with the days he wants to go hunting. He marks the days he’s most likely to shoot a deer. For 25 years, he’s predicted his success by coordinating his hunts with cycles of the moon.
This year, the Mount Washington hunter took an archery 9-point from a treestand on his 97-acre property in Greene County, as predicted on Oct. 28.
“My trail cams told me these two bucks were showing up early in the day chasing does on the edge of a fence row,” he said. “Just after the light rain was tapering off, it was super foggy and I could see a small buck, a doe and her young in the clearing in front of me. I knew the big bucks wouldn’t allow that, so I grunted.”
Immediately a heavy-rack buck leaped the fence row and raced into the clearing. The small-antlered deer ran off, and the doe and yearling stopped trotting under the tree stand.
“The big buck stopped at 13 yards quartering [toward me] slightly,” said Mr. Fazio. “I chose a target high and just behind the shoulder and released. He kicked up his back legs, so I knew I got him.”
Mr. Fazio’s hunting journal shows that for a quarter century he’s taken a deer within days of a particular lunar juncture. “The second full moon after the fall equinox, the day of and four days before or after.”
Read More
This year’s fall equinox, the autumn date with the same hours of light and dark, was Sept. 22. October had two full moons, Oct. 1 and Oct. 31. Mr. Fazio took his 9-point three days before the second full moon after the fall equinox.
“Why the deer act up on those days, I have no clue — no physiological reason,” he said. “Rutting is due to photoperiod, we know that. These full moon or near full moon dates that coincide with the rut, someone could say it has to do with deer responding to moonlight. But my log shows that some days when I shot a deer were raining or foggy, so it isn’t about moonlight.”
Weather can impact prime hunting dates. Excessive heat can put big deer down, he said, and on windy days the movement and sound of rustling of leaves and displacement of scent take out three of a deer’s primary senses.
A diehard crappie fisherman, Mr. Fazio follows lunar tables on the water, too, checking for the daily hours when the moon is crossing Western Pennsylvania skies.
“That’s something else. It’s the tide schedule,” he said. “The moon moves the tides. It must have some impact on smaller waters, too. My fishing log tells me I catch fish within two hours before and after moon rise and when the moon is crossing the meridian.
“I don’t know what impact it has on land animals, or why this works for deer. I just know it works for me.”
Andrea Kriner, an archer from Montoursville, Lycoming County, also schedules her hunts according to “solunar” tables, the name given to projections based on solar and lunar movement. Five years ago, she purchased Solunar Tables, the company that publishes the SolunarTables.com website, booklet and calendar based on the original 1926 research of founder John Alden Knight.
“My calculation is based on his theory and moon phases,” she said. “It’s crazy how the schedules are really accurate. It does work and he did it by trial and error.”
Ms. Kriner mentioned some of the weather factors that could impact deer on prime solunar dates, and suggested that wary hunters should experiment with the theory.
“Make sure you’re reading [the schedule] right, and be at the right spot at the right time,” she said.
There has been little scientific research applied to Mr. Knight’s theory. In 2017, the Penn State College of Agricultural Sciences published research based on data gathered for the Deer-Forest Study, a 2013-17 collaboration of Penn State, the U.S. Geological Survey, Pennsylvania Game Commission and state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources.
The original data used GPS tracking of female deer 2 years or older, documenting their positions hourly. Researchers developed a statistical model combining the elements of sunrise, sunset, hour of day and moon phase.
Overlaid against periods of full moon, the study showed that the deer traveled less than 20 feet farther per hour during nights with a new moon. In daylight during periods of partial moon phase, they moved about 13 feet farther. The results suggested that the moon and its phases have little to no impact on deer mobility by night or day.
But Duane Diefenbach, adjunct professor of wildlife ecology and leader of the Pennsylvania Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit at Penn State and leader of the Deer-Forest study, said the lunar movement research wasn’t conclusive.
“This little study is not the end-all of this question,” he said. “We looked at female deer in the month of October in one particular part of Central Pennsylvania. We looked at the data we had available, gathered for multiple purposes. [The study] didn’t include bucks, and isn’t as relevant to the needs of archers.”
Mr. Fazio operates the YouTube channel Off the Hoof Outdoors. Digging Deeper: To view a video of Mr. Fazio’s successful hunt and learn more about Solunar Tables, get a free digital subscription to The Wild Life newsletter.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.