Deer by deer, county by county, chronic wasting disease is infecting its way closer to southwestern Pennsylvania. The best way to slow its spread, researchers suggest, is with the help of hunters.

Pennsylvania Game Commission staff plan to discuss the results of new research and encourage public input in developing a new CWD Response Plan Proposal during a seminar at the Allegheny Outdoor, Sport and Travel Show in Monroeville on Feb. 14. The proposal would replace the existing plan.

Chronic wasting disease infects wild and captive deer, elk and moose and is always fatal. A threat to white-tail and mule deer across North America, CWD is confirmed in 26 states including Pennsylvania and three Canadian provinces. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has “no reported cases of CWD infection in people,” but since 1997 the World Health Organization has recommended that animals and their parts suspected of CWD contamination be separated from the human food chain.

In Pennsylvania, three Disease Management Areas are established to help control its spread, using enhanced regulations for hunting and handling deer. Last year, for the first time, one DMA was extended into Westmoreland County. Samara Trusso, a Game Commission deer biologist who will speak at the seminar, said confirmation of CWD in Cambria County led to the DMA being expanded as far west as Ligonier.

Advertise with us

“There are no CWD-positive cases in Westmoreland that we know of, but it’s getting closer [to southwestern Pennsylvania],” she said. “DMA boundaries are set, with an abundance of caution, 10 miles from every positive result. We’re trying to [create] a buffer zone.”

Last year, DMA 2 in south-central Pennsylvania was extended westward when four road kills tested positive in the Cambria County townships of Adams, Cambria, Portage and Richland, near Westmoreland County. Another four infected road kills were found in Somerset County’s Allegheny and Ogle townships. Also a hunter-harvested deer in Somerset County tested positive.

Ms. Trusso said a CWD-positive case in North Mahoning, Indiana County, will likely result in the expansion of DMA 3, which runs slightly west into Armstrong County. Chronic wasting disease in DMA 3’s Clearfield and Jefferson counties threatens Pennsylvania’s free-ranging elk population.

Of 15,000 deer carcass samples collected by the Game Commission in 2019, 6,500 are still being processed. At the seminar, Ms. Trusso said she will release new testing results.

CWD was first detected in south-central Pennsylvania in 2012. The Game Commission believes it came from deer farms within the state as well as wild whitetails that entered from Maryland. The CWD response plan under review states that research from across the U.S. suggests that with no change, more than 30% of deer in parts of Pennsylvania where CWD was first detected will be infected in the next 10 to 20 years.

Advertise with us

One theory on how to slow its spread among wild deer is “targeted removal.” If public hunting doesn’t reduce deer density to levels likely to slow the spread of CWD, professional shooters would be hired to kill deer within a radius of each confirmed case. The Game Commission proposed such an idea but quickly withdrew it following the staunch objection of hunters.

In the DMAs, additional harvest tags are available to hunters through the Deer Management Assistance Program. Probably because of the “ick” factor, not enough deer are being killed in the DMA zones to slow the disease. The proposed response plan addresses that.

“In control units, the initial management step is to reach a minimum sampling goal via hunting,” it states. ”If management objectives are not met in CWD control units or established areas, the Pennsylvania Game Commission will seek to reach those objectives through agency-directed targeted removals.”

Patrick Snickles, Game Commission education officer for the Southwest District, said hunters have a lot of questions about targeted removal. They’ve asked for input into the new response plan, he said, and their participation will be “necessary” in slowing the spread of CWD.

“The response plan is highly dependent on removal [of deer from infected zones], but it is not my belief that the agency is absolutely determined to do targeted removal,” said Mr. Snickles, who will speak at the seminar. “We don’t want to do it. It’s expensive and has had limited success when it has been attempted in other areas.… There are other things in the plan that could be tried.”

Advertise with us

Changes to the current response plan could include mandatory deer-feeding bans, increased antlerless permit allocation, additional antlered permits, expanded hunting seasons, removal of antler point restrictions, mandatory sampling in control units and deer-harvest incentive programs.

The public comment period for the CWD Response Plan Proposal ends Feb. 29. View the proposal and submit comments at pgc.pa.gov.

The Allegheny Outdoor, Sport and Travel Show is at the Monroeville Convention Center on Feb. 14-16. $10 admission. Information: 412-373-7300 or sportandtravel.com.