Veteran steelheader James Swearingen of Windgap and a friend relied on egg sacs when they caught and released six brown trout and 16 steelhead at Elk Creek on Christmas Day. On Jan. 4, he hooked a beautiful rainbow male steelhead on the same section of the creek.

“All fish were caught on a size 12 hook and 6-pound test. I used my 10-foot Daiwa Riversider rod and 2000 Series Pfleuger President,” said Mr. Swearingen, a spokesman for Pautzke Bait Co. and co-publisher of the Steel City Anglers Facebook page.

“The water we were focusing on was in a deeper section of the creek that had a nice flow to it and a seam that ran down the far side of the drift. Mostly all our fish were caught in or next to the seam in the slack water.”

For most January steelheading, forget the shallows, Mr. Swearingen said.

Advertise with us

‘“Most fish are going to be in deeper holes on the creek when the water is cold. Once the water warms up a bit, the fish will start to wander to riffles and tailouts to [attempt] the act of spawning.”

Lake Erie and tributaries (Erie County) Big brown trout took advantage of high green-tinged snow melt to advance on Elk Creek. Steelhead were active, too, and angler pressure was high. Fishing was slow at Twentymile Creek and Walnut Creek, except at the mouth, and small fast-draining creeks were low. Walk-in access to Sevenmile Creek at Glinodo Conference Center on Route 5 now requires permission from the Sisters of St. Benedict. Smallish yellow perch continued to be pulled from the bay, and a few nice lake trout went for spoons trolled deep in 10-20 feet of water out of Northeast.

Lake Erie and tributaries (Erie County) Big brown trout took advantage of high green-tinged snow melt to advance on Elk Creek. teelhead were active throughout Elk Creek and angler pressure was high. Fishing was slow at Twentymile Creek and Walnut Creek, except at the mouth, and small fast-draining creeks were low. Walk-in access to Sevenmile Creek at Glinodo Conference Center on Route 5 now requires permission from the Sisters of St. Benedict. Smallish yellow perch continued to be pulled from the bay, and a few nice lake trout went for spoons trolled deep in 10-20 feet of water out of Northeast.

Pymatuning Reservoir (Crawford County) Ice anglers continued to wait for a hard top.

Allegheny River (Forest County) Anglers using suckers, chubs and large minnows reported good catches of walleye, muskellunge and Northern pike near Tionesta and at the Kinzua Dam outflow.

Advertise with us

French Creek (Venango, Mercer, Crawford counties) Heavy flow pushed walleye and Northerns into creek mouths and shoreline areas. Floating jigs tipped with large fatheads were hot.

Allegheny River (Venango, Clarion counties) Throughout the Middle Allegheny, muskies, Northerns and larger-than-average walleye took soft plastics.

Lake Arthur (Butler County) The first ice fishing event of the 2020 Western Pennsylvania Hardwater Tournament Series is scheduled for Saturday, but at midweek safe ice was doubtful. The next meet is planned for Lake Wilhelm, Mercer County, on Jan. 25. Get details at the group’s Facebook page.

Raccoon Lake (Beaver County) Skim ice melted in recent days.

Bradys Run Lake (Beaver County) A few large trout were caught.

Advertise with us

North Park Lake (Allegheny County) Despite a big trout stocking in mid-December, hopes for an early ice fishing season melted with the decaying skim ice.

Quemahoning Reservoir (Somerset County) Few anglers were on the water, but they caught Northern pike on large live minnows.

Youghiogheny River (Fayette, Somerset counties) Good trout fishing was reported at the outflow.

File your report and high-resolution digital photos (1MB minimum) at fishingreport@post-gazette.com. Include name, age (for children), town, species, size, body of water and other details.