The expansion of Sunday hunting moved one step closer last week when the state House Game and Fisheries Committee agreed to advance a crucial Senate bill for a vote in the full House. But some hunters say an amendment requiring them to have written permission from landowners will make it less likely that much Sunday hunting will ever occur.

“How can I know who owns what?” asked Eric Fields of Monroeville, who said he’s been deer hunting on private property south of the Allegheny and Kiskiminetas rivers’ confluence for decades with the owners’ implied consent.

“I’ve never met them. They don’t post their properties. Other people hunt there, too, and it’s never been an issue. I can hunt there on Saturday, but to come back Sunday I have to find out who owns it and bring a note? That’s crazy.”

Pennsylvania currently permits hunting for foxes, coyotes and crows on Sundays. During the 20 years that expanded Sunday hunting bills have been in the state legislature, their primary opponent has been the powerful Pennsylvania Farm Bureau. The bureau’s staunch opposition to hunting on Sundays has influenced the votes of lawmakers, mostly in the southcentral counties where it represents hundreds of farming families and giant agro-industry co-ops.

Advertise with us

While much public discourse has focused on concerns about hunting safety, the Farm Bureau’s opposition dealt mainly with trespassing by hunters and the need for farmers to chase off interlopers on a day that is traditionally a day of rest. Forty-seven states that permit Sunday hunting report no increased hunting safety issues.

Years ago, Pennsylvania legislators who supported Sunday hunting recognized that they could follow the lead of Ohio, where that state’s Farm Bureau dropped its opposition to Sunday hunting in exchange for massive increases in trespassing penalties.

Early this year, for the first time, the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau presented to legislators a list of conditions it said must be met in regards to Sunday hunting for it to take a neutral stance. The Senate approved a bill granting two of the Farm Bureau’s top three points: Sunday hunting would be limited to three days; and a new crime, hunting trespass, was created with steep fines including prison time and revocation of hunting privileges for a second offense.

An amendment attached to SB 147 in the House committee gave the Farm Bureau another significant win: written permission to hunt on Sundays.

“The legislators caved,” said Carl Wilnix, who lives near California, Washington County. “This is what the Farm Bureau wanted all along. Nobody’s going to be able to get it in writing, so there won’t be hunting on Sundays.”

Advertise with us

At the Monday meeting, Rep. Bill Kortz, D-Dravosburg, reminded House members that SB 147 is compromise legislation and the lawmakers were “on the cusp of passing an historic law.”

In the spirit of compromise, an outspoken hunters group that is frequently at odds with the state Game Commission has publicly supported the “written permission” condition.

“The Allegheny County Sportsmen’s League has always supported Sunday hunting,” said Klint Macro, the group’s president. “As far as needing to get permission from landowners to hunt on Sunday, A.C.S.L. is also a huge supporter of personal property rights. Any ethical and law-abiding hunter would need to get permission to hunt on private property any day of the week.”

Mr. Macro said responsible hunters must respect the wishes of private property owners.

“With map apps and county websites, it is not difficult to find out who the landowners are, contact them and respectfully ask them for permission to hunt on their property,” he said. “All this should be done long before you don your orange and take your rifle, bow or flintlock into the woods.”

Advertise with us

Randy Sanduci, past president and executive member of Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania, said his group is “evenly split” over Sunday hunting and SB 147.

“Our position has changed from supporting [the bill] three years ago to a neutral [position today],” he said.

Mr. Santucci said he suspects linkage between Sunday hunting and the new Saturday firearm deer opener, which he opposes as a threat to tradition.

“It is always good to get the landowner’s permission, which covers hunting anytime not just Sunday,” he said. “Focusing all this effort on written permission just for a Sunday hunt may backfire to be more disturbing to landowners and hunters alike. Maybe that is part of the strategy of the Farm Bureau's continued opposition for Sunday implementation?”

Rep. Keith Gillespie, R-York, chairman of the House Game and Fisheries Committee, said months ago there was no consideration of changing opening day to a Saturday to coincide with the Sunday hunting initiative.

More amendments could be added to SB 147 or it could be passed when the bill is debated by the full House on Monday. If passed by House and the Senate approves the amendments, the bill would go to Gov. Tom Wolf, who has generally supported Sunday hunting.