Americans haven’t changed their minds about hunting in the last 25 years, but their opinions have grown more nuanced.

Days before Saturday’s opening of Pennsylvania’s early archery deer season in the region, a new national survey shows that the general acceptance of legal hunting has gradually increased from 73% in 1995 to nearly 80%, the highest level ever recorded.

Legal hunting, as opposed to illegal poaching, garnered varied support depending upon the respondent’s hometown, race, gender and age. Approval ratings were influenced by the species being targeted and the stated reason for hunting.

The survey was conducted by Responsive Management, a research firm that has tracked public attitudes about hunting, fishing, shooting, trapping and other wildlife-related activities since 1995. Executive director Mark Damian Duda referenced the company’s long-term trend data when determining how attitudes about hunting have changed over the years.

Advertise with us

“While only about 4% of the American population hunts each year, the majority of the American public supports hunting even if they don’t personally participate,” Mr. Duda and Andrea Criscione, a Responsive Management research associate, said in a co-written editorial in a recent edition of Conservation Frontlines.

“It seems counterintuitive that hunting, an activity in which so little of the population participates and that which is no longer critical to survival, would enjoy such widespread contemporary approval. Nonetheless, social science research clearly confirms this support,” they wrote in the not-for-profit e-magazine, which tracks news about ethical hunting and conservation.

Support among respondents who were white or Caucasian was 86.5%; black or African American, 64.6% and Hispanic or Latino, 61.5%. Views categorized by race may have been influenced by prevailing hometown attitudes regarding hunting: support in rural areas was 89.8%; small cities or towns, 83.4%, and large cities or suburbs, 73.8%. And in an era of declining hunting license sales, the study showed a generational rift: Hunting support among ages 55 or older was 82.7%; 35 to 54 years, 81.8%; 18 to 34, 75.7%.

“Prior to the development of farming and agriculture … the hunters in the group were primarily males who would pass the ability to survive on to the next generation by taking them hunting,” Mr. Duda and Ms. Criscione wrote. “Hunting today is still predominantly a male activity: 83% of hunters are male. Research also consistently shows that it takes a hunter to make a hunter, meaning almost all hunters today were initiated into hunting by another hunter, usually by a father or father figure.”

According to the survey, hunting was supported by 86.4% of American men and 73.2% of women. People who go fishing were more likely to support hunting than those who don’t. Approval among those who grew up in a family that owned firearms was 88.3%, but just 65.6% in families that didn’t own a gun.

Advertise with us

Americans' Attitudes Toward Hunting, Fishing, Sport Shooting and Trapping, a 2019 telephone survey of American adults, was commissioned by the National Shooting Sports Foundation with the support of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

The study showed that even when hunting is supported, approval is not unconditional. Support varied widely depending on why the hunter is hunting. When told the hunting was to protect humans from harm, respondents’ approval was 85%. Hunting for the meat rate 84% approval; for wildlife management, 82%; to get locally sourced food, 83%; to get organic meat, 77%; and to protect property, 74%.

“Americans are much more likely to approve of hunting for those species traditionally hunted for food in hunter-gatherer societies, such as deer, 78%; wild turkey, 78%; and duck, 74%,” Mr. Duda and Ms. Criscione said. “However, support drops with some of the species that posed a higher threat to humans, were more difficult to kill and were not the type of meat typically consumed.”

Americans seemed wary of hunters who hunt because they enjoy it. Approval of hunting for the sport was 50%. Hunting for the challenge, 41%.

Although license and landowner fees for legal trophy hunting are used to finance much of the global conservation of those species, support was lowest — 29% with just 9% strong approval — for hunters who are out for a rack, a rug or a full-body mount. Only 1% of hunters reported their primary motivation to hunt is for a trophy.

Advertise with us

“Whether we live with or without hunting today, we seem to have an innate understanding that connects our participation in, opinions on and attitudes toward hunting … an understanding that persists despite significant historical, societal and environmental changes,” stated Mr. Duda and Ms. Criscione in Conservation Frontlines. “It is this persistence that convinces us as social researchers that hunting is, indeed, part of who we are.”

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.

     Post-Gazette Outdoors Poll                                                  

LAST WEEK: Hunting trespass was the key issue in the state Senate debate on Sunday hunting. Will hunting safety feature more prominently as the bill enters the House?

Yes 50 %

Advertise with us

No 50 %

505 responses

This poll is an unscientific tally of web postings generated by Civic Science.