ERIE, Pa. — Captain Lane Brown’s new charter service caught the attention of Lake Erie anglers in May after he helped a client set a new state record with a 40-inch, 31-pound 13-ounce lake trout.

Most lake trout fishing off Erie County occurs in late April and May. In recent Fishing Reports, when Mr. Brown described clients catching multiple lake trout in July, I asked if I could tag along.

A lifelong fisherman from North East who has worked for several charters, Mr. Brown named his guide service God’s Grace Sport Fishing and begins every trip with a prayer.

I met him and first mate Tom Thompson at 6 a.m. on a perfect morning last week. Their walleye trips normally trailer in at a Pennsylvania ramp, but on this day the 22-foot bow rider was docked 10 miles east of the state line at Barcelona Harbor Pier, N.Y.

Advertise with us

“It’s closer to where the lakers are now. They’re migrating, following a temperature they like,” said Mr. Brown. “Not too long ago we had a big blow from the northeast that pushed the cold water in. It really messed things up. Now the lake’s stabilized, got cold in the right places and [lake trout] are coming back out.”

His clients — Ron Vanderhoof of Titusville and Justin Magness and his son Connor, 13, of Clymer — had booked a split day of fishing, four hours on walleye and four on lake trout. A little after 6:30 a.m., Mr. Thompson pushed off between cloudy skies and a light chop. The boat hadn’t traveled far when the captain started scanning the electronics for walleye suspended in 60 feet of water.

In short time he put his clients over a traveling school. With planer boards out, the boat trolled 5-inch Renosky lures, deep-diving Bay Rats and Michigan Stinger Stingray spoons on lead-core lines with monofilament leaders clipped to Dipsy Divers and downriggers.

Unlike many charter services, the God’s Grace crew doesn’t hook fish for clients. They called out strikes when necessary, but the clients pulled rods from the holders, set the hooks and fought the fish to the boat.

“I want people to fish,” said Mr. Brown. “It’s funner that way.”

Advertise with us

The first walleye strike was followed by a 5-minute pause, then pandemonium with back-to-back strikes, doubles with two anglers fighting fish, long-handled nets crossing in the water and smiling clients posing for fish photos.

Two hours after leaving the dock, the party had boated about 25 walleye, lost a few and landed another dozen white perch, white fish, a freshwater drum and a big brown trout. Walleye are legal in New York at 15 inches, but on the recommendation of the conservation-minded captain all ’eyes under 18 inches were released. They quickly iced a limit ranging from 18 to 22 inches.

“Limiting out in two hours. It’s incredible,” said Mr. Magness.

“My arms started getting tired from reeling them in,” said Connor.

Mr. Thompson reorganized the boat for lake trout as the captain motored to deeper waters.

Advertise with us

“I like the lake trout,” he said. “Every captain knows perch and walleye are their bread and butter, but I like to see the rod bend.”

Lake and brook trout are the only trout species native to Pennsylvania. They can live for 40 years and many are caught between 25 and 30 inches. Despite the state record set on his boat, Mr. Brown said he doesn’t believe Lake Erie’s biggest lake trout has been caught.

Over-fishing, pollution and problems with invasive species nearly eliminated Salvelinus namaycush from the Great Lakes by the mid-1900s. Extensive rehabilitation efforts were launched by federal, state and provincial wildlife agencies, and there is recent evidence of natural lake trout reproduction in lakes Superior, Michigan, Ontario and parts of Lake Huron.

In Lake Erie, the shallowest of the Great Lakes, the autumn spawn is stymied by zebra and quagga mussels that dominate the rocky shoreline shoals most conducive to eggs’ survival. In less suitable habitat, spawning attempts fail. Adult lake trout are the favorite food of sea lamprey, which attach to their sides and literally suck the liquids from their bodies.

Lake trout exist here only because of stocking. Commercial exploitation is banned, and aquatic wildlife managers say the minimal recreational harvest has little impact at the population level. An estimated 70,000 lake trout live in Lake Erie, compared to 50 million walleye.

Advertise with us

Mr. Brown slowed the boat over 90-foot waters registering 44 degrees at the bottom. On 20-pound fluorocarbon leader, Mr. Thompson rigged an attention-grabbing Spin-N-Glo dodger about 20 inches above heavy Fish Hawk jigs or 5-inch Stingrays. Dipsys and riggers took the lures to 80-90 feet.

Almost immediately a line tripped and Connor started reeling as his dad and Mr. Vanderhoof shouted encouragement. The 12.3-pound laker he landed had a dark round spot on its side where a lamprey had been attached.

“It was very heavy, hard to reel in,” said Connor. “Different from walleye. It’s a lot harder to pull in and it fought harder.”

When the captain found 42-degree water at 106-110 feet, he found schooling lake trout. Again the boat rocked with the excitement of frequent hook-ups. Before 10:30 a.m., the party had caught and released nine lake trout and could have continued fishing, but they legally kept one each in the 25-inch range that were gill-hooked and destined to die.

The eight-hour charter trip was cut short when Mr. Vanderhoof, Mr. Magness and Connor limited out on walleye and lake trout in just four hours. That doesn’t happen on every trip, Mr. Thompson said, but he and the captain had seen 40-lake trout days. Mr. Brown said a lot of lake trout anglers look for a particular depth. His strategy is to follow the preferred water temperature.

Advertise with us

“They’re particular. Two degrees can make a big difference,” he said. “When the lake warms and they go deeper, people give up [on lake trout] and switch to perch and walleye. … If you can get a boat on the lake, you can catch lakers if you find the temperature where they’re comfortable.”

Learn more about God’s Grace Sport Fishing at godsgracesportfishing.com.