ERIE, Pa. — A convergence of three unusual environmental forces is expected to cause uncommon conditions on Lake Erie in 2019.

• For several years rain water has collected in the Great Lakes faster than the St. Lawrence River can spill it into the ocean. High water and navigational impediments stretch from the Duluth waterfront on Lake Superior to the eastern sand and gravel flats of Lake Ontario. Add to that unusually heavy and consistent rains over the Ohio region, which washed tons of agricultural nutrients into western Lake Erie tributaries this spring.

• At a conference July 11, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration strengthened its spring forecast that those nutrients will fuel one of the largest Lake Erie algal blooms on record this summer. Two weeks ago, a toxin-producing planktothrix algae bloom, usually confined to Ohio’s Sandusky Bay area, merged with 2019’s first documented toxin-producing microcystis bloom off Toledo. The merger of the algal colonies is unusual. Both contain the most notorious forms of harmful algae that have dominated the lake in recent years.

• Good smallmouth bass fishing and an explosion of walleye, the result of several extremely successful spawning seasons in the lake’s Western Basin, are attracting large numbers of recreational anglers to the southern shores of Lake Erie.

Advertise with us

The abundance of boats, navigational hazards and toxic blooms are expected to meet up this summer.

At the NOAA conference, panelists warned the blooms are indicative of a continuing danger to the health of Lake Erie. Phosphorus from excess agricultural fertilizer use pours into runoff water and into the lake, upsetting the natural nutritional balance and resulting in the toxic blooms. In December, the Ohio legislature voted down a proposal by then-Gov. John Kasich that would have required less agricultural use of phosphorus-heavy fertilizers.

Conference panelist Rick Stumpf, an oceanographer with NOAA’s National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science, said that as the lake warms the blooms are expected to spread as far north as Ontario.

“If you look there now there’s nothing, but all the elements are in place for a toxic bloom larger than what appeared last year but not as large as some previous blooms,” he said.

Research is underway to predict the likely toxicity of the algae before it blooms, said Mr. Stumpf.

Advertise with us

For Western Basin anglers, this year’s bloom will add a slimy “ick” factor, but the floating algae is not expected to drift as far east as Pennsylvania, said Mr. Stumpf.

“People don’t want to be fishing in scummy water. If you have scum concentrations, the toxin can cause skin irritations, rashes and other problems,” he said.

Unlike the Caribbean red tide blooms that Mr. Stumpf also researches, the microscopic planktothrix and microcystis don’t kill everything in their path. These algae contain cyanobacteria, a phylum of bacteria that obtain energy through photosynthesis and is uniquely able to produce oxygen by moving up and down in the water column. It “can be there even if you can’t see it,” he said.

The algal blooms are not toxic to fish, but it is believed that concentrations of scum are detrimental to bass, panfish and other sport fishes that spend most of their time within a few feet of the surface. Yellow perch and walleye are more mobile and can avoid contact with the algae.

Decomposing biological matter usually strips oxygen from the water and sinks, causing areas of hypoxia (low oxygen) or anoxia (no oxygen) that fish avoid. Not so with planktothrix and microcystis blooms.

Advertise with us

“The lake is large enough that small amounts of wind also help with mixing, so it stays stirred up enough in the shallow areas, like the Western Basin and the nearshore of the Central Basin, to get some oxygen to the bottom,” Mr. Stumpf said.

So far predictions of an icky bloom haven’t scared off Ohio anglers, who had a successful walleye spring in Lake Erie’s western spawning waters.

Last week aboard the Perch Pirate, a 44-foot head boat moored in Presque Isle Bay, senior captain Bob Zawadzki said some clients ask about the toxic blooms but he doubts their concerns have cut into bookings.

“I don’t know a lot about [the algae]. I know you don’t want to get it on you,” he said. “The [walleye] spawn was over long before those blooms in the Western Basin, so I don’t think there will be any impact on the current year class.”