In the spring, the Post-Gazette described early walleye season shore fishing opportunities and techniques that gave anglers without boats access to the greatest concentration of Lake Erie walleye on record. We traveled to the lake’s shallow western basin with an Ohio charter to explore the post-spawn. When the migration of millions of Lake Erie walleye — three times the normal angler catch rate — brought about a third of them to Pennsylvania waters, we hitched a ride on a Presque Isle head boat that provided low-cost access to the walleye bonanza.
Now, the walleye migration is facing another juncture. By mid-September roving packs of walleyes are expected to begin following 50- to 55-degree temperature zones north and northeast across the Pennsylvania Channel to the lake’s deepest waters in the Long Point Escarpment, which plunges steeply off the large Canadian sand spit dropped by a receding glacier some 14,000 years ago.
As the walleye begin to move on, Pennsylvania charter captains typically will follow them farther and farther into deeper waters until motor fuel consumption is no longer cost-effective. The head boat Perch Pirate will drop its 20-angler summer walleye trips on Labor Day.
Explore the Outdoors with John Hayes!
Outdoors writer John Hayes shares tips, tricks, photos and more in his Facebook group. Join today!
“We’re going back to perch,” owner and captain John Krasa said. “Switching to walleye for the summer was a big success for us. Bookings were filled. The boat had some 75- and 85-walleye days.”
Read More
Krasa said the huge 2017 and 2018 walleye populations seem to follow traditional migration patterns.
“Walleye traditionally migrate about the second week of September,” he said. “They follow cooler water to deeper regions north and east of Erie, before moving back to the western basin to reproduce.”
The migration is well-documented in Lake Erie’s west and central basin management areas, where telemetry studies have provided solid estimates about the lifestyles of resident walleye that don’t travel with the packs.
In east basin waters, the proportion of resident versus migrating walleye and their home ranges is less understood. Initial data from the first Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission walleye telemetry study, funded by angler groups, is expected to literally balloon to the surface in coming weeks with the release of receivers deployed on the lake bottom that track tags embedded under the walleyes’ scales.
“[Pennsylvania’s Lake Erie waters] are in a special place with access to cold deep water, warm shallow flats, good fishing on the west side, good fishing on the east side,” said Mark Haffley, a biologist with the state Fish and Boat Commission, prior to the start of the study. “It has always been assumed that the walleye fishery in Lake Erie has been driven by western migration, that they spawn in the western basin — Sister Islands, Maumee River, Bass Islands — and follow favorable water temperatures eastward. A question that hasn’t been answered: Do discrete spawning stocks in eastern waters contribute differentially to Lake Erie’s total walleye population?”
Haffley said the soon-to-be-concluded telemetry data, combined with similar projects completed in Ohio and New York, will help researchers to estimate the percentage of walleye that stay in the east basin.
“This is an incredible opportunity to put a number and location on [whether] and when these fish are spawning here,” he said. “Do fish spawn off Shades Beach and return every year to Shades Beach? How many of the walleye caught off Walnut Creek stay there? This is the first time we’ve had the ability to do this. It’s going to give us a better understanding of the true walleye population and how they live.”
Don’t expect answers immediately after the reception of telemetry data. To be biologically significant, Haffley said, the study would have to be ongoing and include more tags. In the Ohio Division of Wildlife acoustic telemetry study, researchers submerged some 600 receivers throughout the Great Lakes, including 80 in Lake Erie. Walleye were tracked on a journey from the lake’s western basin through Lake St. Clair and into Lake Huron.
In Lake Erie waters off New York the 2017 Walleye Movement Study collected acoustic telemetry from 70 units and traditional tracking methods including jaw tagging, otolith (ear bone) analysis and genetic sampling from the sport fishery, Canadian commercial gillnets and walleye implanted with the acoustic tags.
In a report presented in March 2018 to the Lake Erie Committee and Great Lakes Fishery Commission management groups, researchers from the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation noted that the largest concentration of west basin walleye occupied New York’s east basin waters in October. Most of the walleye spawned in the west basin migrate to the same places throughout the lake, while east basin walleye more often live their entire lives in the eastern basin. Staying put improves their chances for survival, it was theorized, because the homebodies are less vulnerable to large fisheries in the western part of the lake, biologists said
“ ... At any given time there will be more west basin walleye in the western portion of the east basin than there is in the eastern portion of the east basin,” the report stated. “However, the magnitude of observed occupancy varied greatly by location and season.”
More research was needed to arrive at an east basin residency estimate.
“Given the apparent magnitude of the west basin population occupying the east basin relative to the size of our east basin stocks,” the report stated, “it is still reasonable to conclude that western basin walleye contribute significantly to our New York walleye fishery in Lake Erie.”
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.