DUNBAR, Pa. — One of Western Pennsylvania’s best trout streams is having some work done. A nip here, a tuck there and the removal of several collapsed dams will take about 100 years off the appearance of Dunbar Creek. Below the surface the 12½-mile Fayette County freestone stream is expected to return to a more natural state and perhaps produce more caddis, mayflies and stoneflies.
Fed by tributaries that have sustained brook trout since the formation of Chestnut Ridge, Dunbar Creek rolls off the mountain through a rugged 4.22-mile Catch-And-Release Fly-Fishing Only section stocked with brook and brown trout by the state Fish and Boat Commission. A general-regulation stretch from a quarry off Furnace Hill Road to the town of Dunbar is favored by many local bait anglers who fish the well-stocked pools behind a series of failed industrial dams. Below the town, smallmouths and panfish enter at the creek’s confluence with the Youghiogheny River at Connellsville.
This month the last of the collapsed concrete dams were removed. In September a separate project will begin to take out log-framed cross vein dams from the fly fishing area.
Some 300 dams have been removed from Pennsylvania waters. Lisa Hollingsworth-Segedy, director of river restoration for the nonprofit American Rivers, said the state leads the nation in dam removal because it had the most dams.
Explore the Outdoors with John Hayes!
Outdoors writer John Hayes shares tips, tricks, photos and more in his Facebook group. Join today!
Read More
“Some dams still have a purpose. But many, especially in areas like Pennsylvania that were settled early and had a lot of industry, no longer serve the purpose they were intended to provide,” she said. “Some were abandoned and are deteriorating. There are safety and liability issues, they contribute to flooding, create blockages that prevent the movement of fish and amphibians and block riparian travel routes for other animals. Then there’s recreation — remove those dams and there’s better fishing, better access and better water for paddlers.”
The four dilapidated concrete dams spanning Dunbar valley were built within a 1½ mile stretch around 1900 to supply water for coke ovens. When the industry left, the dams were abandoned. The state Game Commission, owner of Game Land 51 where the dams were located, removed one of the structures in 2016. American Rivers, the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy and partners raised $220,000 to remove the others.
“Taking out the dams allows the stream to function more effectively,” Hollingsworth-Segedy said. “It gives wild and stocked fish access to the whole creek system — we’ve calculated that’s 44 miles of habitat. Reducing sediment in the dam pools will create better water for macroinvertebrates.”
Dismantled dam materials were used to create new habitat for the valley’s threatened and endangered species, Massasauga rattlesnakes and Allegheny woodrats. Improved water flow, she said, will benefit the bugs eaten by Indiana bats.
“We think this is going to help the Dunbar community, too,” she said. “It’s a beautiful valley. These improvements should bring new recreation dollars into the region.”
In addition to the fishing, the valley includes part of the 150-mile Great Allegheny Passage trail and the Sheepshead Trail extension into the Dunbar community. Hollingsworth-Segedy said there was no local resistance to the project despite the emptying of several popular fishing holes.
Upstream, no concrete dams span the valley, but three wooden “jack dams,” originally built by Depression-era Civilian Conservation Corps workers, were sporadically repaired by Chestnut Ridge Trout Unlimited and the Dunbar Sportsmen’s Club. The wooden structures were mangled or destroyed in a 2014 flood that left exposed rebar, dredged gravel beds and scoured stream sections to the bedrock.
“The jack dams were definitely impediments to stream connectivity,” said Dale Kotowski, president of Chestnut Ridge TU. “They prevented fish from moving upstream during spawning and contributed to poaching in the Catch and Release area because that’s were the trout congregated. Some say it was easier to fish those pools, but I think this is far better. The creek is more healthy since the dams were destroyed.”
In a 2016 electroshock survey at the bottom of tributary Glade Run, researchers from California University of Pennsylvania and Chestnut Ridge TU found brook trout from five year-classes, including wild brook trout up to 10 and 11 inches.
With $4,500 in grants from Dominion Energy and the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, matching funds from Trout Unlimited and help from Cal U, the first of the dam remains will be removed in September. The project includes stabilization of a cross-stream gas pipeline that’s causing erosion of the stream bank.
Fish and Boat recently requested that the state Department of Environmental Protection designate all of Dunbar Creek as an “exceptional value stream.” A measure of water quality, the designation would give the creek and its headwaters the highest level of environmental protection.
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.