John Arway took charge of the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission in 2010 as his predecessor was being forced out. Last week, Arway said he was retiring following a 10-month legislative purge in which lawmakers moved to force him out.

After 38 years at various positions within the agency, Arway said it’s time for a change. His very public dispute with the legislature over the agency’s funding, he said, is just background noise.

“This really has nothing to do with that,” said Arway in a phone call minutes after issuing a statement that he’ll retire Nov. 2. “The time is right. Personally. Financially. I had this time frame in mind last year when we were doing the haggling over getting the legislature to move [on the funding issue]. They tried to force me to retire in March, but I wasn’t ready.`”

When Arway was promoted from environmental director, one of his top priorities, he said, was to get the user-funded commission on solid financial footing. Fish and Boat is a semi-autonomous commission of the executive branch. It gets little funding from the state, operating on what it brings in through license sales and the federal Dingell-Johnson Sport Fish Restoration Program, which includes an excise tax on fishing and boating equipment and boat fuel, and grants based on license sales.

Advertise with us

Explore the Outdoors with John Hayes!

Outdoors writer John Hayes shares tips, tricks, photos and more in his Facebook group. Join today!

The legislature doesn’t fund Fish and Boat, but by statute it sets the license fees. For various reasons, including the reluctance of politicians to tell voters they made it more expensive to go fishing, the commission has not received a license fee increase since 2005 when legislators set the price of an adult resident fishing license at $22.90.

Fish and Boat isn’t alone in its funding quandary. Another executive branch agency, the state Game Commission, has not seen a bump in license fees since 1999.

Throughout Arway’s eight-year battle with the legislature he’s tightened the belt at Fish and Boat. Staff was slashed by attrition from 432 to 366 full-time employees. The innovative addition of voluntary youth fishing licenses and vintage license buttons boosted Pennsylvania's Dingell-Johnson reapportionment.

Advertise with us

The agency, budgeted at $54 million, has a long-term policy of holding a cash reserve about equal to its annual budget. Commissioners call it a financial cushion insuring the survival of its wildlife and habitat programs should there be an ecological catastrophe. But with the agency unable to meet annual pension obligations and afford structural repair-or-replace priorities beyond 2018, commissioners ordered Arway to get the elusive funding increase or trim $2 million per year from the bone-thin budget beginning with the 2018-19 fiscal year.

By Arway’s calculations, he said, the agency would save just about $2 million if it shrank its cooperative fish nursery program, closed its cold-water trout hatcheries in Oswego, Potter County, and Union City, Erie County, and shuttered the Dyke Research Station for Anadromous Fishes, a cool-water shad program in Juniata County. The plan would dictate the loss of 220,000 of the 3.2 million trout that the agency stocks annually.

With his next decision, announced in September 2017, the fisheries biologist tacked into a political tempest he had been circumnavigating for eight years. The streams that would not be stocked, he said, would be in the jurisdictions of legislators who opposed increasing Fish and Boat funding. A map showing political divisions and waterways that would not get trout went up on Fish and Boat’s website.

“I thought, why should the [legislators] trying to help us be hurt?” said Arway. “Maybe I should have reconsidered.”

The strategy backfired. Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, even those who had supported a revenue increase, turned on Arway. Instead of raising license fees, they proposed Senate Bill 935, which would cap the position of Fish and Boat executive director to an eight-year term limit. Legislators vowed that no legislative action on license fees would occur until Arway was out.

Advertise with us

Publically, commissioners supported Arway while they considered options. The House passed its version of the term limit bill. The Senate version had not made it to a floor vote when Arway announced his retirement July 31.

Suddenly, the political clouds cleared and the tempest subsided. The term limit bill went away. Lawmakers who for years had balked at increasing funding for an agency with a $50 million cash reserve conceded that Fish and Boat needed a license fee increase. Committee chiefs who had blocked funding bills assured commissioners the matter would finally be decided,

“It’s going up for a vote. We’re moving that at the next session,” said Patrick Stefano, R-Fayette, who heads the Senate Game and Fisheries committee. Stephano now favors incremental license-fee increases over three years.

Keith Gillespie, R-York, chairman of the House Game and Fisheries Committee said he supports a license fee increase that grows incrementally over five years.

“I’ve always supported a funding increase, but there wasn’t enough support to put it up for a vote,” he said. “[Arway’s retirement] enabled legislators who didn’t appear to be supportive, unfortunately, to move that way. Now we’re back to setting a number — $6 million, $7 million [in revenue increases] phased in over five years, three years, whatever it turns out to be. I made a commitment to John and the commission … to do whatever we can do to get a license fee increase.”

Advertise with us

One plan that was never voted on by the full Senate would have increased next year's adult resident license fee to about $28.90 with annual increases of 3 percent during each of the following four years.

Arway admits that he pushed too hard to get funding. In his time as director, however, Arway prevented noticeable cuts in service at Fish and Boat. He initiated the ongoing Unassessed Waters program, in which the chemical signatures of 13,000 Pennsylvania waterways and their status as wild trout nurseries have been documented and the up-current watersheds of some have been protected by the state Department of Environment Protection.

Whether he’s a brilliant political chess player or just a passionate supporter of wildlife management and anglers, Arway’s pending retirement accomplishes the goal he set for himself eight years ago. According the lawmakers who can make it happen, Fish and Boat is finally getting a license fee increase.

“At the July meeting we got a commitment from the legislature to recognize our financial need and commit to a fee increase at the next session,” said Arway. “Our board deferred action on closing the hatcheries until next year, and we’ll see what happens then.”

By that time, Arway said, he’ll be fishing with his grandchildren and sitting in a tree stand waiting for the deer he hasn’t had time for in eight long years.