MINNEAPOLIS — An aquatic weed is creeping across the Great Lakes region. It grows really fast and is very hard to kill.

Scientists don’t know a lot yet about starry stonewort, but they’re hurrying to find out more. The robust algae first turned up in North America in 1978 in the St. Lawrence River in New York. Researchers think it probably arrived in ballast water from ships entering the Great Lakes.

It wasn’t a big concern for about 30 years, but then it took off. Now it’s widespread in Lake Erie waters of western New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania, where it has been sighted on the lagoons and canals of Presque Isle.

The algae has reached beyond the Great Lakes. On Michigan’s Lower Peninsula it has infested more than 200 inland lakes. It is present in inland waters of Canada, Vermont and Indiana. In Pennsylvania it has been documented in Lake Arthur, Butler County.

Advertise with us

The name starry stonewort comes from the tiny, white six-pointed star-shaped bulbs, or bulbils, that grow on the stems. In its native Europe and Asia it is endangered and even considered beneficial, but it turned aggressive in American waters.

Starry stonewort is difficult to kill with herbicides because it doesn’t have a vascular system that could carry the poison to the entire plant, said University of Minnesota invasive species specialist Dan Larkin. Herbicide treatments often result in a “haircut effect” that burns off the top but leaves the rest alive to regrow.

The weed mats -- up to 7 feet thick and spreading across the bottom -- can be a nuisance to boaters and anglers. Scientists are concerned about the potential harm to native plants, fish habitats and other disruptions to aquatic ecosystems. But last year Larkin said there was almost no peer-reviewed research documenting the algae’s adverse effects. Still, experts wouldn’t be sounding the alarm if they weren’t worried.

Researchers are just starting to understand the conditions in which the algae thrives, and modeling suggests that large swaths of the U.S. could be highly suitable, including the mid-Atlantic states, the Great Plains and much of the West, Larkin said,

Starry stonewort reproduces when fragments and bulbils break off, and they can hitchhike on contaminated boats and trailers. Recent discoveries have often been concentrated near public accesses such as boat ramps. Scientists don’t know yet how long those plant fragments can stay viable out of water, Larkin said.

Advertise with us

The algae is sometimes misidentified because the distinctive bulbils don’t appear until late in the season. In 2016 it was confirmed in a lake in northern Minnesota, but the infestation probably went unnoticed for several years. That finding is concerning because the Mississippi River flows through the lake, a popular fishing destination. No infestations have been found downstream so far, though monitoring continues, said Tim Plude, an invasive species specialist with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. He said the species doesn’t seem to like fast-moving water.

But it’s tough. Wisconsin has had some success with an expensive method known as DASH — Diver Assisted Suction Harvesting. Divers hand-pull plants and feed them into a big suction hose.

Different approaches were attempted on a popular recreational lake in central Minnesota where the weed was first discovered in the state. Crews used a mechanical harvester, aided by a diver, and followed up with herbicide. Researchers hopes to learn whether other methods of starry stonewort eradication work.

The best strategy, they say, is prevention. Boaters are urged to thoroughly clean their watercraft, trailers and other equipment of plants, mud and other debris before moving them from one body of water to another.

John Hayes contributed.

Advertise with us

Starry stonewort is not a ‘true’ plant

By John Hayes / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Starry stonewort was first observed in Presque Isle’s east and west canal bays in 2009. The U.S. Geological Survey’s most recent sighting in Presque Isle lagoons occurred in 2015, leading to the algae being categorized as “established” in Erie County. It is confirmed in Lake Arthur.

The algae is closely linked to very ancient life forms, according to a report by Pennsylvania Sea Grant, a research and educational program administered and funded by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Penn State University and the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

“While starry stonewort resembles a true plant, it is actually a rooted alga descended from some of the earliest life forms on earth ... thought by scientists to have been the ancestors to all plants,” the report states. “Its ability to degrade ecologically sensitive areas and proliferate rapidly makes it a highly invasive species.”

Advertise with us

Unlike some algaes, it is not dangerous to touch. Sometimes mistaken for musk-grass and brittlewort, Nitellopsis obtusa has long, straight branches of variable length patterned in whorls at stem nodes. Thin stems can stretch nearly 3 feet and grow at depths of more than 25 feet. Creamy white bulbils can appear just under the water surface or at branch intersections. The bulbils “pop” when squeezed.

Thick mats of starry stonewort can completely cover vast areas of lake bottom, obscuring light and decreasing the biodiversity of aquatic plants and animals that rely on bottom resources, including bug life, clams and small fish. Anglers are often unaware of the rapid change in bottom vegetation, which changes the feeding behaviors of game fish. When starry stonewort appears, fishing tactics need to change.

Because only male starry stonewort exists in the U.S., no viable seeds are produced. It spreads through fragmentation, and its reproductive cells can easily become attached to the fur and feathers of mammals and birds as well as boat hulls and trailers, which provide easy transport to inland waters such as Lake Arthur. The most likely Presque Isle-to-Lake Arthur vector was unintentional human transport.

In 2015 Pennsylvania Sea Grant coordinated a mock exercise involving government agencies and independent organizations that would be alerted during an aquatic invasive species emergency. Participants practiced a rapid response to a fictional starry stonewort situation unfolding at Presque Isle State Park.