Horticulturists have been cross-breeding existing species into new plants for at least as long as there has been civilization -- some 8,000 years. The ancient Chinese even experimented with designer goldfish varieties.

But the process for breeding gold-colored trout was invented in West Virginia.

In 1955 the manager of the state’s Petersburg trout hatchery noticed unusual yellow specks on the side of one juvenile female rainbow trout. During the next eight years, hatchery staff selectively spawned her gold-mottled offspring, eventually producing a strain of rainbow trout with so little black and green skin pigmentation that the yellows and reds dominated, resulting in a rainbow trout that appeared to be golden, sometimes with a reddish horizontal stripe from gillplate to tail.

The new strain was ready for stocking just as West Virginia was about to celebrate its golden anniversary -- 100 years since its separation from Virginia during the Civil War. In 1963 the state’s trout anglers got a treat when the Division of Natural Resources unveiled the West Virginia Centennial Golden Trout, stocked at a ratio of one for every 10 traditional rainbows.

Advertise with us

Other American wildlife agencies later developed their own novelty rainbow trout, but all golden rainbows living today trace their lineage to that one yellow-mottled genetic variant noticed by accident in that West Virginia hatchery.

Pennsylvania’s first attempt at novelty breeding in 1967 resulted in a pale green-and-yellow strain of rainbow trout called “palominos.” But there were problems.

“A palomino is what they got first in West Virginia,” said Brian Wisner, director of the Bureau of Hatcheries for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission. “Breed a palomino with a palomino and you’ll get rainbows, palominos and goldens. If you keep breeding goldens to goldens, which we do now, you get only goldens -- they breed true. With the palominos, you’d have to keep sorting them out, which took too much time, and people didn’t like them as much.”

The strain was discontinued when Fish and Boat came up with its own brightly colored golden rainbow, although some Pennsylvania anglers still erroneously call them “palominos.”

None of the golden rainbows are genetically linked to the true California golden trout, which evolved naturally high on the slopes of the Sierra Nevada Mountains. Golden rainbows are not sterile, but the chances of reproduction in the wild, said Wisner, are “very slim.”

Advertise with us

“Mathematically it’s possible, but I’d take that bet every day,” he said. “We don’t have a lot of naturally reproducing rainbows to begin with, compared to brook and brown trout. The golden rainbows are so vulnerable to predation, especially by humans, because they’re so visible. Even if you had golden to golden breeding, when the eggs hatch you’d have a lot of little yellowish, whitish fry that would be eaten up by everything.”

Wisner said the yearly goal of the Pennsylvania hatchery system is to produce 9,000 trophy-size golden rainbows. Another 1,000 golden rainbow fingerlings are raised by cooperative nurseries.

“They’re distributed throughout the state so that everybody has a chance to try to harvest one,” he said. “We try to stock them at 18 inches on average -- 2 1/2- to 3-year-old fish.”

Rainbow trout in hatcheries are susceptible to color variations, and about 1 in every 200,000 comes out blue. Wisner said there would be no novelty angling advantage to intentionally producing a blue trout that’s not easily visible. Creating novelty colors in other species would be impractical, he said, because of the way other species breed.

“Trout have a different reproduction system. They’re easy to spawn -- you can pick them up by hand and breed individual to individual,” he said. “Also, the trout we stock are intended to be put-and-take. You wouldn’t want to spread a genetic mutation into a naturally reproducing species.”

Advertise with us

The golden rainbow is biologically identical to the traditional rainbow trout, which was transplanted from its native Pacific Ocean tributaries in northern Asia and North America to waterways around the world.

Golden rainbows are neither smarter nor dumber than any other rainbow trout. They are not heftier or skinnier, harder or easier to catch, stronger or weaker fighters or better or worse tasting. The only difference is the brighter skin tone and the excitement they generate among anglers who can see what they’re fishing for.