For Jeff Coles of North Huntingdon, Westmoreland County, fishing is more than a hobby. A busy purchasing engineer for a manufacturing company, he calls his weekends on the water “an escape.”

“It’s a critical part of keeping my sanity,” he said. “In the spring and summer I fish for walleye, but I trout fish in the off-season when there’s nobody else there. It’s my therapy.”

With several recent catches, Coles may have found a cure.

In October, 2017, he began catching rainbow trout in the 20-inch range on Loyalhanna Creek near Ligonier. That could be expected -- the 1.67-mile Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only section is enrolled in the state Fish and Boat Commission’s Keystone Select Stocked Trout Waters program, in which 14- to 20-inch browns and rainbows are stocked in the spring at a density of 175 to 225 big fish per mile, in addition to regular state stockings of the same species.

Advertise with us

But in November Coles’ started filing Fishing Report selfies with beautifully striped tiger trout in the 20-inch range, all caught, he said, outside of the Delayed Harvest area.

Extremely rare in nature, tigers occur when brown trout eggs are fertilized by brook trout sperm. Both species inhabit the Loyalhanna and crossbreeding is possible, but not likely to produce fish of the size and frequency caught by Coles and other anglers, who quietly catch and release tiger trout near Ligonier.

This fish story takes another turn: Fish and Boat does not breed the exotic hybrid in its hatchers or stock them in the state’s streams.

“Commission trout hatcheries have experimented with raising and stocking small numbers of tiger trout to determine if they would grow any faster or more efficiently than other species,” states a page on the agency’s website. “... As no biological advantage was found, this practice was discontinued around 2005.”

Nevertheless, Coles filed another Fishing Report with photos taken Jan. 26-27 showing him chomping on a cigar while a 19 ½ -inch tiger trout chomps on his Joe’s Fly, the golden spinner still hanging from its mouth. In 2 ½ hours on the water, he said, he released three tigers between 18 and 20 inches (he recognized one, which may have been caught twice). The next day was all about rainbows, he said. Three of 22, 19 and 18 inches were released.

Advertise with us

A few calls to other anglers who fish those waters confirmed Coles’ claims. One savvy fly fisherman said the Loyalhanna tigers were, “the best kept secret in Ligonier.”

“I don’t see a lot of tigers in the fall,” said Coles. “During the freeze-over and just after, they’ll chase fast-moving spinners.”

Sometimes he doesn’t even get in the water. Coles catches trophy-size tiger trout pitching brown Joe’s Flies with an ultralight spinning rod. The fight on a fly rod, he said, is even more exciting.

“As I learn to fly fish, I’m finding some open spots where I can backcast, and that’s where I’m catching the tigers,” he said. “I’m using a 5-weight rod and 5x tippet with pretty big single-hook streamers -- like a Marabou Minnow or anything dull. Nothing flashy.”

Coles said the tigers defy much of what he knew about trout fishing.

Advertise with us

“They say use small nymphs fished very slowly in cold water, but I’m fishing in tinged snow-melt using big spinners or No. 16 streamers and Wooly Buggers and retrieving fast,” he said. “I want the fly line to have some slack in it. I throw upstream and just before the end of the swing I give it some slack so the fly drops down, bouncing off the bottom.”

Mike Depew, a fisheries biologist for Fish and Boat, said he’s not surprised to hear of the veracity of the tiger strikes.

“They’re reputed to be pretty efficient piscivores -- they like to eat a lot of fish,” he said. “I’ve never caught one, but they can be fairly aggressive at times and are acrobatic fighters. That’s why some private hatcheries raise them to sell to fishing clubs. What we found was there’s a really poor [hatchery] survival rate. About 25 percent of the eggs survived compared to about 95 percent survival for other trout.”

Pennsylvania inland water regulations apply to all trout species. Outside special regulations areas the extended trout season ends Feb. 28. No specific bait or tactic works best to target tiger trout, said Depew, but in waters where they cohabitate with smaller trout the big tigers may be the first to strike.

Depew was quick to add that the unintentional presence of the exotic species, even at trophy sizes, is not likely to crowd out their more common cousins on the Loyalhanna.

Advertise with us

“It’s not something I consider to be an issue,” he said. “Tigers are a sterile hybrid, so there’s no chance of them getting into the gene pool, especially in populations of [state] stocked trout. As for them eating all the bugs, the amount of biomass in Loyalhanna Creek is quite high -- no matter how many [tiger trout] are getting in, there’s plenty of food. They can’t push out the stocked fish since they are a stocked fish themselves, technically speaking, having come from a hatchery.”

Which hatchery is a sticky issue. A few independent trout farms in the surrounding Laurel Highlands are regulated by the state Department of Environmental Protection. Depew noted that the exclusive Rolling Rock Club, on 10,000 acres along Route 30 east of Ligonier, operates a trout hatchery used to stock the private Rolling Rock Creek, a Loyalhanna tributary, and parts of Loyalhanna Creek also on private property just below the headwaters.

A Rolling Rock Club spokesman declined to comment on the workings of a private facility.

“I don’t know exactly what they raise,” said Depew, “but those fish can travel upstream or downstream to other areas. They move. We picked up tiger trout as far down as Loyalhanna Lake [20 miles downstream], two years ago in our nets. One was in the 17-inch range.”

Depew said wherever the tigers are coming from, it’s good news for anglers.

“I kind of look at them going into public areas as kind of a bonus,” he said.