TRAVERSE CITY, Mich. — A federal report released last week proposes a $275 million array of technological and structural upgrades at a crucial site in Illinois to prevent invasive Asian carp from reaching the Great Lakes and its vulnerable fish populations.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers outlined its tentative plan in a report that had been scheduled for release in February but was delayed by the Trump administration, drawing criticism from members of Congress and environmental groups.

It analyzes options for upgrading the Brandon Road Lock and Dam near Joliet on the Des Plaines River, part of an aquatic chain that connects Lake Michigan to the Asian carp-infested Mississippi River watershed. The Brandon Road complex is considered a bottleneck where defenses could be strengthened against fish swimming upstream toward openings to the lake at Chicago.

The report is the latest of several developed by the Army Corps since it began examining species migration between the two watersheds in 2009. The study was inspired by discovery of Asian carp DNA upriver from the existing electric barriers — part of a system with a history of power outages and criticism that it does not operate at a strength to repel even small fish — in the shipping canal, raising questions about whether carp were slipping through them. Two live carp were found past the barriers, the latter in June.

Advertise with us

Since bighead and silver carp can grow up to 100 pounds and eat 20 percent of their body weight in plankton each day, scientists and environmental advocates fear they could devastate Great Lakes fisheries. If the large, voracious filter-feeding carp became established in the Great Lakes, they could devastate the region’s $7 billion recreational fishing industry on the U.S. side, as well as the economies of Great Lakes sport fishing in Canada and commercial fishing in both countries, by out-competing native species.

Chuck Murray, Lake Erie fisheries manager for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, said he doubts that $275 million will fix the problem.

$700,000 Asian carp challenge

Got an original idea for keeping Asian carp from reaching the Great Lakes? It could earn you some good money.

Michigan’s “Invasive Carp Challenge” is underway. Gov. Rick Snyder says the state is accepting proposals for shielding the lakes from the invasive fish, which have infested the Mississippi River watershed. Scientists say if they become established in the lakes, they could crowd out prized native species.

Advertise with us

Scientists and engineers in the region are working on the problem. But the state wants to inspire creative thinkers worldwide to offer innovative solutions.

Officials will accept proposals in any phase of development, from concept to design to field-tested models.

Written proposals will be accepted through Oct. 31. One or more winners will share up to $700,000 in cash awards.

The Invasive Carp Challenge will be hosted by the crowdsourcing company InnoCentive. Interested solvers can join InnoCentive's solver network at any time, free of charge. Visit the InnoCentive Challenge Center (www.innocentive.com/ar/challenge/9933993) to register and submit your solution.

- Associated Press

Advertise with us

“I consider it a Band-Aid at best,” he said, “unless they provide separation.”

He’s talking about restoration of the natural separation of the Mississippi Rivers system and the Great Lakes that occurred at the end of the last Ice Age. The only way to stop Asian silver, black and big head carp from entering the lakes, he said, is to “return the waterways to their original state.”

Hydraulic separation —  literally blocking the man-made waterway linkage installed for commercial traffic — was the most thorough and expensive of eight carp-migration prevention options provided by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Estimated cost: billions with a B.

“There have been numerous investigations that have had various perspectives on ... how Asian carp would impact fishing in Lake Erie,” said Murray. “They would be coming in through Illinois, and that seems like a long way, but once they’re in the [Great Lakes] there would be no way to stop them.”

The grass carp that have lived in Lake Erie and western Pennsylvania for years were recently categorized “invasive,” joining the silver, black and big head species whose range expansion beyond the Mississippi river system is in question. All species of Asian carp are filter feeders that eat various planktons. The Asian carp would directly compete for algae and other microscopic life with quagga and zebra mussels, mollusks, sturgeon and other filter feeders. That might sound beneficial to Lake Erie until you consider the scale of the potential competition.

Advertise with us

“They would totally disrupt the bottom of the food chain, which would have an impact on the predators at the top,” said Murray. “And there’s a direct impact — most game fish feed primarily on plankton when they initially hatch from the egg.”

So far, he said, environmental DNA surveys have found no traces of silver, black or big head carp in Presque Isle Bay, but a reproducing population of grass carp have lived there for years.

Pennsylvania steelhead streams are probably too small for Asian carp breeding, he said, but reproduction could occur in any of the big rivers that empty into Lake Erie from other states and provinces.

The Army corps said the plan outlined in the 488-page document is intended to block the path of invasive species “while minimizing impacts to waterway uses and users.” Elected officials and business leaders in Illinois and Indiana have said that significant changes to the Brandon Road complex could hamper cargo shipment on the busy waterway.

Among technologies the report endorses is using sound systems to create “complex noise” underwater that would deter fish from the Brandon Road area, plus installing a new approach channel and placing an electric barrier at its downstream end that would repel fish and stun them if they get too close. Brandon Road is several miles downstream from an existing barrier network in the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal.

Advertise with us

Other measures would include installing water jets to wash away “small and stunned fish” that might be caught up around barges, plus a new lock where floating invasive species could be flushed away and rapid-response boat mooring and launch spots.

The report says the federal government would pay 65 percent of the project’s costs, with the rest coming from an unidentified “non-federal sponsor,” which Illinois officials said probably meant their state. A massive influx of food-chain disruptors would quickly impact Canadian sport and commercial fisheries. Murray said that while the Canadians invest in research in Asian carp, he knows of no legislation that would authorize Canada to “belly up to the bar” in co-financing an invasion-prevention plan with the United States.

If the Army Corps project was implemented, “Illinois taxpayers would be on the hook for over $95 million in construction cost and another $8 million in annual operation and maintenance costs,” said Illinois Lt. Gov. Evelyn Sanguinetti.

Despite the benefit of protecting the lakes from voracious Asian carp, the Army corps acknowledged its preferred approach could affect other wildlife species, from turtles, frogs and otters caught in the electric current to native fish whose migration paths would be interrupted.

Most of the eight states adjoining the Great Lakes, including Pennsylvania, have called for dams or other structures to physically separate the two watersheds, an idea Illinois and Indiana oppose.

Advertise with us

In a joint statement, the Alliance for the Great Lakes, Natural Resources Defense Council, Sierra Club and Prairie Rivers Network said the corps plan was “another step in the fight against the upstream movement of Asian carp,” but didn’t address how to impede Great Lakes fish from migrating downstream into the Mississippi watershed.

The corps will take public comments on the report until Sept. 21. After a feasibility study and series of federal and state reviews, a final version is scheduled for release in August 2019. Congressional approval and funding would be required to begin construction, which could be finished by 2025.

“The Army Corps report makes clear that it’s time for serious preventative actions to keep Asian carp out of the Great Lakes,” said Howard Learner, executive director of the Chicago-based Environmental Law and Policy Center. “The ecological and economic costs of further delays are not sensible or acceptable.”

The National Wildlife Federation said the Army Corps plan to make Asian carp “run the gauntlet” before they reach the Brandon Road lock looked promising.

“While we are still evaluating the draft report, our initial reaction is that a combination of these options could possibly reduce the chance that an Asian carp gets through at each stage,” said Marc Smith, Great Lakes Conservation Director for the National Wildlife Federation.

Advertise with us

In a summer fishing season when 50- to 70-walleye hookups are common and the perch bite is solid, this could be as good as it gets.

“If the Asian carp come it will have some impact on fishing, and I think there’s no question they’re coming,” he said. “I wonder if there’s some inevitability to it.”

The Post-Gazette contributed.