Echoing the old real estate mantra, “Location, location, location,” David McElroy said his unlikely winter pastime is all about “position.”
Hiking over woodlots and railroad tracks at dusk in a cold winter rain, he reached his spot near the mouth of an Allegheny River tributary in Allegheny County. He paused near the bank to assess the rising flow, hours before the National Weather Service issued a regional flood advisory.
“This could be a good day,” he said.
A good day for fly fishing. For walleye. In the river. In January?
McElroy chuckled at the suggestion that by conventional wisdom he was using the wrong gear in the wrong place at the wrong time of year.
“Yeah, I’ve heard that,” he said, grinning. “But I’m fishing every single day and doing pretty good.”
That’s an understatement. Since late November, McElroy has been sending notices to the Post-Gazette’s Friday Fishing Report accompanied by photos showing him cradling big walleye. A 10 pounder. A 24-inch pre-spawn female. He catches other species, too. A 30-inch flathead. Big carp.
“I just want to do things that other people aren’t doing that I know could be done,” he said.
Born in Pittsburgh, McElroy grew up fishing in Florida, where he never touched a fly rod. He was introduced to fly fishing a little over a year ago.
“I saw some guys on Erie tributaries fly fishing,” he said. “They were catching more steelhead than me, so I switched over.”
A catch and release guy, McElroy said he’s caught stocked trout using nymphs or streamers. But discovering that the same rod could wrestle in big walleye and heavy common carp, just a short drive from his Brookline home, changed everything.
“I found out I can fish right here,” he said, reading the water as it crested over a small brush-covered nearshore island. The tiny spit of normally dry land creates a visible seam, even in the evening’s rising flow, as the water breaks around it. Through many days and nights of trial and error, McElroy found that when conditions were right walleye cluster on the shallow slow-moving side of the seam.
“You have to be in the right position to fish this spot,” he said. Getting there was a treacherous, waist-deep slog around the edge of the submerged island, its stiff dead weeds poking out of the rising water. McElroy positioned himself with his back against the stiff weeds about 10 yards below the island’s upstream edge.
“The water temperature is on the rise on the third day of a warming trend,” he said. “That’s what I’ve been waiting for. The water temperature was 42 yesterday, it’s probably 43 to 45 now.”
McElroy looks for current breaks and depressions on the bottom in water that is 1 to 10 feet deep.
“You see the break?” he asked. He pointed his rod to the aquatic line on the surface where the current that was slowed by contact with the island met the faster water of the rising river.
“In warm periods in the winter, the walleye will move around more and get active. When it’s warm, about 43 degrees, they’ll come up off the bottom to eat,” he said. “You have to go deep, keep your fly on the bottom. I lose a lot of flies.”
McElroy goes for just about any streamer tied on a No. 2 to No. 4 hook. Color is the vital element.
“I’m mainly a streamer guy,” he said. “I’m a stripper for life.”
Casting a chartreuse streamer tied to a level 10-pound test fluorocarbon leader and sinking fly line, he dropped it on the inside edge of the seam and let it fall. When the fly hit the bottom, he stripped in line with two abrupt tugs.
“I’ll cast upstream and bring it down past. Or sometimes I’ll cast downstream and swing it. It depends on where I think the fish are and the best position I can get,” he said. “You pause maybe 5 seconds after your cast. Let it get to the bottom, strip it twice and let it drift for maybe 3 seconds. A lot of times they’ll see it on the drop and take it when it hits the bottom.”
Within about 45 minutes, McElroy had hooked, fought, netted and released two big fish. They weren’t walleye, but he had a blast bringing in two bigmouth buffalo -- an overgrown cousin of the sucker -- one weighing upwards of 10 pounds. A filter-feeder that rakes zooplankton from the bottom, both buffalo were hooked by the streamer on the lips.
“That’s weird,” he said. “They must have picked it up off the bottom when [the fly] dropped. I knew right away it wasn’t a walleye, unless it was foul hooked, from the way it fought.”
While he was fighting the 10-pounder, the dusk had turned to darkness. After its release, McElroy switched on his headlamp and looked behind him at the submerged dead weeds.
“Hmmm. The river’s rising,” he said. “We’d better get out out here.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.