You can cut. You can purr. Scratch the ground, relocate, clam up for hours. It can be frustrating to wait for a wary tom to step into range.
“I’ve tried everything. When they don’t come, they don’t come,” said Perry Burdick, proprietor of Burdick’s Lodge, a deer and turkey camp and guide service in Smethport, McKean County. “If there was a way to get a gobbler to come in, even 25 percent of the time, everybody would use it. The fact of the matter is, when the gobbler’s ready, the gobbler’s ready.”
Hunters getting ready for the April 30 spring gobbler opener might put some thought into how they’ll deal with toms that won’t budge. Burdick says it used to be easier.
When Pennsylvania held its first spring gobbler hunt in 1969, following a pilot program a year earlier, the toms were less cautious. But the state has changed since then and so have the turkeys, Burdick said. In the early 1970s, the big woods were bigger and carried less undergrowth. Despite decades of rampant development and industrial intrusions, world-class management of native Eastern wild turkeys is generally credited for increasing their numbers nearly 10-fold — from an estimated 30,000 birds in 1969 to a peak population of some 280,000 in 2001. Since 2014, the trend has held at around 234,000, or about 9 percent above the 10-year average, according to the state Game Commission.
But Burdick said there’s another reason turkey hunters of a generation past may have had it easier.
“The turkeys then were uneducated,” he said. “Now they’re more aware of all those hunters in the woods. They can tell a live hen from a bad call. Now in Pennsylvania, it’s extremely difficult to kill a gobbler in the spring.”
The Holy Grail of turkey hunting is a call or tactic likely to prompt a distant and stubborn long-beard to close the gap. Burdick said just about everything imaginable has been tried.
“Methods have changed. When I started, we stayed still,” he said. “If I would have scraped the leaves when we saw a gobbler my dad would have been mad. Now everybody does it. That, and moving back when he won’t come closer.”
Turkey hunters reward product manufacturers for technological creativity. Electrical calls and devices are prohibited in Pennsylvania turkey hunting, but sales are up for decoys that move with the wind. And there’s always a market for new camouflage patterns.
“We’ve created new products and techniques since the ’70s and educated ourselves,” Burdick said. “The selection of commercial calls is unbelievable compared to the ’50s and ’60s. We’ve done everything to increase our odds, but it’s still extremely hard to get a reluctant tom to come closer.”
No turkey tactic has generated more buzz, or is more controversial, than “reaping.” TV hunting shows and YouTube videos rave about the effectiveness of the counterintuitive practice sometimes called “jumping” or “fanning.” Hidden behind a decoy or actual spread tail, the hunter crawls quickly toward a hung-up tom, provoking a charge.
“Actually, it’s becoming very popular, but in some states it’s running into the legality of stalking,” Burdick said. “In Pennsylvania, you’re not allowed to stalk.”
It’s a safety thing. Nearly all non-self-inflicted turkey-hunting-related shooting incidents occur when a stationary hunter mistakenly shoots at an approaching sound or movement, or when a hunter creeping up on what is believed to be a turkey mistakenly shoots a calling hunter.
The regs are clear: Hunting by calling only. But there’s a legal caveat: Hunting by not calling.
“There are a couple of things you can do when a gobbler won’t come in,” Burdick said. “If he responds to your call one or two times but is 100, 200 yards away, stop calling and don’t move. It’s highly likely that sometime during that morning he’ll come back to where he thinks that hen was. But it might be four hours, and 95 percent of hunters don’t want to sit for that long.”
Burdick said his go-to tactic for birds that won’t close the gap is all about scouting and positioning.
“This is guaranteed,” he said. “Turkeys are birds of habit. If a gobbler is coming into a field where hens are, he’ll come in every day in the same way, strut in the same place and exit the field by the same route. So you set up near that exit spot. Don’t move. Don’t make a sound. You know he’s going to leave that field eventually. Just wait.”
Most hunters aren’t that patient, Burdick said, but those who are take home a tom every year.
Burdick's Lodge: 814-887-4160, wildcat887@comcast.net, www.padeerhunting.net.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.