ERIE -- In what looks to be another weird weather year, ice fishing lasted just a few weeks, ice-out was a month early on most waters and spring temperatures have fluctuated from 20 to 60 degrees or higher.

As a result, still waters in northwestern Pennsylvania have stayed right around ice-out temperatures, providing an extended 40-degree spawning trigger for early spawning fish.

While most Pennsylvania anglers are catching stocked trout, some avoid the crowds and target native northern pike from the shores of Presque Isle’s quiet lagoons.

“People don’t see them that often, but you just never know,” said Keith DiLuzio, a winning pro-angler, fishing guide and owner of Bassin’ on the Bay Charters, based in North East. “I know because I grew up fishing [on Presque Isle] with my dad. It’s not a secret -- everybody up here knows about spring pike -- but not a lot of fisherman come up for them.”

Advertise with us

Truly a product of glacial ages, northerns are one of the few fish species whose natural range includes North America, Europe and Asia. In Pennsylvania, they’re native to the Ohio and Allegheny river watersheds and Lake Erie. For some 14,000 years, since a melting glacier dropped the moraine that formed Presque Isle, pike have lived among the tall grasses in the clear waters of the peninsula’s leeward lagoons.

“They’re not a traveling fish. There’s no migration like with walleye or steelhead or perch,” said DiLuzio. “These northerns live in these small bays and come into the lagoon to spawn.”

Water temperatures of 40 to just over 50 degrees trigger the spawn. Unusually unstable weather since this year’s early ice-out have left the waters around Presque Isle stuck at about 40 degrees, and the northerns are believed to be stuck in a pre-spawn state.

“Every lake is different,” said DiLuzio. “In this area, they’ll probably spawn any time between now and early May, and just like other fish they’ll come in waves over a period of time.”

Northerns feed voraciously during the pre-spawn, then clam up when spawning occurs. During daylight hours in weedy backwaters of 3 to 5 feet, females broadcast 3,000 to 120,000 adhesive eggs over plants, logs and other organic matter. No parental care is provided to eggs or fry. Later in the spring when other fish spawn, the young pike have grown large enough to eat their young.

Advertise with us

One of the fastest-growing freshwater fish, northern pike can reach 6 to 12 inches in their first year. They can live for 25 years, and the state record, caught in 2003 at Allegheny Reservoir, McKean County, weighed 35 pounds.

Northerns are often caught incidentally by bass anglers on medium tackle, but DiLuzio said it’s best to specialize when targeting pike from shore. A heavy spinning rod strung with 15- to 20-pound monofilament can land a fighting northern, but most pike anglers play it safe with a 7-foot-plus casting rod and braided line. A wire leader isn’t necessary, but DiLuzio said it can’t hurt.

“They’re not line shy,” he said, “and they’re not spooked by big lures. When I was little, my dad would catch northerns all through the lagoon and Thompson Bay, right here behind us. The only lure he ever used was a Mepps No. 3 with a piece of pork rind on it.”

Bigger is generally better when targeting northerns. DiLuzio likes big-hair Bucktails and 8- to 10-inch shad-style swimbaits.

“Big stuff that can hardly fit into your tackle box,” he said. “In April and early May, I’d do a dying shad -- a bigger version of the fluke baits that the bass guys use. Early in the season fish everything slow -- they won’t chase it until the temperature rises. ”

Advertise with us

Shore fishing for pre-spawn northerns can feel more like hunting. Quietly and without disturbing the water, walk the banks looking for choke points where the pike might pass, and for grass or wood habitat where they might wait for warmer spawning water.

“I think it’s about the effort you put into it,” said DiLuzio. “Having the right tackle, zeroing in on just northerns, anything can happen.”

Contact Bassin’ on the Bay Charters at 814-460-3160, basscharter@gmail.com.