Its name, or rather one of them, hints at resilient survival. North America’s biggest wild cat became known as “mountain lion” because the remote Rocky Mountains were its last stronghold after determined persecution confined it there. But the same animal, also called cougar or puma, had stalked eastern forests for thousands of years including what is now Western Pennsylvania where cat-fearing 18th century settlers called it “panther” or sometimes “painter.”

For the next two centuries, anyone who saw one killed a panther at every chance. Settlers cleared its forest habitat and shot away its prey of elk and deer. Once the western hemisphere’s most widely distributed mammal, ranging from northern Canada to South America’s southern tip, the mountain lion retreated to its high western refuge, leaving behind one stranded eastern remnant — the Florida panther, denizen of the Everglades.

But now cougars are probing eastward again.

The Cougar Network, an assembly of research scientists and state wildlife agency biologists, has been investigating, dismissing and verifying cougar occurrences in unlikely locations. Between 1990 and 2014, the network confirmed 790 lion reports from Midwest and prairie states. Most confirmations have come from Kansas, Nebraska, Missouri, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Wisconsin and Michigan, with a scattering in Illinois and Indiana. But there’s another smaller cluster of verified cougar presences in New York, Maine, Massachusetts and even Connecticut, where a young male lion with DNA originating in South Dakota’s Black Hills ended up as suburban road-kill in 2011.

Advertise with us

The researchers also studied potential cougar habitats across the central United States and made predictions. In a study soon to be published in the journal Ecological Modelling, Cougar Network executive director and University of Minnesota research associate Dr. Michelle LaRue predicts that cougars will re-establish breeding populations in blocks of suitable habitat across the Midwest within 25 years.

“They can travel through and around open country by sticking to river corridors,” LaRue said. “They’re ambush predators, so they stick to cover to catch deer and other prey.”

Cougar Network scientists believe a few wandering cats entered New England by traveling through Canada north of the Great Lakes.

LaRue and other researchers constructed mathematical models to forecast eastward cougar dispersal, considering variables that might slow or accelerate range expansion. The most important variable was the level of mountain lion harvest by hunters and trappers in cougar-rich western states. Even when LaRue’s team ran its models with heavy hunting and trapping mortality in the West, they still predicted eastward spillover.

“Prevailing knowledge holds that a stimulus for this dispersal is that cougar management out west changed from classing the species a predator to a managed game species with regulatory protections,” LaRue said. “That allowed populations to rebound. In many parts of the West there may be no room for more cougars in established territories, so some have dispersed.”

Advertise with us

LaRue said most of the network’s confirmations in the Midwest and Northeast are of male cougars.

“The presence of a dispersing male doesn’t demonstrate a breeding population,” she said. “An adult male cougar won’t tolerate other males in its territory, so young males might move long distances. The question regarding the establishment of new breeding populations is; how long will it take the less mobile females to reach islands of suitable habitat?”

The Cougar Network confirms or rejects cougar reports after analyzing tracks, scat, hair and the proliferation of photographs from hunters’ scouting cameras. Often, as in the case of a cougar shot and killed by police officers in Bourbon County, Ky., in December 2014, the researchers can examine a carcass.

“We must have physical evidence,” LaRue said. “Sightings are unreliable. Most sightings turn out to be bobcats or even house cats.”

When the network learns of a potential cougar photograph, network members or cooperating biologists from the respective state go to the site to verify authenticity.

Advertise with us

That happened with a Tennessee photograph taken by a hunter’s scouting camera last fall. Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency biologists made photographs at the same location to compare vegetation, landscape and soils. They confirmed that a cougar had passed through Obion County, Tenn., in October 2015. The confirmation was significant because Tennessee is east of the Mississippi River, assumed to present a significant obstacle to mountain lion movements.

LaRue refused to speculate about movements of cougars into Pennsylvania and the Appalachian or Mid-Atlantic regions.

“Any observations I might make about the East would not be based on any research,” she said. “We chose to study the Midwest because it’s the next-most likely place for cougars to disperse. The Appalachians would likely offer adequate habitat — if [cougars] can get there — but we haven’t studied the region because it’s too far out on a likely timeline.”

Matt Lovallo, wildlife biologist with the Pennsylvania Game Commission, said his agency receives reports of mountain lions from across the state, but he doubts there is a reproducing population anywhere in Pennsylvania at this time.

Lovallo rejects the possibility that the recent widespread use of scouting cameras might be simply documenting something that was always there.

Advertise with us

“When they [cougars] are really there, you’ll find them,” he said. “In the Midwestern states, they’ve found supporting evidence quickly when valid reports came in. Lions leave tracks, get hit by cars or people shoot them, whether they should or shouldn’t. I think the volume of new reports of long-range dispersal events are a function of a growing population in established ranges. That’s where the genetic material from collected carcasses and hair has traced back to.”

Lovallo invites hunters who get photos of what they believe are mountain lions to contact the Game Commission.

“I’m fully open to the possibility that someday one could make it here and we will have a confirmed report,” he said.