OHIOPYLE, Pa. — The strike was hard, visibly jerking the surface-floating fly line. The fish was heavy, like a log that was swimming upriver before turning abruptly into a frothy chute that carried it quickly downstream. The fight was long, covering about 100 yards of the Youghiogheny River — the guide deftly maneuvering the inflatable raft, the tight line sharply bowing the rod, the fish awkwardly wrapping itself in tippet before surrendering to the net.

The plump 22-inch rainbow trout was caught deep on a stonefly pattern during a May raft trip on the Middle Yough. Before releasing the fish, I noticed its bright silver scales and oil-stain colors — curiously dissimilar to the red ochre rainbows I had tangled with on a similar Youghiogheny raft trip last year.

Why did this trout look so different?

“It could be what they’re eating,” said Ryan McCauley, head fishing guide at Ohiopyle’s Wilderness Voyagers outfitter, as he rowed the raft toward the next seam. “Or it could be that this rainbow is biologically different than the other rainbows from a different strain stocked by a different group.”

Advertise with us

The Middle Yough is stocked by several organizations with varying philosophies on how best to improve the fishery. More small fingerlings or fewer catchable trout? Warm water-tolerant rainbows or cool-water browns? Marking trout for future research or not?

In 2014 a voluntary stakeholders working group was formed to increase communication among the stockers, and a new Youghiogheny River management plan is due this year.

“We laid it on the table [in 2014] that what we have to do is find out whether fingerlings or catchable trout are making the greater impact on the fishery,” said state Fish and Boat Commission regional fisheries biologist Rick Lorson. “We’re grateful for the help and we all get along. But we all need to be on the same page so we can gather reliable data, and right now that isn’t the case.”

Named for an Algonquin word meaning “stream that flows in a contrary direction,” the 134-mile-long Youghiogheny River is a rare north-flowing waterway. It spits out of Maryland’s Class V rapids, pours from Youghiogheny River Lake near Confluence, tumbles over scenic falls at Ohiopyle and empties into the Monongahela River at McKeesport.

A generation ago, the river ran red with industrial pollution, but in 2008 it was designated River of the Year by the Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources. With diverse gradients, temperatures and habitats, the long waterway is managed by Fish and Boat as six distinct fisheries.

Advertise with us

The Middle Yough — 9 rugged miles from Ramcat Run below Confluence to the Route 381 bridge at Ohiopyle — is widely considered one of the best trout and smallmouth waters in the eastern United States.

Bottomed with big boulders and sparse gravel, trout reproduction is rare, although the tributaries hold natives. But through most of the year, the bottom-release dam fills the tailrace and Middle Yough with clean cool water, enabling stocked trout to holdover. Some survive for years on robust populations of stoneflies, caddisflies, mayflies, sculpin, crayfish and additional foods. All Tackle Trophy Trout regulations (14-inch minimum, two trout in possession) help some of the section’s browns and rainbows to grow to rod-bending proportions.

About a quarter of all the fingerling trout stocked in Pennsylvania are planted in 29 miles of the Youghiogheny River. Fish and Boat annually stocks about 175,000 brown and rainbow fingerlings of 2 to 4 inches.

“We estimate 12.5 percent survive to legal size,” said Lorson, “and it takes about three years for them to grow to 14 inches.”

Independent groups that also stock the Middle Yough question the state’s fry-stocking policy and pursue another way. The Chestnut Ridge chapter of Trout Unlimited raises browns and rainbows in cages at the tailrace, stocking 10,000 to 15,000 8-inch browns and rainbows per year. Last year, the nearby Nemacolin Woodlands Resort and Spa began annual stockings of 6,000 browns and rainbows of 6 to 8 inches.

Advertise with us

“The perception is that 8-inch fish is the way to go,” said Lorson. “In theory and on paper, that can look like a good idea, but our research does not confirm that those fish do better. Part of the problem is we’re getting catchable [trout] from the tailrace, Laurel Hill Creek and the Casselman River, TU and Nemacolin as well as those we stocked as fry. It’s hard to confirm which stocking method is better. We need more coordination.”

TU chapter president Dale Kotowski said he understands that outside stockings can skew Fish and Boat’s data.

“But it’s also about the cost of feeding their fingerlings longer and managing the effluent they produce,” he said. “We think stocking larger fish, you get more bang for the buck and make a better fishery.”

Nemacolin fishing guide director Mike Steiner buys the resort’s browns and rainbows from Laurel Hill Trout Farm, Somerset County.

“The type of rainbows we get are bred to grow better in warmer water,” he said. “They continue feeding actively after other trout grow less active when the water reaches 65 degrees. It extends the season. If our fish do better, it might be worth [Fish and Boat’s] money to stock less fish in a bigger size.”

Advertise with us

In the working group meetings, said Lorson, TU and Nemacolin were asked to mark their fish by clipping fins in identifiable patterns. That has yet to happen, he said, and stronger language about clipping is likely to be included in the new management plan.

“I’d like to see it require catch-and-release from Ramcat to Ohiopyle,” said McCauley. “If we want to breed a true trophy trout fishery, I see no better way to do that.”

Kotowski said TU has a similar vision for the Middle Yough.

“Fish and Boat doesn’t believe harvest significantly lowers the number of fish in the river,” he said. “We disagree. I’d like to see no-kill in that area, or at least an increase in the length of fish being kept, but I don’t think it will happen.”

Lorson said Fish and Boat is considering an increase in the size of its fingerling trout, among other changes in the new management plan.

“If they would stock bigger fish, 5 to 7 inches,” said Steiner, “you’re increasing the survival rate. And instead of waiting 10 years for the next survey, if they could survey in two years, we’d have a better pulse on what’s happening.”