One look at the crowds casting under the bridge, near the car and off the picnic table nearest the lake, and you might think those are the best places to fish for trout.

But personal convenience rarely has anything to do with determining where to fish. Trout are most comfortable where there’s a good supply of oxygen and food, where cover protects them from predators and — for different reasons at different times of the year — where the water temperature is just right.

With the April 18 opening of the statewide trout season just two weeks out, it’s time to plan where you’ll be when fishing starts at 8 a.m. Water temperature should be part of that decision.

Trout are cold-water fish, most comfortable at around 50 degrees, the temperature at which spring water comes out of the ground. The hatchery pond doesn’t change that. Optimal temperatures are 50 to 63 degrees — brook trout prefer it on the cooler side; rainbows like it a little warmer. Water temperature affects their metabolism, and cooler water holding more dissolved oxygen makes it easier for trout to breathe.

Advertise with us

There’s room in every vest and tackle box for a fishing thermometer. Whether you’re fishing for trout in a lake or a stream, water temperature can impact the success of your fishing trip.

“In lakes this time of year, the temperature could be in the 40s — cooler if there’s still ice,” said state Fish and Boat Commission education specialist Denny Tubbs. “You want to be fishing where a stream is coming in. It gets a little warmer there and trout like that.”

Until recent weeks, trout were still being pulled through the ice.

“But in most ice fishing, [anglers] find where the fish are eating and sit right on top of them,” said Tubbs. “The fish are sluggish at colder temperatures, less active.”

Rainbow trout are more mobile, cruising around the lake in large groups. Browns are homebodies, staying within an established range.

Advertise with us

“When the lake is still cold, you’re looking for the warmest areas you can find,” said Tubbs. “Shallow areas that get some sun warm up quicker, and rocky bottoms hold more heat than mud. It could be that the north side of the lake gets more sun. Underwater springs could create a warm spot.”

On cloudy days at the lake, fish deeper, said Tubbs, at 7 to 10 feet. On sunny days when the top water is warmer, fish at 3 to 6 feet.

“There are lots of factors that could change that — food, oxygen, shade, angler pressure,” said Tubbs. “Be willing to adapt to conditions.”

Moving water impacts temperatures in different ways. In Pennsylvania’s limestone streams — fed primarily by aquifers pouring out of springs at a constant 50 to 55 degrees — temperatures remain mostly steady year-round. When creeks and rivers in eastern and western counties are iced over, central-state limestone waters are a balmy 50 degrees and fishable for trout year-round in Delayed Harvest sections and areas that are not stocked, not designated Approved Trout Waters.

“That doesn’t change in the spring,” said Bob Phillips of International Angler in Robinson, “but snow melt and shade cools the water, and in places with a steeper gradient and faster flow, the water stays cooler.”

Advertise with us

At freestone streams — fed mostly by run-off — water temperatures can change dramatically with the weather. In early spring tributaries can run warmer than the main branch, attracting trout to the confluence and waters just downstream.

If the arrival of the stocking truck was recent, trout may still be gathered near the spots where the buckets were dumped. But after a few days, they will have acclimated to their new environment and spread out. Those elbow-to-elbow crowds surrounding the pools may be fighting for the wrong spot.

“On freestone streams you want to fish where the water is moving and there’s no flowing ice,” said Phillips. “Big pools with not enough gradient will have more tendency to freeze or be cooler at a time when trout are looking for warmer water.”

Find tributaries and seeps with vegetation — a sign of warmer temperatures. Use the thermometer at a variety of stream sections. Once you’ve identified slightly warmer water, find the spot that is most oxygenated, most covered or with a good seam — a quicker current carrying food adjacent to a slower current where a trout can hold still without expending much energy. That’s where you’re likely find the most dominant trout.

Water temperature rules of thumb are generally reversed in the summer when lake and stream temperatures can rise to levels that are stressful to trout. Then, incoming water sources and deep, shady spots are generally cooler, carry more oxygen and are more attractive to trout.