Mt. Lebanon has been granted a permit to start conducting its deer management program.
The municipality received the green light Tuesday from the Pennsylvania Game Commission to trap and shoot deer through March 31 with services to be provided under contract with Wildlife Specialists LLC of Wellsboro in Tioga County. The cost is $500 per deer with a target of 150 and a ceiling of $75,000.
The contractor is in the process of setting up traps and baiting them, according to Susan Morgans, municipal spokeswoman. Letters were sent Tuesday to residents who live near the areas where the animals will be corraled — the municipal golf course, the conservation district off Connor Road, McNeilly Park, Bird Park, Robb Hollow Park and Twin Hills Park.
The school district and neighboring municipalities also were sent letters, and no-trespassing signs will be posted at the 8-by-8-foot corrals serving as traps.
In addition to trapping and euthanizing, municipal officials twice attempted to organize archery hunts as another method of reducing the deer population. No additional permits were available from the game commission during archery season, and the commission did not extend the season for Mt. Lebanon.
The municipality also is pursuing a third method, surgical sterilization. If approved, such an effort would represent the first of its kind in Pennsylvania.
The stated goal of Mt. Lebanon commissioners is to reduce the number of collisions between vehicles and deer by 50 percent in the next three to five years. Commissioners have agreed on a multi-pronged approach to lethal and nonlethal methods of deer population control.
“That’s the way you’re supposed to do it,” said Anthony DeNicola, president of White Buffalo Inc., a Connecticut-based nonprofit wildlife control company Mr. DeNicola founded in 1995.
The most effective approach, he said, would involve using sharpshooters, a method that commissioners have declined to pursue. As an alternative, a majority agreed to trapping and shooting the deer.
“You’ll see that capture and euthanize is very limited on returns,” said Mr. DeNicola, who in the summer of 2013 compiled a list of deer population control options for Mt. Lebanon. In that document, he stated that the “technique would be significantly less humane than sharpshooting. Deer are greatly stressed during the capturing process.”
Merlin Benner, Wildlife Specialists president and a certified wildlife biologist, also has acknowledged that sharpshooting would be a more effective and humane approach. But he also takes into consideration the divisiveness of the deer issue within the community and even among commissioners.
“They reached a compromise, agreed on not by all, but enough to get some action,” Mr. Benner said. “There are a lot of places that end up doing nothing because of various opinions and high controversy.”
Commissioner Kelly Fraasch consistently has opposed using lethal measures to reduce the population. Her point of view drew support at last week’s meeting of commissioners, when a group gathered to present a petition to the municipality opposing the killing of deer.
Some Mt. Lebanon residents take the opposite point of view, presenting their own petition calling for the municipality to use the most effective means to decrease numbers.
Whether deer actually are overabundant also is a matter of debate. But Laura Simon, wildlife ecologist for the Humane Society of the United States in Washington, D.C., pointed to factors that serve to attract the animals.
“This is a giant deer buffet,” said Ms. Simon, who participated in a June panel discussion about the animal’s perceived overabundance. “I was looking at flowers everywhere. It’s clear: Mt. Lebanon is a magnet for deer because of all the food.”
Her organization supports efforts to render deer infertile.
“Surgical sterilization can work,” said Ms. Simon. “You will see a reduction in population over time. It may be expensive” — cost estimates run as high as $1,000 per doe — “but it’s a really good investment if your goal is to reduce the deer population.”
Mr. DeNicola, who has conducted well-publicized sterilization programs in communities including Cayuga Heights, N.Y., and Fairfax, Va., agreed that the process takes time.
“You’ve got to be patient,” he said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.