A trap-and-euthanize deer management program has been approved in Mt. Lebanon.
Commissioners Monday voted to hire Wildlife Specialists LLC of Wellsboro, Tioga County, to conduct the services at a cost of $500 per deer taken, with a total amount not to exceed $75,000.
The program, which is targeted to start Feb. 1 and end March 31, is contingent on Pennsylvania Game Commission approval. It will take place in Mt. Lebanon public parks, with specific sites yet to be determined.
The vote was 3-1, with Commissioner Kelly Fraasch opposing. John Bendel, commission president, was not at the meeting.
Merlin Benner, Wildlife Specialists president, agreed to a payment-per-deer contract while talking with commissioners during their pre-meeting discussion Monday. Originally on the table was a flat $75,000.
“We haven’t had to have a contract like that before,” one that would “guarantee performance,” he told commissioners. “Usually, we’re hired to give a service.”
The objective is to take 150 deer during the trap-and-euthanize effort.
“I feel very confident of meeting that goal,” Mr. Benner said.
He plans to work with the police department to determine optimal sites for setting the traps. Once that is established, information will be posted on the municipal website.
Commissioners have addressed deer management with the stated goal of reducing vehicle collisions involving the animals by 50 percent over the next three to five years.
Trapping and euthanizing deer is one of three population-reduction measures the municipality is attempting to implement. An archery hunt planned for December and January did not take place because of issues with a limited number of antlerless deer permits available through the Game Commission.
The third approach is surgical sterilization, which has yet to receive Game Commission approval anywhere in Pennsylvania.
Ms. Fraasch, who opposes lethal methods, read a written statement about the deer issue prior to Monday’s vote.
“If we are serious about deer maintenance, we shouldn't be picking and choosing a lethal method only because it will be a quick fix,” she said. “Even if we kill 100 deer, we will still have deer, and residents will continue to complain.”
She suggested that a sterilization program would be more effective than ongoing lethal methods for population reduction in the long run, while eventually saving money for the municipality.
“We are looking at a huge difference financially,” Ms. Fraasch said.
Commissioner Dave Brumfield questioned the financial aspect while reiterating that sterilization has not been approved. He did agree that using a variety of deer-control methods would be optimal.
“Culling is not, by itself, an answer,” he said.
Commissioner Kristen Linfante, whose stated position is that she favors sharpshooting as the most effective method, agreed that other options could be pursued.
“We embraced sterilization. We submitted a request for a permit. What more would you have wanted us to do?” she asked Ms. Fraasch.
“It was not accepted, and I’m sure that part of the reason was the same reason Tony DeNicola told us,” she said, referring to the founder of White Buffalo Inc., a nonprofit organization that offers fertility control among its deer management services.
“The numbers suggest that there are too many now,” said Ms. Linfante. “If we were reaching some sort of threshold but weren’t there yet, sterilization alone may have been an option. But we’re well beyond that.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.