Most birders keep a life list of all the species of birds they've seen. Thanks to backyard birds and common species near waterways, parks, fields and forests, the first hundred species comes quickly. But soon the challenges of birding become apparent.
Among the most difficult birds to see are rails -- secretive marsh birds. When spooked, they usually run through dense vegetation rather than fly. So it's always a thrill to see a rail. This explains the excitement earlier this summer in Ohio when birders found a spot sheltering a black rail. It's a tiny dark bird, weighing about 1.1 ounces, about the size of a fox sparrow. For weeks, thanks to tips on the Internet, birders flocked to see this bird.
The interest in this rare bird got me thinking about the status of rails. They are classified as webless migratory game birds by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which establishes a framework that state wildlife agencies use to set waterfowl hunting seasons and bag limits.
When it comes to rails, black and yellow rails (1.8 ounces) are too small to hunt, but six other species of rails are fair game in many states. Coots and moorhens -- larger, duck-like members of the rail family -- often are found near open water and are easier to see and hunt. But sora, Virginia, clapper, and king rails exhibit more typical rail behavior: secretive and difficult to see.
So I asked myself, to whom are these species more valuable, birders or hunters?
More than 50 million American birders would thrill to even the briefest glimpse of any of the more secretive rails. This summer's experience with the black rail in Ohio demonstrated that. Rapid communication via the Internet allows birders to communicate almost instantly when rare or unusual birds are found, and when that happens many race for a chance to see a new species.
I had no idea how valuable rails might be to hunters, so I did some checking. According to USFWS data, 8,000 rail hunters killed 24,500 rails last year. Fifty-four percent were soras; 41 percent were clappers. Virginia and king rails made up the remaining 5 percent of the 2007 harvest. Those numbers pale in comparison to the 2007 harvest of 14.4 million ducks. Clearly, rails are not an important game species.
Furthermore, the annual rail harvest is declining. In 2003, hunters killed 29,100 rails. The species composition of the harvest was similar: 94.5 percent were sora and clapper rails.
On average, hunters devoted fewer than three days per year to pursuing rails, and the majority of the harvest was soras, which weigh in at about 2.6 ounces. That makes a 4.2-ounce mourning dove or a 6-ounce bobwhite seem like a banquet.
My point is that it's time to protect all rail species. Hunting them provides minimal recreation for hunters and little food for the table. Shooting rails is essentially target practice. Why not manage rails for the millions who want to see them rather than the 8,000 who want to kill them?
Though the USFWS sets seasons and limits, individual states can tweak those parameters. In Pennsylvania, Ohio, New York, and Michigan, for example, only sora and Virginia rails are classified as games species, and daily bag limits range from three (Pennsylvania) to 25 (Ohio) birds.
The majority of the limited rail hunting that occurs takes place in coastal states from New Jersey south to Texas. Harvests from inland states are minimal. USFWS data from 2007 report 1,200 rails taken in Pennsylvania, 200 in Ohio, 200 in New York, 200 in West Virginia and 100 in Michigan.
This is not an indictment of hunting; it's a call for common sense. I defend hunting when it can be justified ecologically, socially and economically. I simply believe that rails have become more valuable to birders than to hunters.
Changes in wildlife management reflect a growing understanding of humans' role in the environment. Otherwise, we'd still be killing and eating robins (2.7 ounces), killdeer (3.3 ounces), and larger shorebirds such as willets (8 ounces), godwits (12 ounces), and whimbrels (14 ounces).
Let the debate begin.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.