Got a question about hunting, fishing or the outdoors? Send it with your name and place of residence to outdoors@post-gazette.com.
Q: Is there any talk of a horsepower increase on Lake Arthur and other state-owned lakes? They made the restriction 20 hp, yet no outboard motor company produces a 20 hp motor, only 25 hp. Seems like something was not thought out properly.
Matt Sentner, Bellevue
Q: I purchased a 16-foot Bass Tracker with a 25 hp Mercury engine. I was told that a 25 hp Mercury would be OK at Lake Arthur, even though the restriction was 20 hp. ... The dealer [said] the DCNR and others were aware that Mercury did not make a 20 hp and would overlook the 25 hp. I was told that a 20 hp decal would be provided for $60.
I know I was deceived by the salesperson, and yes I was naive to believe what I was told. I should have known better. But I just want to be able to fish Lake Arthur and Lake Wilhelm. Can anything be done? I know for a fact I'm not alone in this situation.
Dale S. Marhefka, Cranberry
HAYES: Horsepower restrictions are widely misunderstood and often violated.
The 20 hp limit isn't applied to "state owned" lakes. It's applied to six large lakes located within Pennsylvania state parks. Enforcement of the restriction is beyond the jurisdiction of the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission; it's the responsibility of the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources.
The DCNR, Army Corps of engineers, county and municipal parks and private owners are within their rights to apply and enforce horsepower restrictions. State park rangers often come down hard on boaters who violate the 20 hp restriction, particularly those who slap a lower horsepower sticker on an outboard motor.
"The bureau's primary interests concerning horsepower limits on state park administered lakes are to evaluate for the safety of boaters and park visitors, and protection of natural resources," said Jeff Woleslagle of DCNR's Bureau of State Parks. "It is not the desire of the bureau for horsepower regulations to negatively affect our visitors."
In 2002, the DCNR initiated a pilot program at six state park lakes liberalizing the maximum allowable horsepower from 9.9 to 18, and in 2003 the limit was permanently increased on those lakes to 20 hp.
"Twenty" became the magic number in Pennsylvania because of decisions still to be made in Ohio.
"Part of our consideration to allow up to 20 hp motors was due to the fact that Ohio would only consider raising the horsepower limit on Pymatuning Lake to less than 25 hp," said Woleslagle. "Since Ohio and Pennsylvania are required by the Pymatuning Compact to administer the lake jointly and with identical legislation, we felt it prudent to hold the horsepower limit to 20 hp at all our limited horsepower lakes."
Pennsylvania has passed the legislation to raise the horsepower restriction on Pymatuning Lake to 20 hp, and is waiting for similar action in Ohio.
"With the available personnel, it is more practical to regulate based on one horsepower limit [for all state park lakes]," said Woleslagle. "One reason for the original decision to increase to 18 and then 20 hp was to correct the problem that existed when the limit was 9.9 hp. Boaters could modify their 9.9 hp motors to operate illegally at 15 hp and still have a 9.9 hp cowling on the motor. It is the understanding of the department that 25 hp motors can be altered to operate at 40 hp without altering the outside appearance of the motor. Twenty horsepower motors cannot be altered in that fashion."
Woleslagle said higher horsepower limitations would cause increased shoreline erosion due to increased wave action, and the lower limits provide a safer environment for non-power boating activities such as swimming, kayaking and canoeing.
It's true, 20 hp outboards are sometimes more difficult to find, particularly in used motors. But Johnson, Evinrude, Honda and Mariner manufacture 20 hp outboards, and several companies, including Johnson, make a 15.
And, Dale, as for a boat dealer lying that the DCNR overlooks 25 hp motors, and then having the gall to charge $60 extra for an illegal sticker ...
"We've heard that goes on," said the Fish and Boat Commission's Dan Tredinnick. "It seems like the salesman saw this customer coming. It's terrible. But I don't think there's anything covering that in our regulations. To my knowledge, there's no law in the Fish and Boat Code about it."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.