A friend recently loaned me a book he had found at a flea market. "You might find this interesting," he said. He was right. The book is the 1901 report of the Fish Commissioners of the State of Pennsylvania, forerunner board to the present Fish and Boat Commission.
It provides a look at how fisheries issues have changed in the state and how they haven't since Teddy Roosevelt was President of the United States.
Funding was a concern in 1901, as it is in 2006. Discussing plans to establish a new hatchery for bass and perch, the commissioners reported to then Gov. William A. Stone: "Unfortunately our plans came to naught because from motives of economy as urged by your excellency in your inaugural message, the legislature felt compelled to reduce the biennial appropriation from $35,000 to $25,000. The two years have therefore been years of financial stringency and a difficult struggle to make the ends meet."
Twenty-one years later the legislature established the resident fishing license at a fee of one dollar. The license enabled the Fish Commission to remain independently funded for many years during a period of increasing fishing participation.
Trout stocking was apparently done differently in the early 1900s. The report lists hundreds of individuals who requested shipments (in an iced milk can) of brook trout fry. Most of these sportsmen were issued 1,500 fry but there is no record of where the fish were planted.
W. C. Peoples, for example, of Greensburg, was shipped 1,500 brook trout fry on April 17, 1900. One-year-old "European Brown Trout" were distributed in the same way in smaller lots. H. R. Hyde, Ridgway, Elk County, received 500 browns June 27, 1900, but there appears to have been no procedure for Mr. Hyde's handling of the fish after that.
At the beginning of the 20th century, American shad still ascended the Susquehanna River to spawn. "The shad catch in the Susquehanna was much larger than last year," the report stated. "The fish were taken some distance up the Juniata and to the dam at Sunbury. We have no doubt that if these two obstructions were removed, shad would be caught in large numbers many miles above."
Unfortunately, the opposite happened. The 1901 commissioners envisioned dam removal far upstream, but electric utilities soon placed four dams on the lower river, barely above tidewater. Instead of shad runs again reaching northern and central Pennsylvania, the fish could scarcely ascend above Chesapeake Bay.
In recent years a cooperative effort between the Fish and Boat Commission, electric utilities, Maryland Department of Natural Resources and the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service placed fish passage facilities at the four dams.
Despite initial optimism, results have been disappointing. In 2006, only 1,913 shad passed above the York Haven Dam just below Harrisburg.
The 1901 report provides a glimpse at how long it sometimes takes Pennsylvania to adapt policy to real conditions, despite evidence supporting the wisdom of change.
As the previous century began, fish commissioners were discussing regional differences in water temperatures in trout streams. This same concern, of course, finally resulted in two separate opening days for the trout season, approved in 2006.
"Neither class of reasoners [referring to a dispute regarding the timing of trout stocking] appeared to have taken into consideration the difference of temperature between the water of the mountain and meadow streams during May and the early part of June," wrote the 1901 commissioners. "The latter would be from 10 to 15 degrees warmer. In brief, the water in the mountain streams in May would on the average have about the same temperature as the ordinary meadow streams in April. This is why meadow trout stream fishing is usually termed early, that is that the best fishing is over by June 1."
One hundred and five years later, a Fish and Boat Commission press release announcing an earlier opening for the trout season in southeastern Pennsylvania said essentially the same thing, but in a less quaint and colloquial tone:
"Differences exist in climate across Pennsylvania and the time frame for providing optimum conditions for trout angling in the spring is earlier in portions of southern Pennsylvania. Warmer temperatures there provide conditions better suited for trout angling at an earlier time in the spring. However, these same warming conditions also can limit trout angling opportunities by mid-spring. The combination of a mid-April opening day and the potential for these waters to become too warm for trout angling by mid-May constricts the amount of time that trout angling can be provided."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.