Changes in muskie management made at last week's Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission meeting in Harrisburg are getting a thumbs-up from anglers who see the new 40-inch minimum size and one-a-day creel limit beginning next year as a big step toward growing trophy fisheries.
Not all muskie specialists are happy with the Fish Commission's decision to remove the closed season and allow year-round harvest of fish on all but a few waters where brood stock is maintained. Those Brood Stock Lakes, including Canadohta, Edinboro, Sugar, Conneaut, Union City, Woodcock and Tamarack, would be catch and release in April and May, only because an anesthetic used to sedate fish during the hatchery breeding process could remain in the muskies' tissue for three weeks after they are returned to the water.
"The FDA bans human consumption of the fish for 21 days after they are treated," said the Fish Commission chief warm water biologist Bob Lorantas. "That's our only reason for these special regulation waters."
But anglers such as Red Childress of Warren, Pa., who guides for muskies in northwestern Pennsylvania, have said waters that support natural reproduction, such as the Allegheny River from Foxburg to the Kinzua Dam, also should be subject to special regulations.
"I'm ecstatic about the new 40-inch minimum," he said. "But the commission should never put wild fish in the hands of anglers during the breeding season, which for northwestern Pennsylvania is usually later than the rest of the state. I saw three wild muskies paired up in a foot and a half of water on the Allegheny, June 5.
"If the commission is exempting certain waters from harvest in the spring, they should include ones where fish actually have a chance to reproduce."
Muskie guide Howard Wagner of Fombell, Pa., also opposes year-round harvest, but applauds the new size and creel restrictions. "I think they could double the population in five years," he said, "provided the stocking program stays the same."
Lorantas said changes to the stocking program are in the works, and for the better, since waters with low fishing pressure will be taken off the list and their muskies given to lakes with high angler interest. "We're out to provide the greatest return on our investment, starting with the stockings this fall," he said
Forage type and density will figure into which lakes are chosen, since muskies prefer gizzard shad, suckers and carp, Lorantas said. "Some anglers are concerned about muskie impact on bass and other species they like to fish for. We're not saying muskies won't eat an occasional bass, but they really prefer soft rayed fish."
Lorantas said his agency is also developing a list of waters that eventually could sustain a 45-inch release minimum. Wagner believes it should be 54 inches on waters such as Conneaut Lake and the Allegheny Reservoir.
"Special lakes have proven in the past they can produce state-record size fish," he said. "People from all over the country used to travel to Western Pennsylvania in the early 1980s and spend money trying to catch them. If nothing else, it's about economic development."
The Fish Commission is required to take public comment on the Brood Stock Lake special regulations, since they were not part of the original proposal. To comment, visit www.fish.state.pa.us.
In other board action:
The board also approved year-round harvesting of northern pike and pickerel, beginning next year. The creel limit and size on pike will remain unchanged, while pickerel will go from 15 to 18 inches and four a day instead of five. While pike abound in Western Pennsylvania, pickerel are less common, although grass pickerel are native to the Ohio River basin and anglers probably catch them without even realizing it. "They're sometimes mistaken for juvenile muskies or pike because they tend to be pretty small, no bigger than 12 inches. They're not very appealing, so there's not much interest in them, but they're actually pretty abundant in the Beaver River," Lorantas said.
The board approved stricter regulations for scores of reptiles and amphibians, most notably timber rattlesnakes, a candidate species. To ensure that only male rattlesnakes will be harvested, the minimum size was raised to one a day, at least 42 inches with 21 or more subcaudal scales (above the rattler). Anglers who want to harvest snapping turtles for commercial purposes will now need a $25 a year permit.
The commissioners voted to seek public comment on whether operators of watercraft less than 16 feet long and kayaks and canoes should be required to wear life jackets October through May or all year. Several drowning deaths involving small boats occurred this past winter, when mild weather drew boaters to the water. Eighteen boaters have died so far this year, which is close to a record number.
The board gave the commission a green light to expand efforts to develop programming and legislative support for a fishing license for 12 to 15 year olds.
Opening day of trout season in 18 southeastern Pennsylvania counties will now be held on the first Saturday following March 28. The board approved the regional change because streams in the southeast warm more quickly. Opening day for trout for the rest of the state will continue in mid-April.
The commission will establish a Habitat Management Division to focus on stream restoration, lake improvements and other conservation initiatives.
For all meeting actions, visit www.fish.state.pa.us
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.