The current impasse over a hunting license fee increase raises some fundamental questions about what hunting, fishing and that aspect of nature we traditionally think of as the "outdoors" means to society.

Historically, hunters, anglers and society at large have thought of hunting and fishing strictly as sports, diversions or recreation. In that context, we appropriately paid our way with license fees and no one else knew or cared much about the situation.

But sources inside the state legislature say there is no way lawmakers will pass the latest license increase the Pennsylvania Game Commission says it needs. That portends a real "gut-check" budget crisis for the agency, which administers hunting, trapping, endangered species recovery and a 1.4-million acre system of game lands for hunting and wildlife habitat.

Even if lawmakers relent and approve the fee increase, there's a downside. Supporters of the hike predict a 10 percent drop in hunting participation as a result, on top of the expected annual 5 percent loss to age and attrition (last year the loss was 6 percent). Tragically, that new 10 percent erosion will likely be among young fathers who, otherwise, would have exposed their children to hunting and fishing in the traditional way.

Advertise with us

With gasoline at $3 a gallon, you can envision lots of scenarios where the heads of young families will need to make tough choices.

Sobering as it is, the conceivable demise of regulated hunting and fishing poses the question: Are hunting and fishing, and particularly the "infrastructure" that supports them, beneficial only to the participants? Or, do these activities, the personal rewards they deliver, and the lakes, streams, rivers, forests and fields that harbor fish and wildlife have some greater value to the rest of society as well?

If society can be convinced that the latter response is correct, this crisis could spawn a solution to the chronic and worsening struggle to fund fish and wildlife conservation.

Consider the societal problem of water pollution. We tend to think of solutions to pollution as primarily regulatory, and ultimately technological. Our representatives pass laws, our agencies enforce standards, and science and industry provide technology to "correct" the problem, all at some significant cost to society. But I would suggest that the existence of 1.4 million, mostly forest acres of state game lands on mountaintops, ridge crests and headwater basins across the state contributes at least as much toward clean drinking water in the commonwealth's downstream communities as does the expensive technology employed at municipal water intake and distribution points, at no cost to the Pennsylvania taxpayer.

Furthermore, the fishing and boating access facilities provided by the Fish and Boat Commission help to make a substantial portion of the state's population aware of the importance of clean water before it exits the tap. If clean water has value to society, which it apparently does, and if we know that clean water is currently attained through political will, then that personal knowledge of clean water, earned by hundreds of thousands of citizens through direct participation in fishing and boating, has value to society.

Advertise with us

Likewise, the "deer war," as protracted and painful as it has been, has made hundreds of thousands of hunters aware of the importance of sustainable forests. Whether the next over-riding threat to future forests is overabundant deer, poor logging practices, acid precipitation, or a combination of all those factors, their knowledge, as well as the forests in which they gained it, have value to everyone.

What about sociological aspects? We're told that young people who are engaged in family activities with older role models are less likely to stray into criminal or anti-social behavior. Hunting and fishing engage in just that way. Numerous studies prove that the most indelible introduction to hunting and fishing is through inter-generational contact with family and friends.

So, it follows that hunting and fishing, and the infrastructure that supports them, have value to everyone who enjoys an orderly society.

Perhaps it is time to look beyond the wallets of hunters and anglers to support the diverse and important rewards enjoyed by all.