Though serious, Pennsylvania's current dilemma of inadequate funding for fish and wildlife conservation is not unique. Many states have struggled to fund their conservation agencies in a time of rising costs and stagnant or shrinking revenue from hunting and fishing licenses.

Some states, notably Missouri, Arkansas and Virginia have implemented "alternative funding" to broaden the revenue base for conservation programs beyond traditional license sales. These states have adopted a plan that dedicates a small portion of the state sales tax to fish and wildlife work.

Some observers have called attention to the need for alternative funding in Pennsylvania but no formal proposals have surfaced.

"A system like Pennsylvania's that funds wildlife management predominantly with hunting license fees is doomed to produce the results we are experiencing. Demographic trends indicate that the hunting population is declining and, therefore, so is the funding base for wildlife management," wrote Gregg Robertson in a recent commentary in the Harrisburg Patriot News. Robertson is president of the Pennsylvania Landscape and Nursery Association.

Advertise with us

"Without any annual stream of revenue from the state's taxpayers to support our operating budget, the inflationary affect on the revenues generated by the current license fee structure has impacted our ability to maintain the status quo, let alone move forward," Game Commission executive director Carl Roe told the House Game and Fisheries Committee last month.

Unfamiliarity with alternative funding options and a reluctance to alienate voters has likely hindered Pennsylvania's progress toward a more stable source of fish and wildlife dollars.

Besides those states that have already enacted alternative funding, others have been examining public opinion to determine support for the concept.

A survey conducted for the Vermont Department of Fish and Wildlife by Responsive Management, a research firm specializing in social attitudes toward natural resource issues, found strong support for a variety of alternative funding strategies.

The survey was conducted in 2000, and because it followed a similar survey in 1995, also gauged changes in opinion over a five-year span.

Advertise with us

Survey respondents were contacted by telephone and asked a series of questions regarding the importance they placed on fish, wildlife and habitats, and their support of various funding options. Support for fish and wildlife conservation and wildlife associated recreation was extremely strong.

Eighty percent of respondents agreed that protecting Vermont's fish and wildlife resources was "very important" and 17 percent rated the same concern "somewhat important." Only one percent of Vermonters said fish and wildlife were "not important."

Ninety-seven percent of respondents also said it was "very important" or "somewhat important" for people to have the opportunity to participate in wildlife-related recreation, such as hunting, fishing and wildlife viewing, even though only 28 percent of respondents said they had ever hunted.

Ninety percent favored dedicating a fixed percentage of the state Rooms and Meals tax to conservation programs.

Other funding methods receiving high support (respondents were allowed to choose any and all options they supported) were: a general fund appropriation for programs and activities--such as managing non-game wildlife--in which the department participates but does not receive funding (87 percent); redistributing a portion of the current state sales tax so that the department would receive one-eighth of one percent (81 percent); reserving a small percentage of the current state sales tax on outdoor related items such as camping gear (73 percent); and charging land developers a fee for habitat evaluations (71 percent).

Advertise with us

Increasing the state sales tax to cover wildlife costs or raising hunting and fishing license fees were opposed by the largest percentage of residents. However, each of those options was still supported by a majority.

Surveyors found that support for fish and wildlife conservation had grown substantially in Vermont since 1995. "Protecting and enhancing fish and wildlife habitat" showed the largest increase in support of all priorities (52 percent increase).

Other priorities whose popularity grew during the five-year interval were: managing and protecting endangered and threatened species (43 percent increase); managing fisheries to provide recreational fishing opportunities (34 percent increase); and educating and informing residents about fish and wildlife (24 percent increase).

A similar survey in Wyoming identified a conservation trust fund from natural resource extractive industries as the most favorable alternative funding approach (62 percent of respondents).

With documented support for alternative funding in widely different parts of the country, the way seems clear for Pennsylvania to, at least, begin examining alternatives.