Andy Starnes, Post-Gazette

ROCK ON: Alex Wilkinson, 9, of Upper St. Clair, fishes in the Ohio River near the Kilbuck access area while standing on a rock May 30. The fishing trip was a reward from his father who said Alex had done well in a school play as the Tin Man in the Wizard of Oz earlier in the day.

By Ben Moyer

Pennsylvania's traditional fish and wildlife conservation funding has hit hard times. Since shortly after the inception of the Game and Fish and Boat commissions late in the 19th century, the sale of hunting and fishing licenses by those agencies has financed efforts on behalf of wildlife and its habitats.

Advertise with us

But selling licenses has reached a point of diminishing returns. The cost of maintaining public fishing areas, public lands, law enforcement, wildlife damage control, wildlife disease monitoring and conservation education programs continues to rise. Meanwhile, there are fewer hunters and anglers picking up the tab in the traditional way.

Sales of resident adult hunting licenses dropped by 4 percent between 2000 and 2004, from 739,000 to 708,000. The annual sales decline reached 6 percent in the 2005-2006 license year. Fishing license sales have shown similar trends over time.

Game Commission revenues from adult resident license sales declined proportionally, from $14,795,000 in 2000 to $14,178,000 in 2004.

Erosion of the ranks will accelerate in the years ahead as today's hunters and anglers age. Game Commission executive director Carl G. Roe recently acknowledged the impending drop. "When the baby boomers start crossing over, in 2015 I think it is, we'll start to see some impact," Roe said.

The decline is not due to any avoidable failing on the part of the two commissions. Our population is growing older and more urban. Neither of those trends bodes well for hunting and fishing participation. In the future, there will simply be fewer people with the background, physical capability and opportunities that promote and enable traditional outdoor pursuits.

Advertise with us

Currently, the only recourse is to raise the cost of license fees. A bill recently introduced in the legislature would increase the cost of a resident adult hunting license from $20 to either $29 or $34, plus establish specialty fees for hunting pheasants and wild turkeys. The increase would likely bring in about $20 million in new revenue for the Game Commission, but hunter numbers are expected to drop another 10 percent in response.

If sales do drop because of higher fees, future hikes may need to be steeper and more frequent.

Besides bearing the entire burden for conservation, and despite declining participation, hunting and fishing make a whopping contribution to the state's general coffers.

According to the 2001 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Survey of Fishing, Hunting and Wildlife Associated Recreation, sales tax gleaned by Pennsylvania's general treasury from fishing and hunting expenditures equals about $92 million annually. Not one cent of that sales tax revenue is diverted back into fish and wildlife programs.

A growing number of Pennsylvanians concerned about wildlife, fish and the woods and waters in which they live, have begun to advocate supplementing revenue from license sales with some other alternative source. A quality environment that supports fish and wildlife, they argue, is beneficial to the health and well being of all Pennsylvanians.

Advertise with us

Other states are recognizing that fish, wildlife, public lands and outdoor recreation are important enough to ask everyone to contribute. Below is a summary of alternative wildlife funding in some other states.

Missouri: It enacted a provision in 1976 that dedicates .008 percent (one-eighth of one percent) of state sales tax revenues to conservation. That provision now nets Missouri about $90 million annually, roughly equal to the total combined budgets of our separate Game and Fish and Boat commissions. The Missouri Dept. of Conservation uses the money for public hunting and fishing access, nature education centers, restoration of endangered species, trails, publications, a television show that covers hunting, fishing and non-consumptive pursuits, and permanent staff that work directly with private landowners to improve conditions for wildlife. "It may be the best investment we, as a state, ever made," said recently retired Wildlife Division Administrator Ollie Torgenson.

Arkansas: It dedicates .008 percent of its sales tax to a variety of earmarked programs, with 45 percent of that revenue tagged to conservation. The combined Arkansas Game and Fish Commission operates eight nature education centers, administers an annual elk hunt and manages some of the country's most innovative trout fisheries programs.

Virginia: It returns 2 percent of the general state sales tax generated by hunting, fishing and wildlife watching to conservation programs. That nets the Virginia Department of Game and Inland Fisheries $13 million annually, in addition to its revenue from hunting and fishing licenses.

Minnesota: The Minnesota Senate recently passed a bill that would authorize a small increase in the state sales tax, yet accrue $94 million each year for fish and wildlife. The Minnesota House of Representatives is considering the legislation prior to voting. John Schroers, president of the Minnesota Outdoor Heritage Alliance called the Senate bill, "historic."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.