Thousands of Western Pennsylvania residents hike, camp, hunt, fish, paddle, and enjoy the Allegheny National Forest every year. Tomorrow evening, Western Pennsylvania residents will have an opportunity to evaluate alternative plans for the Allegheny National Forest's management and offer their own opinions on its future.

Beginning at 4 p.m., the U. S. Forest Service will hold a Forest Plan Revision public information meeting at the Four Points Sheraton, 910 Sheraton Drive in Warrendale. Forest Service officials will make four one-hour presentations throughout the evening so that attendees arriving at different times can receive the same information. The meeting is scheduled to conclude at 8 p.m.

After lengthy study the Forest Service has prepared four alternatives to the plans. The alternative plan that is ultimately selected will guide Allegheny National Forest management for the next 15 years.

Sprawling across the Allegheny high plateau at the four-cornered conjunction of Elk, Forest, McKean and Warren counties, the half-million-acre Allegheny Forest is Pennsylvania's only national forest. It is a land of world-class hardwoods, rushing streams, deep woods wildlife, uncommon scenic beauty, and the centerpiece of a rural economy boosted by outdoor recreation, nature tourism, forest products and energy extraction.

Advertise with us

The alternatives, labeled A, B, C, and D attempt to balance diverse and sometimes competing interests to various degrees. The Forest Service prefers alternative C, which would increase maximum allowable timber sales from 53.2 to 56.3 million board feet, and would identify two tracts -- Chestnut Ridge and Tracy Ridge -- totaling 14,000 acres for possible inclusion in the National Wilderness Preservation System.

In recent years, actual timber sales have averaged about 21 million board feet, far below the current allowable ceiling. Wilderness designation prohibits motorized travel and logging but permits hunting, fishing, hiking and other low impact forms of recreation.

"We all have worked hard to balance the public's desires with the best resource management science available," said Allegheny National Forest supervisor Kathleen Morse.

But a group that conducted its own multi-year study of the Allegheny Forest contends that it holds additional tracts deserving of wilderness designation.

In 2003 the Friends of Allegheny Wilderness published "A Citizens' Wilderness Proposal for Pennsylvania's Allegheny National Forest," which recommends wilderness protection for 54,460 acres in eight different parcels.

Advertise with us

"Wilderness protection is a critical component of the Multiple Use management of our national forests," said Friends of Allegheny Wilderness executive director Kirk Johnson. "While we fully recognize the importance of continued timber production and other uses of the ANF to the region's economy and way of life, it must also be acknowledged that there is an acute shortage of protected wilderness here. Even alternative D of the plan, which offers four wilderness areas, does not go nearly far enough in rectifying that situation."

The Friends of Allegheny Wilderness proposal includes the Chestnut Ridge and Tracy Ridge tracts, plus additional areas known as: Allegheny Front, Clarion River, Cornplanter, Hickory Creek (addition to current Hickory Creek Wilderness), Morrison Run and Tionesta.

Two sites, Hickory Creek and Allegheny River Islands, are currently designated wilderness, amounting to two percent of the total Allegheny National Forest acreage. Johnson noted recently that even if all of FAW's proposed areas were to win wilderness status, wilderness would occupy only 12 percent of the forest. Nationwide, 18 percent of national forest land is protected by official wilderness designation.

Even the two areas proposed as wilderness by the Forest Service are too much for some municipal officials in northwestern Pennsylvania. Municipalities and school districts in the region receive a portion of timber revenues generated on the Allegheny National Forest. Mead Township Supervisor Terry Hawk said at a meeting in Warren that wilderness designation "takes too much land out of production."

But Johnson said his group's proposal is not incompatible with the region's resource-based economy. "When we developed our proposal we went through a series of selection criteria in order to avoid conflict with other uses of the forest, including timber production, motorized trails and oil and gas production," Johnson said. "Our intent was to include areas that could be part of the National Wilderness Preservation System without interfering with timber production. You could designate all eight areas in our proposal and still achieve the proposed 56 million board foot cut."

Advertise with us

The Forest Service will accept public comment on the plan alternatives through mid-August.

Further information about the Allegheny National Forest Plan revision is available at www.fs.fed.us/r9/forests/allegheny/projects/forest_plan_revision.

The current Allegheny National Forest management plan has been in place since 1986.

Comments should be sent to: Allegheny National Forest, Forest Plan Revision, Box 36, Warren, Pa., 16365.

Ed Bernik

Advertise with us

This photo from "Pennsylvania Wilds: Images from the Allegheny National Forest" depicts Bent Run, one of the more scenic spots in the forest.

Click photo for larger image.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.