Anglers can expect quality walleye but fewer numbers at Pymatuning Reservoir again this year, according to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, which is experimenting with ways to bolster future year classes.

The agency's spring trap-net surveys revealed that the fry survival problem that began about four years ago hasn't eased, according to northwest fisheries technician Freeman Johns.

"We captured nice fat, healthy walleyes but numbers were certainly down by half from their peak in 2002-2004, and there were very few sub-legals, which has us very concerned," he said.

Anglers accustomed to high catch rates on the 13,500 acre reservoir will have to work harder to find fish, said Keith Eshbaugh of New Alexander and a Masters Walleye Tour competitor.

Advertise with us

"There used to be so many millions of walleye in there, it wasn't a problem. These days, you have to expand your search," he said. This time of year a good place to start is shallow water during key feeding times -- at dusk and again late at night.

Pymatuning regular Bob MacBeth of Meadville has caught his largest walleye wading two feet from shore.

"They turn on from about 11 at night to one in the morning," he said. "I don't think I've caught one walleye this year that was under 19 inches. The other night, I watched a guy throw back two 25s and a 27 (incher) because he didn't want to keep the breeders. A few years ago, when I was fishing the edge of the islands out of a boat with a Wally Diver, for every two keepers, 50 would be sub-legal. We'd say the heck with it and go to Erie.

"This year, I'm just fishing a No. 9 Rapala, running it on the slow side, enough that it's twitching and working, and I'm catching everything on it. When the bait fish are active and hitting the surface, the walleye are hitting good, too."

Johns said trollers working the weedbeds are also getting good results, given the bounty of baitfish near shore.

Advertise with us

This year's survey showed more shad than alewife, he said. Though the alewife explosion in recent years has been blamed for the walleye decline, Johns said it began after walleye started slipping, and other culprits may include competition from crappie and the impact of prolonged cold spring conditions on the plankton that fry need to survive. He said last summer's die-off of the lake's larger walleye was unrelated, and a consequence of unusually hot temperatures, given the reservoir is just 35 feet in its deepest spots.

"Keep in mind, too, that nature is dynamic," Johns said. "All waters run in cycles."

Johns said hatchery crews are trying to reverse the trend by stocking walleye at night in many different locations. He said a batch of older fry would be planted later this month after they are bathed in a chemical that will mark their bone tissue so scientists can gauge their survival this fall.

"It's actually an antibiotic, OTC, or oxytetracycline, the same chemical used in shad studies," Johns said. "We'll have to sacrifice a few walleye in our young of the year surveys this September, but maybe it will give us a clue as to whether we should be planting larger fish and planting them later."

In the meantime, he said, anglers should consider the quality of adult walleyes netted this spring. "In 34 trap nets, we caught 917 males and 111 females, a ratio that is pretty normal," Johns said. "There were no sub-legal females and only 11 sub-legal males. The females averaged 22 inches and the males, 18."

Advertise with us

And, he said, despite lower numbers, the lake's walleye population is still double what it was in 1989. "You'd be hard-pressed to go to any other inland lake and find this kind of fishery," Johns said.

While the commission considers Pymatuning as Western Pennsylvania's premier walleye fishery, other good walleye waters include the Youghiogheny and Allegheny reservoirs, which permit unlimited horsepower. Pymatuning is restricted to 9.9 hp. Smaller walleye lakes include Arthur, Wilhelm, Somerset, Highpoint, Greenlick and Dunlap.

Youghiogheny Reservoir

According to Gary Smith, the Fish Commission's southwestern regional fisheries technician, the Youghiogheny Reservoir has some of the best walleye numbers -- and natural reproduction -- in the state.

"It has the kind of substrate walleyes can spawn over, in the right locations," Smith said. "It also has nice deep cold habitat to hold walleye through summer."

Advertise with us

At more than 100 feet deep in places, the Yough Reservoir is three times deeper than Pymatuning, but not as fertile. It also lacks structure. Local groups such as the Yough Walleye Association have added limestone sand to tributaries feeding the dam to increase alkalinity and productivity, and they have placed cribs and Christmas trees on the bottom of the lake to attract fish. Alewife is the main forage, followed by small yellow perch.

Walleye stockings have supplemented natural reproduction for 10 years.

"We're now reaping the benefits in terms of good catch rates, varied year classes and good sizes," said Steve Popson, who heads the Yough Walleye Association. "Numbers lately have been the best ever. I'm also shocked at the great smallmouth bass I'm seeing."

"The bass were impressive in our last survey," Smith said. "They were 17, 18 inches and looked like footballs."

Because it is structurally challenged and big -- at 2,840 acres and 16 miles long -- the Yough can be tough to fish, Eshbaugh said.

Advertise with us

"It's not one of these lakes where you can come in and dunk a worm and catch a walleye. If you've never been there before, you'll have to start trolling to mark fish, and, if that doesn't work, drift some crawlers until you find where they are," he said.

Popson suggests finding willow trees, pitching at brush and working the banks slowly to get a feel for where water is most productive.

"This time of year, I'd jig a quarter or eighth-ounce jig and crawler real slowly," he said. "Most of the Yough fishermen will fish split bobbers and jigs. Around June, they'll pull worm harnesses or crankbaits."

"The Yough is steep-sided and has a lot of slopes, drop-offs and points, so mix up your depth levels," he said. For more, visit www.youghwalleye.com