V.W.H. Campbell, Post-Gazette
Ryan Matthews, 8, of Penn Hills had a very good first day of trout season as witnessed by the string of fish he is carrying. Ryan, his father Michael and brother Corey, 5, threw their lines into Turtle Creek.
Click photo for larger image.
Early season angling plans don't have to include crowds, although stockings over the next few weeks will increase fishing pressure.
"You can go to a stocked stream and walk in a little further and find good fishing," Chuck Thompson of International Angler in Aspinwall said. "You'd be surprised at how good it can be if you get away from the bridges. Fish will move, especially if we get higher water."
Project waters are a good alternative for folks seeking the catch and release experience. Some, such as Dunbar, Slippery Rock, Clear Shade and Little Sandy creeks, are limited to fly fishing only. Others, including Deer and Pine creeks and Meadow Run, allow both artificials and flies.
"I was up on Pine Creek by Duncan Avenue with my dog about a week ago and saw dozens of fish rise in the open water, above the delayed harvest section," Thompson said. "They were lying in holes and rising and feeding. Low, warmer water has made the midge fishing good already."
A Griffiths Gnat for midging on top or a midge pupae imitation for just below the surface would have been ideal, he said.
"There were some Caddis and midge flies in the air -- size 18s and 20s -- in the Glenshaw section of Pine, too, and fish were rising steadily. If rain comes and water rises, you'd just go back to basics."
Sucker spawn and Green Weenies are early season classics, according to Don Boyan of Orchard View Angling in McMurray.
"Some people don't like it, but the junk stuff works best on just-stocked trout that grew up in raceways and don't know what a Hare's Ear Nymph is," he said. "A month after they've been in the water and wise up, yeah, the Hare's Ear will start to catch fish."
Location and conditions dictate choice of flies. "You'll catch more stuff on weenies on Neshannock than if you're fishing Spring Creek, where it's all wild trout," Boyan said. "Even on Spring Creek, you'll get a lot of bugs, but not a lot of variety. You could go there and catch fish with just three flies -- Sowbugs, Muskrat Nymphs and Pheasant Tails in 18s and 20s. You've got to stay small. If you're fishing the Little Juniata, a little bigger stuff works."
Fly fishing author Charles Meck recommends carrying Quill Gordons and Blue Quills to some of the more productive waters, such as Yellow Creek and Bobs Creek in Bedford County.
"These and other streams in the area hold heavy hatches the first two weeks of the season," he said. "A Zebra Midge tied on a size 16 scud hook is dynamite early in the season. It's nothing more than a body of black tying thread ribbed about six times with very fine silver wire. I fished Bald Eagle Creek several years ago on opening day and caught all kinds of fish on it."
Another top fly, said Meck, is Ben's Orange Caddis tied on a size 14 scud hook. It is a bright orange body ribbed with fine gold wire and a turn or two in front of dun hackle.
If streams run high and cloudy, he recommends baitfish imitations, such as wooly buggers, Muddler Minnows, Mickey Finns and other streamers.
Overall, said Thompson, fly anglers may even have an advantage on waters already pressured by bait and artificials.
"Stocked trout haven't seen many flies yet," he said, "so that might be just what they take."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.