Area trout streams are likely to be low and clear on opening day, April 15, reflecting a trend in recent decades toward spring seasons that are dry. That, according to experts tracking climatic change and its impact on the environment.

"We'll be heading into trout season with a deficit of water," predicted Penn State University water resources specialist Bryan Swistock. "A good storm might raise levels temporary, but groundwater is so low, it would take more than one good storm to right things."

Last month was one of the driest Marches in a decade, with precipitation down by half in Western Pennsylvania, Swistock said. The university's climate model for April forecasts more of the same. It is part of a pattern that Swistock said puzzles even experts.

"Since 1895, Pennsylvania has actually been getting more precipitation annually," he said, "but, in recent decades, spring has not followed this pattern and has definitely been drier in most, but not all, years. Why is not well understood."

Advertise with us

Warm weather is also coming earlier, according to Richard Alley, Edwin Pugh Professor of Geosciences at Penn State, who said there are several culprits, not the least of which is global warming.

"There's been a shift in the East toward earlier peak flows," Alley said. "It's a little like moving toward summer, sooner, where you have these big thunderstorms but they dry out faster because it's warm, so you have to water your tomato patch frequently anyway."

"Global warming increases total rainfall, but warmer temperatures tend to make more droughts. You also have loss of snow pack, which is a concern, because snow pack helps move peak flow into spring. If snow melts too quickly or comes as rain, the spring peak flow is reduced or disappears."

Another effect of global warming, Swistock said, is that weather has been fluctuating more dramatically, causing scientists to rethink their idea of normal.

"The ping-ponging is nothing new, but the ball has been bouncing a lot more, and in shorter time spans. If you look at 100-plus years of data, weather is much more variable, to the extent there's no such thing as an average year anymore," he said.

Advertise with us

The past 12 months in Pennsylvania have been dry, especially in Erie County and in the eastern part of the state, where up to a foot less rain than normal has fallen, Swistock said. So far this year, Pennsylvania's weather has come from Canada, which tends to bring colder temperatures but less precipitation than southwesterly systems that pick up moisture in the Gulf of Mexico.

"Our creek looks gorgeous," said Bob Shuey of Neshannock Creek Outfitters. "It's just too low for March. We have more of a May flow. If we don't get some steady rain, we'll be in trouble by June. Our water hasn't gone over the banks once so far this year, which is pretty unusual for spring."

"Scary low," is how Glen McConnell of McConnell's Country Store characterized Little Pine Creek in Lycoming County. "we could get a foot of rain and the creek would still be wadable and fishable."

Lakes are low, too, but streams are longer-term systems that reflect what is happening with climate over time, Swistock said.

"They're fed by groundwater. It's their life's blood. If groundwater is low, they may go up quickly after rainfall, but they'll fall quickly, too."

Advertise with us

That is especially true of Western Pennsylvania's freestone streams. Unlike limestone, where fractures and sinkholes allow for the sort of groundwater recharge that promotes consistent flow and cool temperatures regardless of precipitation, freestone bedrock is shale and sandstone, which is tighter and less fractured. That makes for poor groundwater recharge.

Small streams tend to rise and fall faster than larger ones, and urban area streams suffer a double whammy when it comes to fluctuating levels, as a consequence of sprawl.

"There are pretty good correlations between paving and chronically low ground water, since paving doesn't let water into the ground," Swistock said. "It means streams get very low when there's no precipitation and 'flashy' when it does rain. There's no moderation, the way there would be if the ground is allowed to store water. Mountain streams react more gently to rain and are more consistent."

The changing environment is prompting the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission to consider scheduling a different opening day for southeastern Pennsylvania, where streams warm earlier. According to the agency's top cold water biologist, the Fish Commission could move up opening day to early April for some counties, perhaps as soon as next year, while maintaining the traditional mid-April date for most others.

In any case, anglers can adjust to low, clear conditions by downsizing tackle and slowing their presentation, whether they're fishing bait or flies. "You're still matching the hatch. Ypu're just going smaller, especially with your tippet or line.," Sheu said.

Advertise with us

"They're killing them right now on size 16 to 18 early Black and Brown Stoneflies and Blue Wing Oliver nymphs, and bright green and tan Caddis larvae. Some of the attractor patterns like Zug Bugs and Prince Nymphs, or streamers in black, brown or olive work well in early season bait water. They key is natural presentation ... a drag-free drift."

"The water's cold right now," Shuey said, "but without a couple of good soakers a week between now and opening day, there just won't be enough of it."