Deer kill estimates released last week by the Pennsylvania Game Commission do not support the claim of many hunters and state legislators that white-tailed deer herds have been overhunted. Pennsylvania hunters killed an estimated 354,390 deer during the 2005-06 hunting seasons, down from 409,320 whitetails tagged the previous year.
Hunters tagged an estimated 120,500 bucks in 2005, compared to 124,410 one year earlier. Officials said the slight decline was not statistically significant. Since biologists in Pennsylvania and elsewhere regard the buck harvest as the best indicator of overall population trends, the data suggest a stable deer population in the state.
Last year's antlerless harvest did show a significant decline. Hunters took 233,890 antlerless deer in 2005, about 18 percent less than the 284,910 tagged in 2004. Game Commission officials said that decline was anticipated because of lower allocations of antlerless licenses in 2005.
"Going into the year, we expected Wildlife Management Unit antlerless deer harvests to drop in most WMUs because the Board of Game Commissioners approved an overall antlerless deer license allocation that was down 15 percent from the previous year," said Carl Roe, Game Commission executive director.
Button bucks, young males that have not yet grown a set of antlers, made up 23 percent of the antlerless harvest. The button buck component of the antlerless kill has remained constant for many years, indicating that, despite educational efforts by the Game Commission, hunters have made little effort to distinguish between adult female and immature male deer before pulling the trigger.
Cal DuBrock, Game Commission Bureau of Wildlife Management director observed that poor weather played a role in hunter success early in the season.
"Most deer are harvested during the first two days of the rifle season," DuBrock said. "This year [2005], hunters in some areas experienced heavy fog on the ridge tops during opening day, while heavy rain impacted the second day in many areas. As a result, harvests during the first two days were down from 2004-2005."
DuBrock defended the 12-day concurrent season that many hunters and state legislators have criticized.
"The 12-day season increases hunter opportunity, reduces much of the variability in hunter effort associated with shorter seasons and unpredictable weather, and gives our deer management team a more consistent method of monitoring the impacts of the harvest," he said. "Given the relationship of antlerless license allocations to antlerless harvest, the 12-day season is a win-win situation for hunters and managers."
DuBrock pointed out that deer harvest estimates are necessary because of the small number of successful hunters who mail their deer report card to Game Commission headquarters. He said that in 2005, less than 40 percent of hunters complied with the requirement to report their kill with the pre-addressed, no-postage-due card supplied to every license buyer.
According to Dr. Chris Rosenberry, who heads the Game Commission's Deer Management Section, the low reporting rate reduces the precision of harvest estimates but it does not affect the validity of the results.
"The Game Commission's method of estimating deer harvests was designed to account for reporting rates that are less than 100 percent," Rosenberry said.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.