Robert J. Pavuchak, Post-Gazette
STOCKING UP: As her uncle, Gordon Henry, hangs on to her, Jenna Henry, 10, of Waynesburg dumps a bucket filled with trout inot Lake Wilma in Green County. Wednesday the lake was stocked with 2,000 rainbow, brown and a few golden trout. It will be the only stillwater lake in Green County to be stocked with rainbow trout. The trout came from the Reynoldsdale hatchery and the stocking was supervised by Tom Crist, waterways conservation officer.About a dozen helpers, including Jenna and her uncle, followed the truck to help with the stocking.
Click photo for larger image.
As the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission advertises new grant money for youth fishing programs in schools, bass clubs and other venues, it faces a tougher time selling lawmakers on the biggest piece of its junior angler initiative -- a fishing license for 12 to 15 year olds.
"Youth licenses is a volatile issue," said state Rep. Bruce Smith (R-York), the chair of the House Game and Fisheries Committee. "We wouldn't even consider it until after the election. It would be political fodder in a campaign year."
The Fish Commission has tried for decades to implement a junior license, though it has never gotten far. Lawmakers killed the latest proposal two years ago when the Fish Commission tried to include a junior license in the fee increase package. In January, the Fish Commission voted to pursue the concept again and the agency's executive director, Doug Austen, began seeking the support of legislators.
So far, red flags have been raised about cost, how the Fish Commission would handle enforcement of unlicensed youths or provide for kids who couldn't pay.
"We're fleshing these things out now," Fish Commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick said. "One idea is there'd be a third party pool of licenses sponsored by corporations or groups like Trout Unlimited, for kids who can't afford to buy their own. Enforcement is more of a red herring, although it's not like kids don't have to follow regulations now. But we're not looking to bust 12 year olds."
Once a bill is introduced, Smith's committee would probably be the Fish Commission's first hurdle. Smith has indicated he supports the idea of a junior license and would like to see action on legislation before he retires Nov. 30.
"Some things need to be ironed out, including enforcement. In the past, the commission has said it would look the other way. That sends kids a wrong message. If you're going to do that, why even have a license?" he said.
If the commission charges $5 for a youth license -- the figure on the table now -- it says it could make about $2 million a year since it estimates that 272,000 anglers would have to buy one. The revenue would include $3 from the federal government for each license sold, said Tredinnick. That money comes from the tax manufacturers pay on fishing tackle.
Austen has told lawmakers junior license revenues would be funneled into youth programming, including the education grants it is now offering, and to establish more tackle loaner sites for kids. Once the Fish Commission's automated license sale system is in place next year, Tredinnick said, the agency will have a better handle on angler demographics -- something it can use for marketing to young fishermen.
"If the commission can guarantee it would pay for youth programs -- especially urban and suburban kids -- a license is something we'd consider," said state Rep. Marc Gergely (D-White Oak), who serves on Smith's committee. "We just need to be sure the commission's not using kids to pick up the slack from adult license sales being down."
Pennsylvania is not alone among states losing licensed anglers, according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which conducts a census every five years. Most states also are wrestling with a decline in young anglers, though only the states that sell junior licenses -- about a dozen -- are able to track precise numbers. Citing statistics from the National Survey of Hunting, Fishing and Wildlife Recreation, Austen has told lawmakers that, while 41 percent of 6- to 15-year-olds took part in outdoors activities in 1995, just 36 percent were involved in the outdoors in 2000, given the competition from after school sports and video games.
Within the fishing community, reaction to the license concept is mixed.
"There's only so much enrichment a kid can get from an electronic game," said Todd Wehr, who lives in Cranberry Township and runs Bear Run Campground in Portersville. He often fishes with his 9-year-old son Andrew. "If a youth license helps create awareness for the outdoors, it's worth considering. You can spend $5 on a couple of Cokes."
But Pat Rutledge, 16, of Renfrew and a member of the Seneca Valley High School Fly Fishing Club, said it isn't the money, it's the hassle.
"Most kids are so excited about going fishing, they'd probably forget to take their license along. It'd be one more thing they'd have to worry about."
Muskie angler Rick Jackson of Ellwood City and a high school calculus teacher, opposes a youth license.
"Kids don't play enough," he said. "And fishing should be play. I want kids going out and having fun with no restrictions."
Steelhead guide Ken Nulph of Natrona Heights said he would support a $5 license because kids would benefit in other ways.
"I'll never forget the day I had to first buy a fishing license," he said. "It's not on the scale of a driver's license, but I was so proud."
Pennsylvania Steelhead Association president Matt Hryczk said he's "on the fence," but believes the Fish Commission's timing is wrong. "They just raised the adult fees. They'd better wait awhile on this one."
The Fish Commission is taking public comment on the youth license proposal and will continue fine-tuning its plan, although the legislature is the ultimate authority in crafting and voting on a final license measure -- and only after public hearings are held.
"The lame duck session allows enough time for legislation to pass, and it will be my last chance to get a license through before I retire," Smith said. "But the Fish Commission will have to do an outstanding sales job if it's going to earn a youth license."
To comment, visit www.fish.state.pa.us.
CHECK THIS OUT
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission has budgeted $50,000 for the first round of grants in its new program to fund fishing education at schools, clubs and other organizations. Groups have until May 1 to apply for grants of up to $5,000 they can use to purchase equipment and materials, and fund field trips.
Awards will be made by June 1 for funding July 1. For grant criteria and application, visit www.fish.state.pa.us or call 717-705-7835.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.