Deer are not slot machines. You can't legislate how many shall be in the Pennsylvania woods. Yet members of the state's general assembly are endeavoring to do exactly that.
The Pennsylvania Game Commission will be fiscally insolvent early next year if it does not soon get more than the current $20 for each hunting license it sells. But the Game Commission can't simply raise the fee for a license the way your grocer might hike the price of a pound of sirloin. It needs the state House and Senate to approve the fee hike as an act of law.
That's where the deer come in. More legislators than it would be meaningful to name here, from both parties, are being harangued by a few extreme organizations and by hunters who didn't see enough whitetails in the 2005 season. Not fond of being harangued, these legislators have made it clear they will block a license increase unless the Game Commission "fixes the deer problem."
Apparently, if you are the Game Commission you are to interpret your indirect but effective marching orders as: Grow the deer herds to some point at which no legislator's constituents will complain that there are not enough.
Referring to deer as if they were so much sirloin, one legislator accused the Game Commission of "reducing services and disappointing its customers."
Others have been specific, prescribing that the Commission return to the format of brief two- and three-day seasons for antlerless deer if it wants its cash.
That, of course, is their constitutional prerogative. They are, after all, the General Assembly, or at least a part of it. And if this issue were a closed three-way conflict involving nobody except the Game Commission, the state's 800,000 hunters and lawmakers, the impasse would be benign.
But it is not a simple closed conflict, and neither the deer nor the license gridlock is harmless. Mounting scientific proof shows that overabundant deer have gutted extensive tracts of Pennsylvania forests of their biological diversity, their capacity to support other wildlife and their ability to regenerate themselves. Vast stands are stripped of all plants except those deer prefer not to eat. The state's farmers, many teetering on the margins of profitability, lose $70 million in deer damage annually.
About a dozen Pennsylvanians die each year in deer crashes on the highways, and the state leads the nation in new cases of Lyme disease, transmitted by a species of tick whose numbers can rise where deer densities are high.
Today's lawmakers are, in effect, telling the Game Commission that it should not have taken seriously the trust of an earlier legislature, which enacted Title 34, the state's Game and Wildlife Code. Chapter 21 of that Act states: "The Commission shall promulgate such regulations as it deems necessary and appropriate concerning game or wildlife and hunting or furtaking in this Commonwealth, including regulations relating to the protection, preservation and management of game or wildlife and game or wildlife habitat ... "
Five years ago the Game Commission read that phrase and finally accepted responsibility for the degradation caused the state's forest habitats by decades of overabundant deer. It began the first sustained effort to reduce the herds. Now there is growing anecdotal evidence, all untested, that some forests show initial signs of rebirth. Legislators, though, would prefer not to be harangued by "sportsmen" organizations and want to go back to bigger herds. Held hostage is the Pennsylvania Game Commission, punished for the sin of accepting responsibility over immediate gratification.
If the assembly won't allow the Game Commission to exercise the leadership Title 34 extends to it, then the overwhelming majority of voters who are not dissatisfied deer hunters should expect it to provide some leadership of its own. If lawmakers are willing to let the Game Commission go bankrupt, they should offer an alternative way of funding and administering wildlife conservation. As this stands, our state's natural resources are the sure loser either way. If the Commission caves in on deer to get their money, the state's farmlands, forests and forest wildlife all lose. If the Commission stands its ground, is denied its increase, goes broke and withers away, Pennsylvania has no way to run any kind of wildlife program.
Instead of a clear alternative plan for the future of wildlife conservation funding, lawmakers who cannot deliver meaningful improvement on property tax relief, campaign finance reform or the drain of doctors from a litigious state, are trying to legislate how many deer we should have in our woods.
Their power play, void of any and all creative leadership in a time of crisis, is a quite literal example of "passing the buck."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.