Mark Pummell, Associated Press

Two deer stand in a snow-covered field in Mercer County.

Click photo for larger image.

The phrase "The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence" does not apply to deer hunting across state lines, at least not in the Mid-Atlantic region.

Advertise with us

Many Pennsylvania deer hunters claim that deer management policies enacted here in recent years have needlessly reduced the deer herd to levels below their expectations. Some predict the deer kill statistics the Pennsylvania Game Commission will release next month will show a 2005 buck kill below 100,000. They could be right. But Pennsylvania isn't alone.

New York, Maryland, West Virginia and Virginia all report declining buck kills in recent years. Data for 2005 is not yet available in Maryland or Virginia.

The trend is noteworthy because the buck kill is the best index of statewide deer population trends. Bag limits are more conservative on antlered deer and state wildlife departments seldom make radical changes to buck season schedule or length. Within a relatively fixed hunting format, a rising buck kill indicates a growing herd, while a declining take indicates the opposite.

No states are more like Pennsylvania in topography, climate and land use than New York, Maryland, West Virginia and Virginia. The fact that hunters in all those states are tagging fewer bucks demonstrates that reducing deer herds is a goal of wildlife agencies throughout the region, and not unique to Pennsylvania.

New York hunters killed 89,000 bucks in 2005, about equal to 2004, but 18 percent lower than 2003.

Advertise with us

"The recent declines in the deer take were a result of weather, hunting conditions in the field, and specific management actions intended to reduce deer populations from the high levels of 2002 and 2003 and bring populations closer to manageable levels in the many areas where deer were overabundant," New York Department of Environmental Conservation commissioner Denise Sheehan said after the 2004 hunt.

West Virginia's 2005 buck kill of 56,806 was 11 percent below the 2004 mark. As in New York, the decline results from deliberate management actions taken by the West Virginia Department of Natural Resources. "This year's deer harvest demonstrates the overall success of deer herd reduction efforts implemented in counties exceeding their population objectives," DNR director Frank Jezioro said. "We have made significant progress toward balancing the state's deer population with available habitat."

Virginia's 2004 season yielded 105,933 antlered bucks, 9 percent lower than the 2003 harvest. Hunters there killed a total of about 220,000 whitetails of both sexes.

Maryland is interesting, and more like Pennsylvania than many hunters assume. Maryland has extensive forests and public lands in the west, a mix of agriculture and woodland in central counties, and sprawling suburbs to the east. In 2004, Maryland hunters killed 7.5 percent more whitetails (the state also has non-native sika deer in its eastern lowlands) than in 2003.

The increase, however, was due to a deliberate effort to encourage hunters to take more antlerless deer. Maryland hunters killed 59,229 antlerless deer in 2004, a 20 percent jump. But the 34,639 bucks represented an 8 percent decline from the year before. Maryland managers are deliberately reducing the herd because high deer numbers have threatened forest ecology and agriculture.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania buck harvest statistics indicate that the state's deer herd grew rapidly in the 1990s. The hunting season format remained unchanged throughout the span but hunters here killed 20 percent more bucks in 1999 than in 1990. Meanwhile, the 1999 kill of antlerless deer in Pennsylvania (184,000) was 25 percent lower than in 1990, reflecting the protective policies toward antlerless deer at that time.

Since then Pennsylvania antlerless harvests have averaged about 300,000. Despite some claims that more aggressive management has rendered deer numbers "unhuntable," Pennsylvania deer hunters killed nine deer per square mile in 2004, more than any other state in the Northeast.

The growing realization that large deer herds negatively impact a wide range of natural and social values is not confined to Pennsylvania. All across the Great Lakes, Mid-Atlantic and northeastern regions, state wildlife agencies have implemented deliberate management efforts to reduce white-tailed deer populations.

"Deer populations comparable to 2002 levels cannot be maintained without long-term negative consequences such as damage to agriculture, forest regeneration, landscaping or vehicle accidents," said New York DEC's commissioner Sheehan.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.