For hunters eager to mark their calendars with this year's hunting dates, it was the meeting that wasn't. For anyone else it was Pennsylvania's version of "Survivor."

At the Pennsylvania Game Commission get-together last week at the agency's Harrisburg headquarters, commissioners voted to postpone their decision on season schedules and bag limits until April, and then locked in a stalemate to elect a board president that endured five rounds of voting for nearly four hours.

In October, the eight commissioners approved a tentative schedule of seasons but must give it final approval before the proposals become law and can be printed in the digest provided to hunters. A final vote was expected last week, and commissioner Russ Schleiden said earlier that it was important to finalize the dates early so hunters could plan vacations. But Schleiden moved to postpone the decision until April when harvest data from the 2005 deer seasons would be available. His colleagues agreed.

Hunters seem satisfied that the postponement is justified.

Advertise with us

"I believe they did the right thing," said Melody Zullinger, executive director of the Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen's Clubs. "We've always promoted that they use sound science and data to set our seasons and bag limits, and if wildlife management staff feel they need more time to make their final recommendations, then we are very happy to see that our commissioners are willing to wait before making any decisions themselves."

Before they could adjourn, commissioners were bound by state law to elect a new president before the end of this month. Current president John Riley called for nominations and got two -- Roxane Palone (current vice-president) from Waynesburg, Greene County, and Thomas Boop of Sunbury, Northumberland County.

A roll call yielded a 4-4 tie. A second deadlocked roll call led to secret ballots on yellow legal pad paper. Before that vote Riley asked the candidates for a brief appeal as to why each should be chosen.

"This is an election about leadership style and I offer a different style," Boop said. "I would like to be a partner with Mr. Roe (Pennsylvania Game Commission executive director) in taking this agency forward. I think Ms. Palone is identified with past practices, many of which are now being called into question. I also think I am not a polarizing candidate. I offer change and I think the other option does not offer that."

Palone, who has been one of the strongest supporters of deer management programs initiated in Dr. Gary Alt's tenure as the agency's deer leader, told commissioners it was important to remember the agency's broad responsibilities.

Advertise with us

"While I realize that hunters are very important, we also have other constituents," Palone said. "We are the Game Commission, not the deer commission. I think we need to look at the health of the habitats and the forests where all wildlife lives. The vote we make here today will bring the Commission into the 21st century."

When deputy executive director Mike Schmit addressed the board after counting the paper ballots he said, "Mr. President, you're still deadlocked at four to four."

Schleiden lauded Palone's educational and professional qualifications in natural resource management. "She brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise that is beyond most of us on this board," he said.

After two more secret ballot stalemates, Palone suggested the board settle the issue with a coin toss.

"I just feel that we have come this far and it is not fair now to go through the vagaries of a coin toss, so I just can't accept that," Boop said.

Advertise with us

Palone finally ended the impasse by bowing out. "The natural resources belong to all the people, hunting license or not," she said. "In a spirit of cooperation and an act of good faith and trust in leadership I withdraw. I will do my best to fulfill the trust you have bestowed on me as vice-president."

Prior to the deadlock, commissioners did address a number of agenda items. They gave preliminary approval of the atlatl as a legal tool for hunting deer, legalized the use of electronic "locator" collars to aid in finding hunting dogs, and moved to acquire 450 acres of new state game lands in Centre, Erie and Huntingdon counties.