The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission will begin the process of over-hauling muskie creel, size and season limits at its winter board meeting tomorrow and Tuesday in Harrisburg. The board also will consider lifting seasons on northern pike and revamping its management of timber rattlesnakes, copperheads and other reptiles.

For muskie management, two options are on the table, though both would remove the season on muskie fishing, so that harvesting would be allowed year-round.

One proposal calls for creel limits of one a day, at least 36 inches, except on half a dozen "trophy" lakes that would have 45-inch minimums. They would include Lake Arthur (Butler County), Rose Valley Lake (Lycoming County), Cowanesque Reservoir (Tioga County), Marsh Creek Lake (Chester County), Susquehanna River (Fabridam to 1.3 miles downstream) and Loyalhanna Lake (Westmoreland County).

The proposed alternative is a 40-inch minimum on all inland waters, statewide, and no special regulation waters. Currently, anglers can harvest two muskie a day of at least 30 inches, from mid-June through mid-March.

Advertise with us

Although anglers in a muskie focus group helped the commission craft the proposed changes, not all muskie specialists support removing the season.

"Handling big females during the spawn can harm them, even when they are released," said muskie guide Howard Wagner of Fombell near Zelienople. "Cleaner water has put natural reproduction on the upswing, something the commission must not know. There's a ton of natural reproduction up around Foxburg [on the Allegheny] and elsewhere."

Wagner recently released a 53-inch muskie in the middle Allegheny River near Oil City and a 54 1/2 incher in the same general area four years ago. As for size limits, he said a 40-inch minimum is the better of the two options. "Once a muskie hits 40 inches, its chances of reaching 50 are good anyway," he said, "although there's too much harvesting of 50-inch fish."

As for pike and pickerel changes, the board also will consider removing seasons on northern pike and pickerel. Size and creel limits would remain unchanged for pike, while those for pickerel would go to four a day, at least 18 inches, from the current six a day of at least 15 inches.

All proposed changes, which we go into effect in 2007, would be put out for public comment before a final board vote is taken later this year.

Advertise with us

Though a vote isn't expected until summer, the board is being asked to allow for additional public comment on a package of changes aimed at protecting almost two dozen species of herptefauna, including the timber rattlesnake and the northern copperhead They and the eastern massassaugua rattlesnake comprise the state's three venomous snake species.

The massassaugua is endangered and therefore off-limits to hunters. But timber rattlesnakes and copperheads can still be hunted despite concerns that wanton killing, over-collection by hobbyists and loss of habitat have caused a drop in their numbers.

In other northeast and Midwest states, timber rattlesnakes are rare, endangered or extirpated, and they may be heading that way in Pennsylvania, where they are listed as a candidate species. Though harvesting of timbers rattlesnakes is limited to just one a year with special permitting, the commission has proposed putting a 42-inch size minimum on the snakes to protect females.

It also is proposing that special permits be issued for copperheads and that "taking" be reduced from two to one a day. The commission is considering tighter regulation of hobbyists and breeders, and a ban on snake sacking contests, which are still popular in some rural areas. Snake hunting fees would go from $5 to $50 for individuals and from $25 to $100 for group hunts. The commission sells more than 1,180 snake hunting permits a year.

Other changes in reptile and amphibian management include reducing daily creel limits on green frogs to 10 and bullfrogs to 15. That is half the current limit on each.

Advertise with us

Lou Krasky, Associated Press

The Fish and Boat Commission is considering a proposal that would limit the taking of copperheads from two to one a day and a ban on snake sacking contests.

Click photo for larger image.More Coverage:

Youth fishing license considered

Fishing Notebook: Washington show Feb. 2-5

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.