The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection are expected to decide by March whether to permit continued sand and gravel dredging on the Allegheny and Ohio rivers with possible new restrictions.
The concern is over mussels that have been found in the Allegheny River. According to biologist Tom Proch, DEP's mussels and dredging expert, the problem is a lack of knowledge.
Though the dredging industry funded a $1.5 million environmental impact study -- the first in 10 years -- as required in the permitting process, the mussel survey portion covered just one-tenth of one percent of the 100 miles of the rivers where dredging is allowed That is according to Allan Percha, an engineer with the London-based Hanson America, formerly known as Pioneer Mid-Atlantic Inc., one of three sand and gravel companies seeking permits.
"We don't require monumental surveys; they're all site specific," Proch said. "We don't have a good handle on how significant mussel resources are but we have committees working on trying to come up with a satisfactory way to survey and protect them, and allow dredging to continue."
Environmentalists challenged DEP in the last permit round five years ago to change its requirements for collecting mussel data. That resulted in DEP's establishing a work group to review new survey protocols. "We need to look at three things -- how many species there are, how abundant they are and how big an area they occupy," Proch said.
Proch estimates there are at least 30 types of mussels in the Allegheny River, half as many on the navigational pool from Point State Park to East Brady, and fewer on the Ohio River.
The discovery of three federally endangered Northern Riffleshell and Clubshell mussels in pool eight near Templeton, which is northeast of Butler, within the past seven years raised red flags among environmentalists and the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission. Though there are dredging restrictions on parts of pool eight and a moratorium on all of pool six near Kittanning, the Fish Commission last year sought an injunction against dredging in all of pool eight but failed, said agency spokesman Dan Tredinnick, in the absence of comprehensive mussel data.
"We kind of said, 'We need this whole area to be off limits,' but we didn't have the data to be site specific," Tredinnick said. "Although we're not the permitting agency -- we're advisers -- if we're going to advise, we need good data."
The Fish Commission has begun to move closer to that goal.
Earlier this month, it received $200,000 from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service for a two-year mussel mapping project on the lower Allegheny River. The mapping will be helping to establish a public-private sector task force to explore ways in which data can be better collected on mussels and other river species, Tredinnick said. The $400,000 in funding for the work will come from DEP's Clean Water Fund over five years.
"Mussels may be invisible to most folks, including anglers," Tredinnick said. "But if you don't protect them they're gone, and with them a critical link in the whole chain of natural resources."
The Fish Commission has characterized mussels as among the most imperiled aquatic animals in North America. As filter feeders, they help to keep water clean. They are hard to survey because it typically requires scuba divers digging into the riverbed by hand.
Theories differ as to why Northern Riffleshells and Clubshells were found at Templeton, but Proch believes they made their way down from the free-flowing Allegheny River near Tionesta where huge numbers of the same species have been documented. Mussels move by attaching themselves to the gill plates, fins or other body parts of "host" fish, such as darters, Proch said.
While more endangered mussels could turn up in future surveys, Proch said three "waifs" aren't enough for mussels to colonize and repopulate. Hundreds of years ago, there were abundant riffleshell mussels in the lower Allegheny River, but they died off from water pollution and because of locks and dams.
"Navigational pools aren't their preferred habitat. As their name implies, they prefer riffles and shallow water," Proch said.
While the discovery of endangered mussels has cast new focus on the river's ecosystem, Proch said the existence of large numbers of common mussel species could have even greater impact, though it could take years and ultimately millions of dollars to explore.
"We don't get real excited about a few animals in a few square feet," he said. "But if we see a lot of animals in a quarter mile stretch of river, that's important stuff. It shows good habitat and that's what you have to protect.
"If there are enough diversity of species and enough animals over a big enough area, that could be enough to halt dredging."
Hanson America and others seeking permits, including Tri-State River Products Inc and Glacial Sand and Gravel, are required to survey for mussels before dredging specific locations, which are typically less than a mile. Though aggregate also can be mined, the glacial substrate of Western Pennsylvania rivers yields a higher quality product, at least for road construction material, Percha said.
While river aggregate and sand can sell for $6 or more a ton, dredgers pay the Fish Commission just 30 cents for every ton they extract. Last year, Tredinnick said, that amounted to $750,000.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.