Robert F. Bukaty, Associated Press

The debate is whether recent hunting regulations are responsible for low deer numbers in certain areas of the state, or if the low numbers are a result of habitat issues.By Ben Moyer

Preliminary results from a Pennsylvania Game Commission study do not support the claim from some sportsmen groups that more liberal hunting regulations are causing an overkill of the state's deer herds.

One year ago, Game Commission biologists captured and placed radio-transmitter collars on 64 female antlerless deer on the Sproul State Forest in north central Pennsylvania. As a comparison, 41 antlerless deer were also captured and collared on the Tuscarora State Forest in the state's south central ridges.

Advertise with us

In the ensuing year biologists monitored deer by radio signals to document their movements, home ranges and mortality. Some deer died, some lost their collars and some collars may have stopped working. At the start of the hunting seasons, 55 deer were still "on the air" in the Sproul study area. At Tuscarora, 39 deer were still transmitting signals as the season began.

After the 2005 hunting seasons, which included six weeks of archery hunting, a one-week October muzzleloader season, a three-day firearms hunt for junior and senior hunters, and a two-week statewide firearms season, hunters were known to have killed only five of the available 55 marked deer on the Sproul State Forest (9 percent) and nine of 39 at Tuscarora (23 percent). A small number of deer remain unaccounted for.

Biologists and deer experts say those rates of harvest, especially at Sproul State Forest, are far below rates needed to control deer populations through hunting. But last summer the Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania (USP) sued the Game Commission and the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources in Commonwealth Court for instituting policies they believe have reduced deer populations to "unhuntable" levels.

"The Pennsylvania Game Commission has initiated and continues to espouse a massive deer reduction plan that has severely reduced the number of deer in Pennsylvania," Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania Board Chairman Greg Levengood said. "We need to stop the killing now. Simply reducing the doe permit allocation is too little too late and, quite frankly, the Game Commission cannot absorb the loss in revenue. A better way for all concerned is to reduce the number of days that gun hunters are allowed to pursue antlerless deer in the regular firearms season."

Professional managers who know the Sproul State Forest well don't think recent hunting regulations are responsible for low deer numbers, and the study supports their view.

Advertise with us

"Basically this is a habitat issue," said Doug D' Amore, Department of Conservation and Natural Resources district forester on the Sproul State Forest. "We are not seeing any real habitat recovery here yet and there is not much here for deer to eat. We know from the age composition of deer taken here that we have a major reproduction problem. Of all deer taken by hunters here, 70 percent were adults and 30 percent juveniles. That's telling us that for whatever reason, poor habitat, predation, we are not getting good recruitment.

"The first sign of habitat recovery is blackberry coming back into the understory and we're not seeing it here yet. We put a fence up on a 300-acre failed clearcut. Inside the fence you need a blood transfusion after you walk through the blackberry briars. Outside all we have are the trees we planted inside plastic tubes to protect them from browsing. It looks like a cemetery. Until this habitat recovers from overbrowsing, I think we're just going to be in a cycle where nobody is happy.

"I believe you could ban doe season and it would not make any difference because hunting is not limiting this herd, habitat is."

Biologists believe the higher kill rate on the Tuscarora study area is due to better access for hunters there. D'Amore said DCNR had opened additional forest roads during the season to facilitate access on the Sproul forest as well.

"Altogether we opened 29 road sections to hunters. We had more miles of road open on the Sproul State Forest than are in the entire Pennsylvania Turnpike system," D'Amore said.

Advertise with us

He added that the road system does not necessarily lead to areas where deer seek cover.

"The roads here are all on top of the ridges," D'Amore said. "There's not much access down into the deep hollows and the deer are going into the hollows. I hunted a couple of days and saw no hunter tracks in the snow except for two guys who came in by canoe on the West Branch. They camped at the mouth of a creek and you could see two drag marks where they dragged deer into camp."

Game Commission press secretary Jerry Feaser said it was too early to tell if the Game Commission would consider the results of the antlerless deer mortality study when it finalizes hunting regulations for 2006 later this month.

"Some of the deer that aren't accounted for may have been killed by hunters but not reported, or they may have wandered into remote places where we can't pick up their signals," Feaser said. "Biologists will fly over the area in the coming weeks to check for those deer, and then brief commissioners at the January meeting."

Feaser said hunters were encouraged to shoot deer marked with collars.

Advertise with us

"Hunter mortality is part of the study," he said. "We tried through our publications and news releases to assure hunters that the marked deer were legal game."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.