Pennsylvania needs hunters to manage its deer herd. That means hunting will continue to enjoy a relevant niche in Pennsylvania's environmental, economic and recreational landscape.

The important question is: How many hunters does the state really need to accomplish deer management goals?

Some critics of more aggressive deer management argue that trimming the deer herd will cause hunters to quit, crippling the Pennsylvania Game Commission's ability to manage populations and ultimately allowing large herds to return.

The argument seems logical on the surface but the facts don't support its dire prediction. Studies by Responsive Management, a natural resource consulting firm that has done sociological research on hunter motivations in numerous states, including Pennsylvania, determined that the availability of game has little influence on the personal decision to hunt. Instead, the research found that constraints on free time, and loss of access to a social network of other hunters were the key factors that cause some hunters to quit.

Advertise with us

"Note these are all sociological constraints, not resource constraints," Responsive Management executive director Mark Duda said.

Hunting and killing antlerless females -- does -- is the only practical way of managing the size of a deer population. Yet, only about half of Pennsylvania's approximately 900,000 deer hunters buy at least one antlerless license each year. Consequently, only about 450,000 hunters participate in deer herd management. Recent larger allocations of one million or more licenses have sold out because some hunters -- the most ardent deer herd managers -- buy more than one.

The remaining half of those who hunt antlered bucks only are perfectly entitled to enjoy their hunting recreation as they choose. They contribute to the Game Commission's revenue by purchasing a general license and they are part of Pennsylvania's hunting heritage and culture, but they do not play a role in deer herd management.

Readers may be surprised to learn that they need look no further than the Game Commission's executive office to find a sportsman who enjoys hunting recreation but does not, in the field, personally participate in deer herd management.

In a recent interview, Game Commission executive director Vern Ross confirmed that he has never killed a doe.

Advertise with us

"I never had to," Ross said. "I've always gotten a buck. Over the years I've killed 41 bucks in Pennsylvania."

Ross said he's chosen to continue his streak of bucks-only hunting, even though Pennsylvania's current regulations allow hunters to take multiple does with appropriate licenses, plus an antlered buck.

"One deer is plenty for us in a year," Ross said. "I haven't killed a trout in 30 years of fishing and I haven't killed a doe yet. It's not off my radar screen as a hunter, but it's a personal choice I've made to this point."

Ross added that he has accompanied young first-time hunters into the woods and allowed them the opportunity to take a doe.

Ross will retire from the Game Commission at the end of December after seven years at the agency's helm. Prior to his service at the Game Commission he was Sportsman Advisor to Governor Tom Ridge and executive director of the Governor's Sportsman Advisory Council. Ross is also an ardent and accomplished fly fisherman.

Advertise with us

Hopefully, he'll have more free time to enjoy hunting and fishing at his Cameron County camp for many years to come. His chosen hunting career, however, provides high-profile proof that a significant loss of hunter numbers will not necessarily compromise our ability to manage the deer herd.

Keep hunting Vern. Congratulations on your retirement, and thank you for your service to Pennsylvania's wildlife and outdoor heritage.